I don't agree with Orin Kerr on this, but I'm willing to accept that he's likely seen things about the day-to-day business of law enforcement that I just don't understand. It's worth us spending at least a few moments entertaining the thought that maybe we are the naive ones.
I'm sorry, but no, no, no. I'm perfectly clear on what exactly this move by Apple enables, which is that more criminals -- some horrible -- will go free.
But context is important here:
1. By the same token, more innocent people who never should have been charged will also go free.
2. Giving up many of our constitutional rights would also result in more criminals being apprehended, but few of us would do that, because we understand the importance of these rights for our system of government. Why is this any different?
3. Most importantly, many of us would be much more amenable to a compromise here if the government hadn't horribly abused their power over the past 15-20 years. Prosecutorial misconduct and out-of-control blackops agencies have become such a problem that almost any solution is worth consideration. You think Apple would have done this if our government had a reputation for fairly using its power?
So no, not falling for the "we've seen things you kids would never understand" ploy -- that's been pulled on us before. It's not working this time.
But he has been exposed to highly unusual circumstances with a high bias.
Sorry, it's more likely he's just vested in the current (not-privacy-respecting) system of governance. One which has major drawbacks for many folks who are pushing the envelope or who just happen to be on the wrong side of one of the many folks who have access to the government's powers.
This article is very disturbing.
Exactly. Our government is as overbearing and oppressive as it's been in a very long time. I read somewhere that judges approve something like 99% of the search warrants presented to them. They no longer serve as a check on law enforcement.
I'd love to hear otherwise, to hear how judges are doing a good job balancing the interests of people against the interests of law enforcement.
Consider that the police know what warrants a judge is likely to approve and which he's likely to turn down. Over time, police departments will learn to submit the warrants they can get approved and not bother wasting a judge's time with warrants that won't be approved.
So very high approval rates do not necessarily signal the loss of the judge's ability or willingness to check police power. Just that everybody involved is doing their jobs as professionals in their domain.
Your argument is that the approval rate could be 99% legitimately. Even if true it doesn't actually provide any evidence that judges are not acting as a rubber stamp, it only attempts to discount some evidence in favor of it. Moreover, the fact that the approval rate is 99% is still evidence that judges are not being very critical in approving warrants. The high rate makes it statistically more likely that judges are approving warrants uncritically than would be the case if the rate was lower.
No it is not.
> The high rate makes it statistically more likely that judges are approving warrants uncritically than would be the case if the rate was lower.
As I said in another sub-thread, you are going to have to explain the statistics involved if you want to make an argument from them. Otherwise you are just being circular. You cannot expect a statement to be its own proof.
Yes it is. There is no question that it is evidence, so you can only be questioning whether the evidence supports the proposition. You want a mathematical proof? OK. Without knowing the percentage of approved warrants we can't exclude the possibility that exactly zero warrants were approved, which would be a hard disproof of the proposition that judges are uncritically approving warrants. Discovering that the percentage is nonzero eliminates the possibility that it is 0%, which increases the probability that the proposition is correct. Continuing by induction, with each warrant not approved the possibility that it was approved uncritically is eliminated, whereas with each warrant approved the possibility that it was approved uncritically is retained. So the higher the percentage of approved warrants the more it supports the proposition that they are being approved uncritically. QED.
What you're arguing is that it's weak evidence. It could be that there were many legitimate warrants requested and few illegitimate ones. But that's a weak argument unless you can present some contrary evidence for the opposite position. All you're doing is claiming that the proposition hasn't been strongly proved, not proving it incorrect.
Generally speaking, we mean 'critical' to involve the weighing of a decision against an ethical standard. Assuming the standard isn't changing, we would expect an equilibrium to emerge where the parties involved would come to understand the standard, especially given that the warrant process is not adversarial. So there's no reason not to expect the approval rate to settle at close to 100%, with the few denials being law enforcement attempts to skirt the boundaries.
Anything less than a very high rate would indicate that the standards are inconsistent or are being inconsistently applied. The only reason I can see to be inconsistent is to game statistics like this one that seem to mean more to certain people than they actually do.
There is nothing circular about it. There is no requirement to exclude other evidence. Regardless of what other evidence exists, discovering that there is a very high approval rate makes it more likely that warrants are approved uncritically than it was before the approval rate was known.
> Assuming the standard isn't changing, we would expect an equilibrium to emerge where the parties involved would come to understand the standard, especially given that the warrant process is not adversarial. So there's no reason not to expect the approval rate to settle at close to 100%, with the few denials being law enforcement attempts to skirt the boundaries.
The fact that the process is not adversarial only makes it more likely that judges are approving warrants they shouldn't be. Moreover, prosecutors have every incentive to try to "skirt the boundaries" as often as possible, unless the boundaries are so broad they don't need to be skirted.
> Anything less than a very high rate would indicate that the standards are inconsistent or are being inconsistently applied.
Or that prosecutors are continually testing the fences as they have every incentive to do.
How'd this get from "I read somewhere" to "fact"?
Outright convictions for everything the prosecution charged are also not too common, but that the prosecutor deems something illegal and grave enough to charge, the court concurs by opening proceedings, and then in the trial everything falls completely apart basically only happens when the trial brings a complete surprise with it.
And most of those times the "complete surprise" is just a key witness refusing to testify or not remembering anymore (as it happens too often in domestic abuse cases).
Where? Most sources I can find (usually focussing on individual departments) indicate rejected warrants applications aren't tracked, so there would likely be no basis for this conclusion.
Even if it was true, it would likely be misleading -- the fact that a warrant is approved doesn't mean its approved with the scope originally sought. Most sources I've seen also suggest that while rejections are uncommon, limiting the scope of the warrant is not.
Just using the FISA numbers as a starting point for discussion, I'm not ready to believe that 11 requests denied and 33,942 warrants issued is something that makes sense. I'd bet that the Russian Parliament is less of a rubber stamp on Putin. :)
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intellige...
> How is the public interest served by a policy that only thwarts lawful search warrants?
Perhaps the answer is that judges act as rubber stamps now, authorizing way too many search warrants. The author assumes that the judges are fairly applying the 4th amendment.