News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by clarkevans on Monday September 15, 2014 @01:33PM (#8320145)
"I really feel for Notch"

I don't. He cashed in and, well somehow wants the sympathy of free & open-source wish-keepers.

He's in the money; and that was his choice.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by dasil003 on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:46PM (#8321028)
I don't think he wants sympathy, that's not how I read this at all. I think he wants freedom, and he is not asking for it but simply stating for the record how he is going about this.

One of the thing's I admire about Notch's communication is that it always comes off as sincere and matter of fact. I think that is admirable in the face of the reality one faces in becoming internet-famous.

The internet has a big problem with mob-mentality entitlement. People jumping up to call Notch a hypocrite for going back on his word, or otherwise critiquing every little move he makes really don't have a leg to stand on. I mean sure everyone is entitled to their opinion, but the actual power that these people deserve to have over Notch is infinitesimal; it's just noise on the internet with no significance. Look at it this way, if suddenly 10 million people started scrutinizing what you were up to, I'm sure they'd have a lot of complaints, but what do you owe to them?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by clarkevans on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:21PM (#8321247)
Perhaps it's that Notch invited the entitlement with an explicit promise ? http://web.archive.org/web/20100301103851/http://www.minecra...

Included there is a dedication to (eventually) make the work open-source or public domain, and to contribute to it so long as people are paying. Those promises drove MindCraft praise, good will, and adoption. Do you think asking someone to keep these promises, the ones that drove adoption (and hence his current good fortune) is... entitlement?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by dasil003 on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:52PM (#8321746)
Yes, yes I do. The fact that you see his future plans as some kind of ironclad contract is precisely the problem. Minecraft did not explode because of these promises, it succeeded because of the reality on the ground as a fun game.

Notch gave the world a fun game, you gave him a small purchase price in order to enjoy it, end of transaction. The fact that he published thoughts and future plans does indenture him as your eternal entertainment provider. He should be free to leave daily development and do with his creation as he will, including deciding to do something differently than he originally envisioned. This is his prerogative as creator. To all the people who claim their participation "made" the success of Minecraft, I say bullshit, you are playing a fucking game.

You know what's a lot worse for humanity? When Twitter decided to be a media company instead of an infrastructure company. That also pissed off a lot of people who "made" the success of the company. But you know what? Same deal. It's their prerogative. You can cry and gnash your teeth, and of course you are entitled to your opinion, but the value of all those opinions? Farts in the wind.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by rkda on Monday September 15, 2014 @11:12PM (#8322848)
Or as Neil Gaiman would have said it:

Notch isn't your bitch.

http://journal.neilgaiman.com/2009/05/entitlement-issues.htm...

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by kaoD on Monday September 15, 2014 @06:41PM (#8321992)
The repeated use of the verb "will" definitely tricked me into believing it was a verbal contract, not just fuzzy plans (and I still believe he meant it as a contract).

I personally don't care, bought Minecraft, enjoyed it and moved along as I realized the modding system would never see the light... but I definitely understand why people feel disappointed.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by balloot on Monday September 15, 2014 @07:48PM (#8322261)
A blog post is neither "verbal" nor a "contract", no matter how many times the word "will" is used.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by dragonwriter on Monday September 15, 2014 @07:52PM (#8322276)
> A blog post is neither "verbal"

A blog post is -- if, as most are, it is composed of words -- verbal. Its not "oral", but those two don't mean the same thing.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by DanBC on Monday September 15, 2014 @09:47PM (#8322627)
Don't be obtuse. The phrase "verbal contract" is specifically oral contract.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by kaoD on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:34AM (#8323974)
Quoting Wikipedia:

"The term verbal contract is sometimes incorrectly used as a synonym for oral contract. However, a verbal contract is one that is agreed to using words, either written or spoken, as opposed to an implied contract."

It's funny how GP is heavily downvoted even though he's right. Downvoters (which I assume you're one of) didn't even check their facts.

Sometimes HN sucks.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by DanBC on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @04:38PM (#8326969)
Even wikipedia says you shouldn't use them as a reference.

