News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The State of Java by tsally on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:21AM (#834436)
Results 1 – 10 of about 8,620,000 for java is dead. Dead indeed.

Results 1 - 10 of about 22,200,000 for obama is a muslim. Muslim indeed.

On a more serious note, the JVM is a platform that enterprise has a lot of experience deploying and securing. As the author admits, the JVM doesn't need Clojure or anything else to save it; it's entrenched in enterprise. This, combined with the fact that even COBOL isn't dead yet, makes me think that Java has a long way to go. Languages never die because there are better ones out there. It's certainly not trendy, but companies are going to need Java programmers for a helluva long time.

Re:The State of Java by ionfish on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:36AM (#834455)
Results 1 - 10 of about 936 for "java is dead".

Changes quite a bit if you quote it, leaving out pages with headlines like "Dozens dead in Java quake." People should think a bit more carefully before referencing numbers like these.

Re:The State of Java by rbanffy on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:21AM (#834518)
BTW, has anyone tried to port COBOL to the JVM? Sounds like an viable idea for a startup.

edit: it seems a company called Veryant already did it (http://www.veryant.com/products/)

Re:The State of Java by mahmud on Monday September 21, 2009 @11:56AM (#834838)
Product shops should be evaluated under a different light than service shops. Their existence shouldn't dissuade you from looking into the market; sometimes companies are stagnant ghost-ships that haven't done anything for ages. Other times they're an incompetent bunch with outsourced workers for a development team. In yet others, a product company only caters to one big client or two, or is geographically focused in one area.

If you don't see their name in industry publications and trade conferences they're as good as dead. Google their products and see if anybody is looking for help with them online. If they have a small user community, you can get a feel for how well they're doing. If there is no visible user community, well, there is either no market or the "company" is just a brochure website for vaporware.

Re:The State of Java by Kaizyn on Monday September 21, 2009 @12:02PM (#834859)
There's also the NACA project: http://code.google.com/p/naca/

A European company's IT staff built it over a period of several years, and it looks like a fairly impressive bit of engineering: http://media-tech.blogspot.com/2009/06/naca-presented-jazoon...

Re:The State of Java by va_coder on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:24AM (#834439)
Is Java dead? No

Will controversial headlines often get undeserved interest? Yes

Re:The State of Java by junklight on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:19AM (#834514)
Its even worse than a controversial headline. Its lazy blogging/reporting.

In the actual world things don't have to die for new things to appear. In the world of blogs and newspapers - each product must slay the ones that have gone before: "will this product replace all iphone sales?" - and then of course "product fails because all iphone owners didn't sell them and buy the new product".

I guess for programming languages there is also some one up-manship - "I'm better than all you people over there because my language of choice is still alive".

I could perhaps understand the articles point a little if Java had just stopped being flavour of the month - but it stopped being that years ago. It might not be the "sexy" choice but there is a huge amount of the worlds IT infrastructure running on Java and I don't reckon that's going to stop any time soon.

Re:The State of Java by bcl on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:16AM (#834613)
Absolutely. Java is clearly not dead, and will likely never be 'dead'. It is clear that it has been integrated into the Enterprise and is in use for many long term projects. This ensures that there will be a need to at least maintain Java codebases for many years.

Java is being used to teach programming in many schools, so there are a large number of newbie developers walking around with a single hammer in their toolbox. They are going to be using it for any new project that they are tasked with.

And in general I think languages never really die. Look at COBOL, ADA and Perl (wink).

Re:The State of Java by Tamerlin on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @01:01PM (#837410)
It's not just the newbies that limit themselves to the Java hammer, a lot of folks who've been in the industry for some time have grown comfortable with Java and are too set in their ways to change. In some cases, they're so set in their ways that they won't even migrate to newer Java tools that would automate a lot of what they currently do by hand, even though on time-constrained projects where we could have saved a considerable amount of time by taking advantage of faster development methods (it took 30 minutes to build and deploy a functioning web service in C# and 4 days to get the same thing working (but without the DB connection) in Java).

We went with the Java version... what we could have done in one week has now taken up around two months.

