In another 20 years time, what is considered good web design will probably be totally different anyway.
I still remember a great Joel on Software article where Spolsky talks about "things that just aren't possible on the web" like red underlines for misspelled words. We get that now from the browser in text controls, but even if we didn't, it would be pretty trivial.
Progress!
Java applets were a lot less common. Macromedia's Flash 5/MX took over that Java applet marketshare around 2000.
For a content page, you should absolutely not split content, except on major logical boundaries (e.g., chapters or larger sections within a book).
A site I refer to with great frequency is the Project Gutenberg copy of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations. This packs over 1,000 pages of printed text on a single web page.
It's actually pretty usable, and it makes searching for text a lot easier than separate pages.
That website is firmly optimised for large screens, certainly not phones. It’s not even a little bit responsive. And it still manages to have too long line-lengths (though I do like it’s hierarchy and use of white space).
I think this is outdated. Longer homepages—ones that scroll down and appropriately present the content with good flow, organization, and spacing—are just fine. The Docker homepage[1], for example, is not afraid of the scroll bar.
I only bring this up because I think the opposite idea of trying to cram everything above the fold or spread it out across 12 micro-pages creates even more problems.
[1] https://www.docker.com/