Can you find any example of usage of "verbal contract" to mean anything other than "spoken contract"?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:05PM (#8327117)
> Can you find any example of usage of "verbal contract" to mean anything other than "spoken contract"?

http://www.californialaborlawattorney.com/implied-and-oral-c...

Contrary to common wisdom, an informal exchange of promises can still be binding and legally as valid as a written contract. A spoken contract is often called an "oral contract", not a "verbal contract." A verbal contract is simply a contract that uses words. All oral contracts and written contracts are verbal contracts. Contracts that are created without the use of words are called "non-verbal, non-oral contracts" or "a contract implied by the acts of the parties."

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by DanBC on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:31PM (#8327225)
So, that's clearly saying that people use "verbal contract" to mean "spoken contract" - it's not an example of someone using the term "verbal contract" to mean "written contract".
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:08PM (#8327381)
> it's not an example of someone using the term "verbal contract" to mean "written contract".

A verbal contract is simply a contract that uses words.

How is that not an example of a use of "verbal contract" to mean a category which includes both written and oral contracts?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by kaoD on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @04:43PM (#8326993)
Don't be obtuse ;)

Since you're the one claiming "verbal" equals "oral", you're the one who's supposed to do the research. Wikipedia has a citation on that specific paragraph and there are lots of results in Google. Do your homework before your claims.

But anyways, "verbum, verbi" means "word" in Latin while "os, oris" means "mouth". That should be a clue.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by DanBC on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @04:52PM (#8327049)
"Verbal contract" always refers to spoken contracts!

This is about usage, not definition. To interrupt a hrwad with a pointless aside in a snarky manner about a common (mis)use of "verbal" deserves a downvote.

Your inability to find an example of someone using "verbal contract" to mean "written contract" has been noted. :p

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by kaoD on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @04:54PM (#8327058)
> Your inability to find an example of someone using "verbal contract" to mean "written contract" has been noted. :p

Did you even search Google? Do your homework!

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by DanBC on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:29PM (#8327216)
http://www.adviceguide.org.uk/wales/consumer_w/consumer_prot...

here's one. Oh wait, they're using verbal to talk about oral contracts.

http://www.contractsandagreements.co.uk/law-and-verbal-agree...

here's another. oh wait! they're doing the same.

http://www.independent.co.uk/student/young-entrepreneurs/con...

Here's one from a national UK newspaper. They're using verbal to mean oral.

Here's another UK newspaper: http://careers.theguardian.com/careers-blog/contracts-employ...

And again, they carefully use written to mean written and verbal to mean spoken.

The first two pages of my Google search failed to show anyone using "verbal contract" to mean "written contract" - and it's pretty obvious why. A written contract is just a contract, or if you really need to specify whether it's written or spoken you'd be obtuse to use the word "verbal" to describe a written contract.

Perhaps it's a US / UK thing?

EDIT: put more smilies in.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by ceol on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @01:08AM (#8323153)
That wasn't a blog post. It was an About page for a product. It's essentially the product's description.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by watwut on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @07:46AM (#8323997)
Quoting the page you just linked: "Once sales start dying and a minimum time has passed, I will release the game source code as some kind of open source. "

Sales are not dying and minimum time did not passed. It does not even look like the sales will die soon. He was thinking about releasing the game when the game is dead and abandoned by gamers. Even if you take the above as a promise, the initial condition is not met and there is no requirement on him to do anything.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by anigbrowl on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:04PM (#8321517)
I don't see that he, personally, has to contribute free expansions, it's enough if Mojang does. A lot of people seem to be assuming that purchase by MS means the end of mods and the start of paid expansion packs. Is there definite evidence for this claim, or is it just speculation?

As for releasing it as open source, I went to your link and it says 'Once sales start dying and a minimum time has passed, I will release the game source code as some kind of open source.' How do you know he has gone back on this promise, as I have not seen any statement to the contrary so far?

Your claims of entitlement seem to rest on unproven assumptions. Is there some evidence out there you could link to, for those of us who don't follow the company/product closely?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by nl on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @12:47AM (#8323061)
What he actually said is worth quoting:

Once sales start dying and a minimum time has passed, I will release the game source code as some kind of open source.

Given that sales are still growing, I don't think you can even hold that against him.

