Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them
by Zigurd on Monday September 22, 2014 @09:35AM
(#8350469)
In principle, Xamarin Forms should enable many common UI elements, like list views, to be coded cross-platform. In practice, I wonder if that holds up well w.r.t. hooking the list views up to the model behind them. But, nonetheless, Xamamrin supports both cross-platform and native UI elements, which seems like a practical approach.
All that said, I would normally advise a client not only to have native code, but also large amounts of native design for their main platform targets. Lots of Android apps suffer from port-itis. Transliterating an iOS implementation inevitably makes for a lackluster Android app that underutilizes Android modularity features among other things Android does well.
Except this is not possible, as you have to recode the UI for each device anyway.
So just go C++, or any other language with compilers that can target C, and do as little as possible in the UI part.
Companies like Dropbox are following this approach.