In the actual world things don't have to die for new things to appear. In the world of blogs and newspapers - each product must slay the ones that have gone before: "will this product replace all iphone sales?" - and then of course "product fails because all iphone owners didn't sell them and buy the new product".
I guess for programming languages there is also some one up-manship - "I'm better than all you people over there because my language of choice is still alive".
I could perhaps understand the articles point a little if Java had just stopped being flavour of the month - but it stopped being that years ago. It might not be the "sexy" choice but there is a huge amount of the worlds IT infrastructure running on Java and I don't reckon that's going to stop any time soon.
Java is being used to teach programming in many schools, so there are a large number of newbie developers walking around with a single hammer in their toolbox. They are going to be using it for any new project that they are tasked with.
And in general I think languages never really die. Look at COBOL, ADA and Perl (wink).
We went with the Java version... what we could have done in one week has now taken up around two months.
Will controversial headlines often get undeserved interest? Yes