Re:The State of Java by DanielStraight on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:46AM (#834464)
I tend to agree with the comments about intentionally controversial headlines, but the article itself was excellent. If you haven't actually read it, please take the time to do so.

I think in the end, the author really nailed it. The important question is, "Is Java dead for me?" I would not use Java for a new personal project (and probably not for a work project either unless the libraries were needed). I do not have a clear replacement in mind... Python stands out the most.

My biggest problems with Java are the compilation step (admittedly not that big a deal with an IDE, but I don't always like to use an IDE), the insistence on objects, and most importantly, the lack of first class functions.

A new issue that has come up for me in comparison to Python is constructor overloading. In Python, constructor overloading is beautiful because of args and kwargs. In any C-family language (including Java here), it's horrible. With small objects where inheritance works well, the constructors in other languages can get unwieldy fast. In Python, they're always concise. I also love keyword arguments in general. It can make code much more readable, especially when using something like wxPython, where the parameter lists are long and otherwise would be quite vague.

Re:The State of Java by plinkplonk on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:16AM (#834614)
"The important question is, "Is Java dead for me?" "

Great Point,

"Is Java dead for me?" (and why or why not) would be an interesting question to ask HN regulars, vs the stupidity of trying to decide whether Java is "dead" or "alive" in general. The former leads a personal statement of intent, and consequently there is no real argument about any answer. The latter is undecideable and leads to plenty of unproductive argument.

As for me, I just transferred the leadership of an Open Source Java library I maintain to someone else, primarily because I am sick of writing and maintaining Java. That said, it is just a personal decision and I can imagine many scenarios where Java (not just the JVM) use would be appropriate. I just hope I am never part of those situations again! :-)

Personally, when I need to build something on the JVM I'll use Scala or Clojure. Else, I'll use Haskell, Python or C as appropriate.

Touch Wood.

Re:The State of Java by prewett on Monday September 21, 2009 @11:16AM (#834738)
I've been wondering about this: for personal projects, Python is compelling. But when you start working with multiple developers, the lack of compile time type checking seems like it would lead to a lot of subtle runtime errors. How do multi-person Python projects deal with this?
Re:The State of Java by steveklabnik on Monday September 21, 2009 @11:57AM (#834844)
I'm a Rubyist, not a Pythonista, but the same principles apply. I love really really strongly/statically typed languages (Haskell) and really really weakly/dynamically typed languages (Ruby).

Generally, it's not a problem. I have a hard time articlating why, exactly... I guess my code just tends to be short, sweet, and to the point. It's very rare that when I code in C, for example, that I try to do something that the type system wouldn't allow anyway.

That's a terrible answer, my apologies. Maybe this would be better: could you provide an example of a situation where you feel that dynamic code would cause a problem?

Mabye a bit of back and forth will help me figure out what I'm trying to say.

Re:The State of Java by prewett on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @12:04PM (#837258)
Is it only you writing the code? If it's just me, generally the names of my variables imply the type ("price" is probably a float, for example). But say you're joining a project with 100 Python classes. How do you write the code so that someone else will know that the arg named "network" is a ip address string and not a network socket or a class, presumably named "Network"?
Re:The State of Java by steveklabnik on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @06:55PM (#838193)
Funny, my "price" would probably be an integer ;).

Maybe it comes down to documentation. If I were to use some sort of function where I wasn't sure what the argument was, I'd look in the docs to see first.

Re:The State of Java by dasil003 on Monday September 21, 2009 @12:05PM (#834866)
This tends not to be a significant problem--if you pass the wrong type you find out the first time you run the code, which is probably not any later than you would have compiled it. A much more common problem are null references, but Java doesn't do anything about those either.

Java is great for the enterprise because it's stable, mature, and doesn't leave any room for cleverness to fly over people's heads. However the compile-time checks don't do much to prevent difficult-to-debug errors. A more powerful type system like Haskell is much more interesting in this regard.

Re:The State of Java by matunos on Friday September 25, 2009 @01:07AM (#842962)
I admit upfront that I'm a static type snob, but I have to disagree here. I've not had much experience with Pythong, but I've had plenty of experience with Perl at the enterprise software level (not just talking shell scripts here) and in my experience, a few of your statements don't hold up.

