News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by manifesto on Saturday September 20, 2014 @09:36AM (#8344473)
A reminder: the petition https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/remove-united-stat... has not been responded yet, after more than one and a half years.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by bdcravens on Saturday September 20, 2014 @02:40PM (#8345226)
What would the response be? The petition says to remove Ortiz. Not investigate. Not chastise. Not start hearings.

That's a pretty binary decision. A website survey, that could easily be gamed, that has fewer signatures than the population of a random small city, is supposed to result in completely bypassing the USC?

Most would agree with the sentiment, but the petition was failed from the moment the creator hit Submit.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by neverminder on Saturday September 20, 2014 @10:05AM (#8344511)
Indeed, I remember signing this back then. White House seems to be dodging responses to certain petitions that have received enough signatures: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/08/13...
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by jbuzbee on Saturday September 20, 2014 @10:30AM (#8344570)
The administration only responds to trivial petitions or petitions that already side with their policy. Typical. Obama claims that his is the "Most transparent administration ever"

http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/283335-obam...

Journalists loudly disagree:

http://gazette.com/journalists-criticize-white-house-for-sec...

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by freakonom on Saturday September 20, 2014 @11:33AM (#8344724)
You could actually argue that handling of these petitions is very transparent: petition text goes in, petition text comes out, and there's a null transform in the middle.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by cheald on Saturday September 20, 2014 @10:17AM (#8344538)
Has Obama's White House ever responded significantly to any petition made through that system?

It's a pressure valve designed to bleed off discontent, not an actual channel for affecting change.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by lambdapower on Saturday September 20, 2014 @10:28AM (#8344565)
My favorite petition came right after a few of the early responses, titled "We demand a vapid, condescending, meaningless, politically safe response to this petition."

I can't find it on the petition site anymore.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:18PM (#8344841)
Can you really blame the guy for being politically safe? I know it sucks but it is a war of inches.

Things change with the backing of the people. The Republicans know this well and uses that reaction. They are fundamentally populist (whether you agree with them or not, they have skill here).

Absolute justice gives way to a triage. Fundamentally with out that triage nothing gets treated. It is an unfortunate reality.

It will only change, if how we work is rethought. These are the scope of the actions available in our game. The pattern has been replicated consistently through similar models in history.

It could very easily become robbing Peter to pay Paul.

*edit Getting downvote....sigh.... I realize it is an unpopular opinion but it is a consistent pattern for republics through out human history. Please offer me a counter example to facilitate debate if you disagree.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by autokad on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:35PM (#8344887)
i disagree. for one thing, he's in his 2nd term, there is no 'war of inches' to lose. when he has a political agenda, nothing stops him from shoving it through no matter what. for stuff he cares two licks about but knows his voters care about, he just retorts 'the republicans wont let me'.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @01:04PM (#8344953)
Would it not be irresponsible to poison the political landscape for the next candidate?
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by thaumaturgy on Saturday September 20, 2014 @03:12PM (#8345313)
He already has; odds are that he has sunk any chances of a Democratic presidential victory in 2016. A significant portion of the base that rallied for his presidency two terms in a row are disillusioned with the government they got.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by JetSpiegel on Saturday September 20, 2014 @03:29PM (#8345362)
I thought Nobel prize winners should be willing to make sacrifices for the common good.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @04:13PM (#8345463)
That statement cuts both ways... If it is a choice between good and evil, the obvious moral choice is good. It is only a moral decision when it is between two evils.

Determining the lesser and potentially sacrificing for the common good. This the primary responsibly of any leader responsible for strategic decision making.

As you said, this means making sacrifices for the common good.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by MCRed on Saturday September 20, 2014 @05:41PM (#8345664)
No, good and evil are clear choices. Irradiating the flying public, taking pornographic pictures or molesting children are all evil, and Obama could have stopped that.

Domestic spying, Obama could have stopped it.

Hell closing guantanamo, he didn't even do that. And that's a straight up operation in violation of the constitution top to bottom.

We may have the choice between two evils at election time, but no politician is forced to choose evil.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @05:58PM (#8345701)
Okay here is an example. Enigma machine in WW2. Do you let a city get bombed and lose 10k lives or reveal that you have broken a code and lose the war?

How do you act and why?

[deleted]
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @07:13PM (#8345838)
I'd argue it would not be an 'easy' decision.

Numbers could be a criteria, but either way this is where moral philosophy really comes into play. I am disturbed at times how black and white many people see these decision.

Greater good is a perspective and it like anything else is we do...uncertain.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by mijoharas on Saturday September 20, 2014 @07:13PM (#8345843)
> Irradiating the flying public, taking pornographic pictures or molesting children are all evil, and Obama could have stopped that.

Sorry, what are you talking about?

