News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by pjmlp on Monday September 22, 2014 @03:14AM (#8349588)
> what does .net platform offer over the jvm?

Some builtin features that Sun/Oracle leave for third parties.

- It always JITs. Either at runtime (JIT on load) or at installation time (NGEN).

- Windows Phone 8 .NET applications are compiled to native code, to an executable format called MDIL. Native code with symbols left for linking.

- A new JIT in the works that offers SIMD instructions

- A native compiler for static binaries based on the Visual C++ backend (.NET Native)

- Value types (In discussion for Java 9)

- Flat arrays

- Native interop (JNI sucks, Oracle also recognized this)

- Real generics.

Regarding the first issues, Java also offers them, but you have to buy a commercial JVM as the standard Oracle tooling doesn't offer such features. There is the Graal/Substracte VM at Oracle Research, but who knows when integration will happen.

Regarding the last issues, they were discussed at JVM Language Summit 2014. Some of them might be fixed in Java 9 timeframe.

http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/community/jlss...

Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by srean on Monday September 22, 2014 @04:29AM (#8349726)
JVM's garbage collector and JIT are better, they have benefited from several more years of development. But CLR offers so many other advantages (in particular interoperation with C, SIMD, and reified generics) that I lament that CLR is Windows only. Yes, I know Mono exists, my lament remains.

(I know, I should be using D, you say)

Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by x0x0 on Monday September 22, 2014 @04:11AM (#8349682)
Hmm.

what is a flat array?

By value type, you mean assignment causes deep copy instead of reference copy?

What is the advantage of a static binary over just shipping the jvm (which you are certainly allowed to do)? I guess I could see it if you are writing end-user software, but the jvm is pretty much server-software and devtools at this point.

What do you mean it always jits? So does the jvm unless I misunderstand what you mean by jit.

simd is beginning to make its way into java, but numerics are not the jvm's strong spot. I didn't think they where for c# either. Is this incorrect?

And yeah, jni is fucking awful.

Real generics would be nice.

Thanks for your answer.

Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by pjmlp on Monday September 22, 2014 @04:50AM (#8349762)
> what is a flat array?

In multidimensional arrays you do one single allocation instead of n times m time k times ... allocations.

You can fake this in Java by allocating one major block and doing the math for the respective cell yourself but it is cumbersome.

> What is the advantage of a static binary over just shipping the jvm

The same as doing coding in C and similar languages. Guess one of the reasons why Java lost the desktop.

> What do you mean it always jits?

There isn't any interpretation going on. On most JVMs you need to set execution threshold to zero to achieve similar behavior.

On most JVMs, it is a two step process as they start interpreting and only hot methods (this is customizable on most) get JITted.

> simd is beginning to make its way into java

It is still not clear if it will make it into Java 9 timeframe.

> Is this incorrect?

Yes, as C# as managed to place itself as "good enough C++" on the Windows world, for many use cases.

Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by x0x0 on Monday September 22, 2014 @06:08AM (#8349916)
Thank you.

I've shipped single jar programs -- it's pretty simple to repack everything -- and I believe (but am not 100%) that we included the jvm in there, so it can be done. At the expense of a 100+m download, but for our use case, that was not an issue.

Have you seen performance improvements from forcing always jit? I've played with similar settings and only really found them useful for benchmarking.

I'm surprised you're seeing c# for numerics on windows; I thought there wasn't much besides games that needs to be local and isn't written in c++ these days, either for performance or because the codebase is old. I work on ml programs, mostly c++ and java.

Re:Xamarin makes me sad, here is my message to them by pjmlp on Monday September 22, 2014 @07:20AM (#8350085)
> I'm surprised you're seeing c# for numerics on windows;

Bioinformatics