You definitely compile Java code well before you run it, at least in your full enterprise environment. And if you're using an IDE, you'll probably see any type errors well before you even compile it.

Sure, you might put your code through a workout with unit tests (and you should!), but any programmer knows that unit tests do not guarantee that you are using the right types in production, and they definitely do not ensure that clients of your code will be using the right types from your code.

I can't count the number of times I've had to use Data::Dumper just to figure out what type of object I'm dealing with. And don't even get me started with trying to figure out the right types of arguments to pass!

You are correct that the hardest bugs will be left for run-time, but why add to the hassle?

Re:The State of Java by axod on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:10AM (#834605)
That's not being 'dead' though. That's just choosing the right tool for the job at hand.

It's like proclaiming conventional spanners dead now that you can get adjustable spanners.

Some jobs you want solid object based exception handling water tight programming, and other jobs you want loose runtime based functional stuff.

Re:The State of Java by jlgosse on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:42AM (#834548)
You have to realize that Java isn't just important for the enterprise. It's also really important for academia and mobile.

I remember seeing a figure which was in the billions, which basically represented the number of non-pc devices reliant on Java, and that number was comprised mostly of mobile devices.

On top of that, most schools around the world begin teaching their computing undergrads in Java, which is a pretty big deal in terms of where development is headed in the mainstream.

Re:The State of Java by axod on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:26AM (#834440)
This sums up what is wrong with this industry.

Quit the endless "This is hot! This is dead! We're reinventing X by taking all the features out!"

We're not the fashion industry here, we're software developers.

How can a language even die? Sure, the community could die off, there could be no new updates, but that doesn't mean death.

Re:The State of Java by dschobel on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:18AM (#834619)
It's disconcerting how many people are objecting simply on the premise of the article without actually talking about the content (which is quite good).

Headline writers take note.

Re:The State of Java by abalashov on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:07AM (#834497)
I think Java is sufficiently lodged in the annals of the enterprise world that there's no danger of it dying any time soon.

I'm in telecom, and can tell you that Java has completely colonised this space for OSS/BSS (operational support/billing support systems), phone switch EMSs (external management systems), large-scale user portals and provisioning (Broadsoft), etc.

It ain't going anywhere.

Re:The State of Java by mosburger on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:23AM (#834525)
I rolled my eyes at the headline, thinking it was clearly cashing in on the Java deathwatch and a controversial headline. But this is one of the more sane articles on the topic that I've ever read. It's not just a fanboy of some other "trendy" language pointing out Java's shortcomings.
Re:The State of Java by wlievens on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:17AM (#834616)
Slightly off-topic, but I'd love an answer here. Is there any language at all, outside of the .NET stack, that has the kind of tools support java has? I'm talking about IDE with automatic refactoring, a wealth of plugins, instant squiggly-line syntax checking, source crossreferencing of libraries, etc? The only reason I use Java is Eclipse. I'd love to see another language that addresses Java's deficiencies but still has the same tool integration as Java. And I don't want to go over to the .NET side, sorry.
Re:The State of Java by plinkplonk on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:21AM (#834624)
"I'm talking about IDE with automatic refactoring, a wealth of plugins, instant squiggly-line syntax checking, source crossreferencing of libraries, etc? The only reason I use Java is Eclipse."

wlievens, given those requirements, Java is a good choice (and I say this as someone who just gave up on java completely) and there isn't yet a feasible alternative langauge with that level of tool support afaik.

Re:The State of Java by wlievens on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @08:07AM (#836755)
I figured. I'm just often looking for a justification of why I'm using a sometimes crippled language, but it always turns out my productivity and the quality of my code is higher when using Eclipse/Java.
Re:The State of Java by alrex021 on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:54AM (#834571)
The noise level just went up.

