News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by qopp on Monday September 15, 2014 @12:07PM (#8319648)
Lego had the lego creator video game long before Minecraft. Minecraft is something a bit more special.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kabdib on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:33PM (#8320533)
Lego is really, really paranoid about the kids being exposed to "bad influences" and predators. Those definitely exist, but Lego is a huge, fat target for lawsuits. IIRC chat was next to nonexistent in the Lego online products.

Mojang? Too small to care about. The parents seem to know that; at least I haven't heard about any multi-million dollar lawsuits revolving around MineCraft's chat, for instance.

I really wonder what Microsoft is going to do about this.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by cookiecaper on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:49PM (#8321048)
The thing with Minecraft is that it's pretty difficult for children to get in trouble with it. Chat is a minor part of the game and it's hard to send long messages; it's more or less just for coordinating builds. Servers are often private or invite-only and often involve mostly people the kids knew in real life. External resources cannot be imported into the game, so you don't have to worry about offensive avatars or sprays. If someone is really that dedicated to putting a naked woman in Minecraft, and I'm sure some children are, it would be a super pixelated version built out of Minecraft blocks that most parents wouldn't find explicit or offensive (though they may talk to the kid about the server he's on or something).

Even though it probably happened by accident, Minecraft is pretty kid safe.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kabdib on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:34PM (#8321338)
I dunno; my son constantly asks me if it's okay to install some MineCraft mod or another (he's been asking less and less because my answer is always "No").

Likewise, chat can lead to bad interactions. "Where do you live?" and "Are you a girl?" type questions. I haven't observed this, but the possibility remains. We've has serious talks with our son about this kind of thing.

I'm not paranoid, but forewarned is forearmed.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by tacotime on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:38PM (#8321677)
Why deny your kid the ability to mod?!? Dude, you're putting your kid in a box by not letting him explore the world of modding. The ability to add something new to your game is a powerful one and I think it can help a kid wrap his head around how a game is working internally. I think part of a parent's responsibilities toward their kid is to encourage the kid to explore the world (in safe ways of course) and I think minecraft mods are probably a pretty safe way especially if you're approving them one by one. You're stifling your kid's creativity every time you say no to one of his proposed ideas without just consideration. Just my opinion.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kabdib on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:46PM (#8321713)
Well, after the second time I flattened and rebuilt my son's machine because it was infected with mod-carried malware, I was done.

I'd been dubious prior to letting him try them out. It's hard for kids to be safe about downloading things.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by TeMPOraL on Monday September 15, 2014 @08:41PM (#8322447)
Well, that's how they learn. That's probably how you yourself learned it.

Kids need to be able to tinker with computers, and that includes both downloading malware and cleaning the machine including possibly reinstalling it from the ground up. That's how people grow their digital immune system that helps them navigate technology landscape safely.

Constantly fixing everything for our kids will lead to another generation of computer illiterates. This article covers this topic pretty well:

http://coding2learn.org/blog/2013/07/29/kids-cant-use-comput...

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by cookiecaper on Monday September 15, 2014 @06:46PM (#8322024)
This is just a testament to Mojang's poor mod system. They should have an API that only allows mods to perform safe, sandboxed operations and an in-game mod browsing tool to prevent things like that, especially when such a large percentage of their audience is children.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kllrnohj on Monday September 15, 2014 @11:19PM (#8322871)
Unless they add multi-processing to the mod system, they can't. You can't "sandbox" a Java class like that. You can't deny it access to JNI. You can't deny it access to java.io. You can have the host OS do this, of course, but now we're talking something far, far more complex than any mod system ever.

Which is, frankly, an absurd demand.

Mojang should have a mod API, but that won't do diddly squat to improve saftey. Don't execute code if you don't want that code to run.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by spand on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @03:35AM (#8323439)
Of course you can deny it access to JNI [1]. The Java platform has had this built in since forever. This is how applets work. Aside from sandbox exploits classes in Java can be locked down so much that they can pretty much only allocate memory and burn cycles.

[1] http://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/SecurityM...

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kllrnohj on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @12:47AM (#8328656)
Java Applets? That thing that had exploits like clockwork?

Yeah, that worked great

Regardless did you even bother looking at the documentation of SecurityManager? That would be a disaster to try and support. It can't clamp down per-library, it's all about current thread. Mods run in the same thread, they have to. So now you're suggesting that every. single. call into or out of a mod is guarded manually by updates to a permission manager that you are preventing the mod from modifying via reflection through... magic? Yeah, there's no way in hell that would ever work.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by eru on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @02:29AM (#8323318)
We execute untrusted HTML all the time. (And javascript.)

You might argue that HTML is not a general purpose language, and that is exactly true. That's what makes it easier to sandbox.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kllrnohj on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @12:49AM (#8328666)
HTML isn't code, you can't execute it.

And JavaScript runs in a VM designed specifically to handle untrusted code.

Neither applies in the slightest to the Java VM or Minecraft mods which, by definition, occupy the same process space with the same permissions as Minecraft itself. It is not a web browser, it does not have process sandboxing, it does not have a seperate VM specifically for mods, etc...

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by eru on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @03:25AM (#8328908)
> HTML isn't code, you can't execute it.

That's exactly a point I wanted to make. See https://www.usenix.org/legacy/publications/login/2011-12/ope... and http://langsec.org/papers/langsec-tr.pdf

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by ben0x539 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @03:06PM (#8326391)
To be fair, browsers spend a lot of effort on making sure their sandbox works as intended.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by ben0x539 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @03:06PM (#8326387)
When they have a defined modding API, they could expose it to a scripting language like JS or Lua that's potentially even easier to sandbox, too.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by nickodell on Monday September 15, 2014 @09:23PM (#8322563)
Or, y'know, any kind of API, instead of people overwriting mojang's code.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by kabdib on Monday September 15, 2014 @08:40PM (#8322443)
No kidding. As an API provider, Mojang is pretty terrible.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by peteretep on Monday September 15, 2014 @08:56PM (#8322487)
So give him a VM or image the machine. You have an ability that parents who aren't tech savvy don't.
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by Filligree on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @10:58AM (#8324800)
Do it for him, then.

If that would be too much time, use the FTB launcher; the modpacks there should be about as safe as it gets.

Or, hell, use my modpack at http://madoka.brage.info/, though that's pretty much just TPPI anyway. I'm a random internet person on hacker news; you know you can trust me.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by roghummal on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @03:03AM (#8323379)
"flattened and rebuilt"

What's "flattened"? Like you stomped on it?

Grats on raising another dumb user.

Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by dlhavema on Monday September 15, 2014 @12:29PM (#8319785)
i always took that quote to mean Minecraft is the Legos of the Digital Age. building blocks used to make pretty much anything you want.. I've played it on PC and think it's really fun. It is amazing what it's doing for young kids and how its introducing them into programming. the last two conferences (JavaOne 2013, Oscon 2014) i went to had a keynote speaker that was 10 or 11 and got started because of minecraft ( and his parents were techies.. )
Re:Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft by Houshalter on Monday September 15, 2014 @12:54PM (#8319919)
I remember playing the lego creator game. The reason minecraft caught on instead is the controls are much easier, and multiplayer.