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by Kliment on Sunday September 21, 2014 @04:34AM (#8346659)
I'd venture a guess it's the TSA, with the backscatter machines (radiation), millimeter wave machines (pornographic pictures - not really but definitely privacy-invading) and groping people inappropriately, including children all having been or still being policy during the Obama administration's operation, and the president having direct control over the TSA.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @07:22PM (#8345857)
This is actually a perfect microcosm of the subject in question :-)

Knowing the community and how they feel about these hot button issues I gain no reputation by making a point against the grain. In fact I have lost reputation...

Hahaha... If I had took my own advice and applied more PR(triage) or acted as a populist. Then would I not have gained votes instead of lost? Even if the position was invalid or it was not what I believed?

This is precisely the deficit that has held back democratic culture for centuries. It is our greatest weakness.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by bmelton on Saturday September 20, 2014 @02:03PM (#8345125)
Subscribe to the Org For Action mailing list and receive a few of those, and you'll see how fruitless that argument really is.

Yes, the president should stay somewhat politically neutral, lest he alienate roughly half of the population. That doesn't mean the responses can't be neutral.

Considering the emails that from from the president, his wife, and his supporters are routinely filled with provocative, if not downright incendiary statements, it's kind of silly that his responses (where applicable) are so entirely vapid on whitehouse.gov.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @02:14PM (#8345158)
I am not advocating neutrality. I am advocating avoiding snares.

Policy change is fundamentally dependant on the organization of the people. It is that organization that makes it a political reality.

A Presidents ability is constrained by this dynamic and it is a good thing! It keeps power in check.

The people enable absolute justice not the President. They are the arbitrators of liberty.

Whether you agree with the institutions actions or not there is a greater balance to be struck.

* edit I am concerned I did not address your point on vapid responses enough.

I just think it is a constant political liability and it would be better off if every senator, party, legislator ..etc could reply to the question. Then the people could get behind an idea to make it a political reality.

* edit 2 Also checked out Org For Action. I would guess that perhaps it is a different audience and it is not using the Presidential position? I do see your point. Perhaps it is simply different chains of command and therefore policy?

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by ninguem2 on Saturday September 20, 2014 @11:01AM (#8344642)
I think the criticism that they don't normally respond to petitions is valid so I don't really want to point this out but they did respond to the petition to allow cellphone unlocking and that has affected change. Of course, the petition wasn't the only cause of the change.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by cheald on Saturday September 20, 2014 @11:39AM (#8344740)
That's actually really interesting. The cynic in me wants to say "well, it was happening anyhow, so they capitalized on it", but I wonder how much of an impact that petition actually had.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by bjelkeman-again on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:18PM (#8344843)
It is the type of thing a politician gets irritated too by and it isn't really controversial from the voters point of view, so it gets done.

In the EU the politicians at EU level pushed through max roaming charges for SMS messages, whilst leaving data roaming rates ludicrously high. My take on it was that the politicians weren't using data so they only dealt with what was painful for them on an individual level.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by McDoku on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:21PM (#8344849)
Mountains of data analysis and it probably influences the polling. I mean it also likely gets read and discussed.

Whether it is a political realistic or not is another matter entirely.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by yoyar on Saturday September 20, 2014 @10:28AM (#8344563)
^ This
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by idlewords on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:10PM (#8344825)
Better start a petition to fix that!
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by joering2 on Saturday September 20, 2014 @12:06PM (#8344806)
Why are you reminding about this? Isn't it obvious, 6 years later, that entire Obama Administration is a charade?? Why would it be any different when it comes to petitions.whitehouse?

Don't mind the case of obvious abuse of power and long arm of the gov that destroyed the life of a young and basically innocent man.... here look at this one, nice and thoroughly answered:

https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/release-recipe-hon...

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by ivanca on Saturday September 20, 2014 @01:50PM (#8345086)
I'm afraid you are right. "After 911 we tortured some folks but lets not be sanctimonious about the tough job the tortures had" is by far the worst thing any president (or dictator) has ever say in a public speech.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by dredmorbius on Saturday September 20, 2014 @11:49PM (#8346224)
Responses of the Obama administration to online petitions has been ... less than encouraging.

However: the administration created the petitions process, and petitions are online. What has and hasn't been responded to is a matter of public record.

If, at some point, another political party (or even a different administration of the same party) comes into power, and changes this in any significant way (including, possibly, improving the system, though I suspect it might go the other way) will be notable.

Regardless of the follow-through, Obama did set a precedent.

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by rweba on Saturday September 20, 2014 @01:40PM (#8345053)
The current threshold is 100,000 and the petition only has 61,040 votes.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by bdcravens on Saturday September 20, 2014 @02:30PM (#8345200)
Doesn't apply to petitions prior to the change. That page says "SIGNATURES NEEDED BY FEBRUARY 11, 2013 TO REACH GOAL OF 25,000"

(though it's moot anyways, given the usual responses to these surveys)

Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by ninv on Saturday September 20, 2014 @01:55PM (#8345103)
This petition is useless. She was merely following the orders, a puppet.
Re:FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz by WalterSear on Saturday September 20, 2014 @04:51PM (#8345557)
She was advancing her career.