News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kyro on Friday September 12, 2014 @06:36PM (#8310849)
Reading things like this make me OK with startups bending an even breaking the occasional law if they're truly providing something of value. The legal system is rife with regulations and actors that are often not intended to benefit the public. There is nothing inherently right or efficient about it, and it's the oldest and most inflexible of the man-made institutions, behind Comcast.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by bowlofpetunias on Saturday September 13, 2014 @04:39AM (#8311894)
Organizations deliberately breaking the law for profit is generally called "organized crime".

Drug dealers provide something of value and personally I think we would be way better off if drugs were legalized. So we're going to call our local drugs-gangs "disruptive startups" now?

90% procent of the time these companies are simply breaking privacy, consumer protection and labor laws for one reason and one reason only: greed. So occasionally they may stumble upon a law that actually needs reform. Even a broken clock is right twice per day.

That doesn't make me okay with OK with breaking the law as a business strategy, especially since most of the time it isn't the Comcasts of this world that suffer the consequences, but individual workers and consumers.

This Robin Hood worship is pathetic. These startups are not making the world a better place.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by DanielBMarkham on Saturday September 13, 2014 @05:34AM (#8311975)
>> Organizations deliberately breaking the law for profit is generally called "organized crime".

You know, I actually agree with you, by the definitions of things we have in place today, that is, in fact, organized crime. And since most people violate three laws a day, and we use various corporate affiliations to do it, it would follow that we are all members of a vast organized crime syndicate.

Going to need some bigger prisons.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by industriousthou on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:47AM (#8312231)
>>Drug dealers provide something of value and personally I think we would be way better off if drugs were legalized. So we're going to call our local drugs-gangs "disruptive startups" now?

Don't know about "local drug-gangs," but yeah, I see my friendly, neighborhood reefer dealer as an entrepreneur who provides a valued service.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by CamperBob2 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:16PM (#8313264)
These startups are not making the world a better place.

As opposed to governments gone berserk?

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by josho on Friday September 12, 2014 @06:46PM (#8310882)
Agreed, but I also hope that the regulators catch up and make sane decisions to correct the current environment. For example, at the forefront of my mind is the need for consumers and the state to have assurances that the drivers of these services have commercial insurance. Or that it truly is a ride-sharing lookup, not a taxi service.

I'm sure there are other issues that need sorting, but as an outsider much of the taxi industry's regulations seem like they can be modernized for a post uber/lyft world.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by pmorici on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:43AM (#8311717)
"assurances that the drivers of these services have commercial insurance."

I'm not sure about the situation in California but I looked into how taxis were insured in Maryland and it turns out they basically don't have insurance. They are only required to have a certain amount of cash in an account that acts like insurance if something happens. I believe the amount was around $30,000 which is very very little if something legitimately serious were to happen. Which is why I find it funny when people think taxis are some how better insured than ride share services.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by DanBC on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:44AM (#8311785)
What? They must have insurance, and the state minimum is $30,000 per person.

> The Maryland General Assembly approved the increase in April, slightly upping legal minimum insurance coverage to at least $30,000 per person and $60,000 per crash.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by pmorici on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:37AM (#8312468)
Yeah, but they have a special program for Taxi's that allow what they call "self-insurance" where the taxi is insured by a bond or letter of credit with the MVA.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by agiamas on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:54PM (#8313205)
> The same applies almost everywhere in the US and not just to taxis - if you can pay a cash bond at the DMV, you can ride without insurance.

Exactly. And that's amazing. I don't want to pay any insurance, I can self-insure and pay with my own bond if I'm caught into an accident.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by pmorici on Saturday September 13, 2014 @09:57PM (#8314288)
Yup, the difference between a taxi and an individual though is the taxi company will create an individual llc for each taxi so if a given taxi is in a bad accident they will just bankrupt that llc and try to skip out on paying anything.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by alasdair_ on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:48PM (#8313196)
The same applies almost everywhere in the US and not just to taxis - if you can pay a cash bond at the DMV, you can ride without insurance.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by aianus on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:48PM (#8313195)
In most places you can self-insure as a rich individual driving a personal car too.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by metacorrector on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:24PM (#8314147)
When there is an accident, injured parties go after rich people, like the expression "deep pockets", and juries aren't sympathetic to them. Rich people are advised to get (and can afford) insurance more than middle class people.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by oasisbob on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:58AM (#8311730)
I believe bonds in lieu of insurance are commonly allowed across the US, though maybe not for taxis?

As the fleet size increases, the amount of the bond goes up as well -- essentially giving companies the choice of self insuring. I'd be surprised if many independent operators were self-bonded.

And of course, it's not like the minimum insurance requirements are great across the board either.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by aianus on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:51PM (#8313201)
> And of course, it's not like the minimum insurance requirements are great across the board either.

