The borrower is slave to the lender; why would you want that dynamic in your friendship?
It becomes a business when
1) you charge interest
2) you have some terms and conditions or attach some "strings"
3) you require collateral
4) you make your friend sign papers, and you leave "legal" options open
When I loan a friend, all I say is "dude, this is just to help you, I know you are going through tough times. No way this is to insult or patronize you. you can return the money when you can, even if it takes you 5-10 years"
That is trust and friendship, one friend helping the other, nothing more nothing less and definitely not a business.
You are putting a dollar amount on the friendship
Nope, I am not. All I am saying is, if I am in a better position than my friend, and he needs help, I am willing to help. He has to borrow money from someone anyway, why not from me, interest free and trouble free? He can sleep peacefully at night, knowing that I wont foreclose his house or something, if he is going to be late in repaying, or even if he is not able to repay at all.
If they don't pay you back, will you still be friends?
Yes. We are talking of FU money here, and also assuming that I am in a situation like Mint founders. I am in a position to loan money, without affecting my own lifestyle. Obviously, if I am myself living paycheck to paycheck, this won't apply.
why not just give them the money?
because, I don't want to patronize them, and don't want to insult them.
Frankly, I don't understand why you call this bullshit. Loaning money to friends happens all the time. I've done it many times, and have always been repaid.
It's often a bad idea to mix friends and business/money. That doesn't mean it is always a bad idea.
I think it would be a better idea to loan them money to pay off their debts. Of course, your loan should be interest free, shouldn't have any strings attached, should give your friends very long time to repay - otherwise there wouldn't be any difference between your loan and the 'other' loans in the first place.