He also said:

I'm going to have to include some way of winning the game

That never happened, either. Intentions change, and you don't see people judging him on that.

Your sense of entitlement is why corporations now include "forward looking statement" disclaimers.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by backlava on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @01:10AM (#8323154)
If you kill the ender dragon you get a credits screen. Does that not count as winning?
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by nl on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @01:14AM (#8323166)
Yeah, maybe I guess..

But it's not really the point of the game is it?

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by Ntrails on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @04:44AM (#8323583)
It can be, if you want it to - that's the whole point. Much like there are people who play WoW to accumulate gold, or PvP rankings, or raid success, or epic gear, or a working guild, or to craft all of the recipes, or something else I've not encountered.

The fascinating thing to me is that WoW's success was predicated on keeping people playing by paying content creators to come up with new goals for players to strive for, but minecraft demonstrates that people are more than capable of creating their own goals and successes within a sufficiently open ended game. For me, it was a lava moat. Then a pitched roof. Then a farm. Then a railway that took hours to build (and didn't go anywhere useful in retrospect). Then... etc

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by TruthSHIFT on Monday September 15, 2014 @01:44PM (#8320198)
Would Minecraft be in better hands if Notch open-sourced it instead of selling it to Microsoft?
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by opendais on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:00PM (#8320305)
Maybe but is it really a fair question?

Notch wasn't the only owner. In fact, he owns less than 50% and they have 40+ employees.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojang

Open sourcing it would likely screw his co-founders, employees with stock options, etc. compared to the size of this deal.

Tbh, I'd be happier if he donated 10% of his earnings from this sale to Open Source projects and feeding people. Rather than, y'know, having gone the route you suggested. He also seems like the kind of guy that would.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by rpdillon on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:22PM (#8320874)
He said he'd open source it, but it never happened. I think this pre-dates Mojang, but I'm not certain about the exact timing.

http://web.archive.org/web/20100301103851/http://www.minecra...

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by opendais on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:47PM (#8321033)
I think you are ignoring the condition on that sentence.

"Once sales start dying and a minimum time has passed, I will release the game source code as some kind of open source."

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by rpdillon on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @12:05AM (#8322968)
Sales will, at some point, start dying. He has, as far as I can tell, relinquished control of the source in a manner that will forbid him from open sourcing the game at that point.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by MortenK on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @06:23AM (#8323793)
You think it's reasonable that he should continue at the helm of Mojang and retain control of Minecraft IP until what exactly? 10 years pass and the brand (which Minecraft has become) finally fades in popularity?

So he can release it as open source, to make good on what? Some "About" page he wrote fucking 4 years ago when Minecraft was nothing but a PC indie sleeper hit?

Get real.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by opendais on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:37AM (#8324383)
So what? He should screw his business partners out of 2 billion so he could keep a promise from years ago when he had no clue how this would go?

Especially a promise to a community that throws him under the bus whenever something happens they don't like (even if he isn't involved)?

I don't think that is reasonable.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @09:39AM (#8324388)
I agree. That's why I don't recommend ever open-sourcing any software with commercial possibilities. You'd be throwing money away.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by Florin_Andrei on Monday September 15, 2014 @08:06PM (#8322333)
Right. He never thought he was going to make the current juggernaut. He thought it was going to be yet another moderately popular project with a limited duration and impact.
Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by ngokevin on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:46PM (#8321022)
He didn't really.

"Once sales start dying...as some kind of open source".

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by kazagistar on Saturday September 20, 2014 @01:19AM (#8343752)
Dunno, he would have to be a strong man to donate that much to open source after all the hate vomited his way about it.

I somehow suspect he might give money to something else in the end.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by nightcracker on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:15PM (#8320415)
Why would open sourcing it screw his co-founders? You can open source the code, interact with the community and improve Minecraft, while still selling the game. You don't have to open source the artwork and assets.

Piracy is not an argument in this, because pirating Minecraft for single player has always been and will always be piss easy, and multiplayer will still be impossible.

Re:I'm Leaving Mojang by opendais on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:31PM (#8320518)
Microsoft wouldn't pay $2 billion if he open sourced it. So they'd get a smaller payout.