This is maybe a lesson for me to spend less time reading HN from now on. Perhaps leave the reading for the evenings as entertainment. :)

Re:The State of Java by Nelson69 on Monday September 21, 2009 @12:00PM (#834851)
There needs to be like a deficit score for any article that contains "is dead" in the title or "considered harmful"

Just off hand, can anyone think of a company that legitimately could have succeeded but failed because they chose the wrong programming language? Like they had a really really great idea and they had a really good design but the language just got in the way?

Re:The State of Java by brazzy on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:19AM (#834516)
Java's not fashionable. I guess to a lot of people that's the same as dead. These people will eventually grow out of this view.
Re:The State of Java by matunos on Friday September 25, 2009 @12:59AM (#842954)
Rumors of Java's death are greatly exaggerated. I can tell you that the article has failed to mention some other major companies that are using Java and are (believe it or not!) bigger than LinkedIn and Twitter.

Anyways, since when did googling for "X is dead" mean anything? I just googled for "Obama is dead" and got 111,000,000 hits. I guess that makes Obama 13 times more dead than Java. Somebody get me a copy-editor.

I'll give the author some points: the discussion that followed the ridiculous intro was a somewhat interesting, if dissembling, defense of Java. In the end though, it's all just some private pondering.

Java's death won't come at the declaration of some enterprising young turks who like Ruby (hey, I like Ruby too) battling it out over mailing lists and blogs. Programming languages, like old soldiers, don't die; they fade away... and very slowly.

Re:The State of Java by mgrouchy on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:04AM (#834412)
To comment on this, Its not that I don't think Java should probably die, but I don't think Java is going anywhere any time soon. As long as IBM uses Java as one of their core technologies and is writing their own JVM then Java will definitely be around for awhile.
Re:The State of Java by teppefall on Monday September 21, 2009 @11:41AM (#834804)
Goole uses C++ and Java while people focus on the static help system written in Python.

So.. if you want to build a static help system...

Re:The State of Java by neovive on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:38AM (#834541)
With strong support from companies like Oracle and IBM, Java code will likely be around as long as COBOL. Java may not make sense for small companies and startups building webapps. However, it works extremely well for big companies with large tech budgets, many developers and that only run software with support contracts and SLA's.
Re:The State of Java by wayne on Monday September 21, 2009 @11:33AM (#834789)
> The only large – and lets say profitable and growing – startup that uses Java is LinkedIn.

Mint uses Java a ton too and they did ok: http://mint.jobscore.com/jobs/mint/javasoftwareengineerbacke...

Re:The State of Java by ramoq on Monday September 21, 2009 @03:34PM (#835331)
Not to mention Yodle (nyc). They have a strong dev team.
Re:The State of Java by jganetsk on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:07AM (#834596)
OCaml and Factor are interesting and capable, but too far away from the procedural mainstream that is the C legacy.

Statements like this are patently absurd. OCaml is definitely close enough to the "procedural mainstream".

Re:The State of Java by biohacker42 on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:17AM (#834617)
Isn't Scala like Java++? Aren't both primarily aimed at enterprise server-side stuff? Any experienced Java programmers who have coded in Scala care to share their thoughts?
Re:The State of Java by ramoq on Monday September 21, 2009 @12:11PM (#834874)
Honestly, if it wasn't for spring and jpa/hibernate I wouldn't be too interested in java. Spring has _really_ made a great impact on java and people have noticed.
Re:The State of Java by moe on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:29AM (#834634)
As long as idiotic articles asking that question are posted: Probably not.
Re:The State of Java by mey on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:05AM (#834589)
No, FreeBSD is dead
Re:The State of Java by known on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:13AM (#834506)
I think Web Browser is a good alternative to JVM and CLR platforms.
Re:The State of Java by gthank on Monday September 21, 2009 @09:29AM (#834530)
And how exactly do you expect to generate the content for that web browser?
Re:The State of Java by known on Monday September 21, 2009 @10:38PM (#836121)
how do you generate content for jvm and clr?
Re:The State of Java by matunos on Friday September 25, 2009 @01:20AM (#842976)
Those "other" dead languages: C and C++
Re:The State of Java by ilyak on Monday September 21, 2009 @08:35AM (#834454)
If java is dead, what is alive?