News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by dandelany on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:01AM (#8335560)
Here's something I've always wanted: A consumer music file format that preserves all of the underlying tracks ('stems') so that they can be adjusted while you listen to the song.

Imagine listening to a recording and going "ooh, that bassline", and then turning up the bassist and turning down everything else to hear it better. Or easily "remixing" while you listen by eg. applying a filter to only the drums. You could even save presets to listen to "your" mix of the song again. Maybe this only appeals to hardcore music fans, but I know it's something I'd love to play with.

Of course it would have to be supported by major user-friendly software like iTunes, and would have to implement a nice interface for interacting with a tracks. But I've always thought Apple was very well positioned to take this on, if they wanted to.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by imaginenore on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:07AM (#8335599)
There are tons of formats like that. Midi, old tracker ones (s3m, xm, mod).

But very few artists are willing to publish the "source code" of their work.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by johnchristopher on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:31AM (#8335757)
What about rock bands and other recording music with their instruments rather than through samplers ?
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by imaginenore on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:46AM (#8335835)
I'm pretty sure they are recorded separately in a studio. At least the high end bands.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by Ryanmf on Thursday September 18, 2014 @02:52PM (#8336930)
Just yesterday I was investigating music/production startups, and one of the few ideas I came across that seemed halfway-interesting was Splice[0]. On the producer side they have plugins for a few DAWs that enable easier collaboration and version tracking and so forth. But what comes of that (and why it's relevant to your comment) is a Soundcloud-ish embeddable web player that breaks out all the tracks/stems into a timeline beneath the main player interface.

It's pretty interesting, although I don't know how much of an opportunity is there, for some of the same reasons mentioned in the other replies. Musicians and producers can be incredibly reticent about this stuff.

[0]http://splice.com

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by jaimebuelta on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:12AM (#8335630)
It sounds cool, but it will be a disaster. Does anyone remember the "ultra boost" button on the old Walkman to raise the bass to insane levels? Or all the equalizer voodoo, where people will "tune" moving levels and buttons forming shapes?

The sad truth is that audio engineers are way better than anyone else in mixing the music and making it shine. The better approach is not to mess with that and just trust them.

The same thing goes for headphones. It's better to get something more or less neutral in the sound to listen music in the way is supposed to sound, not distorting it adding crazy bass.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by kevincennis on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:25AM (#8335723)
As someone who spent a number of years mixing records professionally, I can definitely attest to the fact that even talented musicians are usually pretty terrible at mixing. It's a subtle art, and it takes a lot of experience/practice to do even remotely well.

But I think the larger point is that most artists and labels would hate this. To a singer, having someone hear your soloed vocal track is like being seen naked.

I think most artists view their records as being a single work of art. The song, arrangement, equipment, mixing, and mastering are all part of something bigger. Artists don't really want people to be able to break that apart. It's not meant to be experienced that way.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by ihsw on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:25AM (#8335722)
> The sad truth is that fashion designers are way better than anyone else in designing clothing and making it shine. The better approach is not to mess with that and just trust them.

> The sad truth is that chefs are way better than anyone else in creating a delicious menu and making it shine. The better approach is not to mess with that and just trust them.

Who ever said that keeping people from dressing hideously or eating food that doesn't match was a good idea?

Some people might even make it sound better, but you're advocating we take that opportunity away from them without giving them the benefit of the doubt.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by jaimebuelta on Friday September 19, 2014 @10:53AM (#8340769)
I don't think that people should be forbidden of playing with equalizers or even making their own recordings and mix. At the moment there are lots of tools that allow this.

But releasing a format for music that works around the idea of "do your own mix", that's a different issue.

If some artist wants to do it, hey, that's totally fine. What I'm skeptic about is that it's the future of music.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by post_break on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:21AM (#8335699)
Doesn't matter who's better at what. If consumers want to make smiley faces with their EQ let them. It's all about customization. Ask Metallica about how great their sound engineers were when they basically neutered their album.

People buy Beats because they like the way they sound (or because their idols use them). Even if you may think it's the same as ultra boost.

It's not about what sounds good, it's about what you think sounds good.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by johnchristopher on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:35AM (#8335773)
I'd agree with you if those audio engineers hadn't participated in the loudness war for the three last decades.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by kevincennis on Thursday September 18, 2014 @12:44PM (#8336173)
For what it's worth, most engineers want absolutely nothing to do with the loudness wars. These are people who've made a career on developing their ears, and the harmonic distortion from limiting the fuck out of a recording sounds even worse to them than it does to the general public.

The problem is that record labels have bought into the idea that a record needs to be outrageously loud in order to compete on radio. And the labels are the ones paying the mastering engineers.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by malka on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:18AM (#8335677)
It might not be for simply listening to the music, but for a moment 'hey this bassline kicks ass, I want to hear it alone to study it'
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by dbever on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:22AM (#8335705)
People often comment on the lack of bass in my headphone choices - I describe it as 'clinical' and much prefer studio-style response.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by ssharp on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:43AM (#8335822)
This could be interesting. Especially for artists using the Apple toolchain, namely Logic. It seems like a lot of stuff could then be duplicated on the desktop / mobile to give interested listeners control over various song elements.

I don't know how many people would actually be interested in that, though. It would be targeting a segment of music listeners that are extremely engaged with their music. I don't know if that market is really big enough to overcome the growing preference for streaming services.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by hazz on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:20AM (#8335695)
I would love this, but the file sizes would be insane. We'd be talking hundreds of megabytes (possibly gigabytes?) per song. Unless each track was MP3 encoded first, but I'd imagine you'd have trouble mixing tracks together from lossy sources.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by johnchristopher on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:30AM (#8335753)
Insane ? A standard DVD is 4.7 gigabytes. That would be 6 tracks and it would be ideal for any rock band and we haven't yet compressed the thing with loss (not technically true but you get the point.

I don't know about electronic music though.

Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by ceejayoz on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:04AM (#8335582)
I imagine this being greeted with fury and lawsuits from the artists. I remember a company in Utah that made family-friendly cuts of popular movies being sued for the modifications.
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by Pxtl on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:19AM (#8335688)
I believe Ogg has support for this, but who publishes oggs?
Re:Apple is working on a new digital music format by dubcanada on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:02AM (#8335571)
That would be awesome...