The alternative is something like Toronto where personal car insurance costs upwards of $300 a month for a 23 year old male with no tickets or accidents because the minimum coverage is so extensive.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kyro on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:06PM (#8311428)
Absolutely. I'm not advocating that we do away with the regulatory system, but that those drafting the rules look at startups like Uber/Lyft as signals and catalysts for change as opposed to reflexively treating them as threats on the system that Has Been And Always Shall Be. The world is changing rapidly, new needs and demands emerge, others die, and the red tape should be in constant reapplication, in tow.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by ChiperSoft on Friday September 12, 2014 @08:36PM (#8311199)
I hope you mean just regulatory laws.

If not, you might have a comfortable position waiting for you in the mafia.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kyro on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:04PM (#8311421)
already cofounder/ceo of kyll, lyft for assassins, and looking for investors
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by uniclaude on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:52PM (#8311503)
You guys should definitely consider applying to Y Criminator.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kyro on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:51AM (#8311662)
hoping our working prototype will get us in
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by vvvv on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:45AM (#8312492)
Or else you'll make an offer they can't refuse ;]
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by toyg on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:49PM (#8313198)
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by tn13 on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:12PM (#8311283)
The lines between Mafia and tech entrepreneurs are not very clear. Threatening competitors of legal action and keeping salaries of employees lower sounds more like a Mafia and less like a tech entrepreneur to me.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by asdfologist on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:42PM (#8311375)
Agreed. Tech entrepreneurs murder their competitors and extort people using physical violence all the time.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by googamooga on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:24AM (#8311634)
No. This is exactly what government does.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by tn13 on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:46AM (#8317848)
Surely your knowledge of Mafia is based on movies !
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by n09n on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:48PM (#8311391)
Is that really how you think the mafia behaves? I wonder if that should be considered a PR problem or a huge success.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by mpyne on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:31PM (#8312813)
Just because the mafia doesn't simply break knees randomly doesn't mean that the threat of violence doesn't underpin the mafia's operations.

Yes, this includes targeted killings and violent extortion when required. Since this threat has been proven credible it's normally not required to actually break people; people simply give up before the tire irons have to be brought out.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by tn13 on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:48AM (#8317854)
Yes and large co bosses also behave in a similar fashion. Very often the kind of people Mafia deals with is the one that normally does not have anything other then their life to lose, but when it comes to large co bosses they are dealing with people who have too much to lose and hence a mere threat of legal action works even if that legal action is totally frivolous.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by maxcan on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:21AM (#8311629)
> The lines between Mafia and government bureaucrats are not very clear.

FTFY

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by logicchains on Saturday September 13, 2014 @04:50AM (#8311907)
Rob a man, and you're a criminal. Get half the people in some arbitrary geographical region to put your name on a piece of paper and rob a man, and you're a statesman.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by tn13 on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:43AM (#8317840)
Thanks. The only line is when a mafia boss says "I will fix that for you" you can rest assured it will be fixed. When government guys says "we are gonna fix it" you better run..
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by edgyswingset on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:31PM (#8312814)
Tech libertarianism is cute.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kashkhan on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:55PM (#8311403)
or government. In government you can break almost any law.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by waps on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:16PM (#8311437)
That's kind of the point of a democratic system. The government can change any law it wants.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by tn13 on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:53AM (#8317863)
That is true but then USA is a Republic where the rule of law matters more than will of the people. The only way people's will can be executed is by first making it a law, at that point all the people who have an interest against the law and unite and put a defense.

However there is a clever trick that the current President has used. Pass laws that are ridiculously long and large. When you pass a law that is 1000 pages long with another 1000 pages of appendixes, no sensible man can read and make sense of it and hence does not have much credible ground to oppose it.

"You think clause 9, subsection B poses a problem for X ? We have taken care of in clause 204 sub-claue 11c when taken into context of Annex. Z" a trick that was mastered by British and Indians.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by logicchains on Saturday September 13, 2014 @04:52AM (#8311909)
That's why America was founded as a republic. Rule of law, not rule of man.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by muuh-gnu on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:31AM (#8312118)
Ultimately, it is rule of man, since man can change the law.

However you call it, it is ultimately power (of man) that rules other men. Having to push it through the frictional and slow law process merely makes powerful men less powerful by the amount of the systemic friction. But the power gradients still exist and lead to the same consequences.

It merely prolongs a "i dont like him, behead him on the spot" into "i dont like him, make the state attorney accuse him of rape and murder, drag him through courts for 20 years and execute him". But the intimidating effect of power differences is the same. Rule of law is just the same ol rule of man cloaked into law.

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by logicchains on Saturday September 13, 2014 @09:29AM (#8312304)
In theory it could be rule of machine, if the justice system was composed of some kind of immutable law-enforcing robots, but you're right that in practice rule by law is just roundabout rule by man. Nevertheless, I'd take "dragged through the courts for 20 years" over "beheaded on the spot" any day.
Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by guelo on Friday September 12, 2014 @09:19PM (#8311309)
Just occasionally dumping arsenic in your drinking water. Occasionally some rat droppings in your meal. Just a little bit of bait and switch scam. Occasionally sneaking in hidden fees.

But we're providing something of value!

Re:California deems carpooling via all ride-share services i... by kyro on Friday September 12, 2014 @10:12PM (#8311434)
i always assumed civets had the market, but never considered rats