News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by keepper on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @04:41PM (#8299004)
Except I pay for the roads.. you know.. registration, taxes on gas, taxes on purchase of the car, etc etc...

But hey, you're welcome to pay a little for the roads too ;)

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by iak8god on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:28PM (#8299308)
I wish I thought you were kidding, but many people seem to actually believe that these things are enough to pay for the construction and maintenance of roads. Not so. Much of the cost comes out of general taxes, which everyone pays. When you consider that cyclists contribute basically zero wear and tear to the roads, it starts to look like they're subsidizing your lifestyle.

That's ignoring externalities like reduced traffic and pollution, and reduced demand for oil.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by reitanqild on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:57PM (#8299424)
Around here car taxes, road taxes, "environmental taxes" on fuel etc adds up to a whole lot more than the combined price of road maintenance and so on. Also none of it is earmarked for environmental purposes.

Point is: While I'm mostly happy with the tax levels a little honesty would be appreciated.

Edit: Why the downvotes? (BTW: I live in Norway ATM, go read up on Norwegian taxes if you don't trust me.)

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by iak8god on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @06:58PM (#8299775)
> Around here car taxes, road taxes, "environmental taxes" on fuel etc adds up to a whole lot more than the combined price of road maintenance and so on.

That's really different from the situation in the States and the UK which is where I've seen the actual numbers.

I'm not a heavy user of fuel, so may be a bit biased on this, but it seems really sensible to me to use taxes to compensate for externalities. For instance, I'd guess based on my general impressions of Scandanavia and other civilized places that Norway has publicly-funded universal healthcare. Good on you for that. Now, doesn't it make sense for some of the taxes on owning and using an automobile to go toward public health? In my country, collisions involving cars are a leading source of injury and death. Elsewhere in this thread are estimates of the health impacts of auto emissions -- they are significant.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by reitanqild on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @07:20PM (#8299868)
> For instance, I'd guess based on my general impressions of Scandanavia and other civilized places that Norway has publicly-funded universal healthcare. Good on you for that.

Thanks! The first time I really understood the North American model where people have to pay to send their kids to college or go to the doctor, that was an eye opener for me. I now happily pay my taxes.

> Now, doesn't it make sense for some of the taxes on owning and using an automobile to go toward public health?

Absolutely. I think I mentioned it in the post. The part I don't like is where they call it road tax or environmental tax only to go ahead and use it for something completely different.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by iak8god on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @08:05PM (#8300045)
> The part I don't like is where they call it road tax or environmental tax only to go ahead and use it for something completely different.

Well, even a little honesty may be too much to expect from politicians anywhere.

I'm guessing you were downvoted above by people who had trouble imagining the existence of a place where automobile ownership and use is taxed to the levels you describe.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by reitanqild on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @10:11PM (#8300502)
> I'm guessing you were downvoted above by people who had trouble imagining

That's what I thought too.

(I had a feeling a few days ago that someone who recently got their downvote privilege has been a little extra triggerhappy but I'm not sure. This is the first time I got hit.)

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by elblanco on Thursday September 11, 2014 @02:47PM (#8304380)
I honestly don't understand where most tax dollars go in the U.S. I'm in Korea at the moment and the tax burden is overall very light when compared to the States, but the level of service you receive is absolutely tremendous for the most part.

Example, if you make over around $85,000 USD, you fall into the maximum tax bracket, which is 35%. Most people pay around 25%. As a foreigner, I can also pay an alternative 17.5% instead.

There's also a 10% surtax at all income levels. So I can really get by with about 18.5% income tax (and there's all kinds of easy deductions).

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by dragonwriter on Thursday September 11, 2014 @02:57PM (#8304449)
> Example, if you make over around $85,000 USD, you fall into the maximum tax bracket, which is 35%.

In the US, the maximum income bracket has a 39.6% marginal rate and is reached at $400,001 in AGI for a single filer; the (weirdly narrow) 35% bracket starts at $398,351.

So if Korea has a 35% top bracket, witha 10% surtax, that starts around $85,000 USD, I'm not seeing how that's "overall very light when compared to the States".

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by elblanco on Thursday September 11, 2014 @03:16PM (#8304558)
Hmmm...maybe you're right. For some reason I feel like I pay less here. I definitely get more service at least.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by Kluny on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:33PM (#8299321)
Plus the fact that most bikers own cars too, they just don't happen to be driving it when you see them.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by TulliusCicero on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @04:52PM (#8299083)
Cars also inflict many externalities onto others that other forms of transportation do not (pollution, increased travel distance, injuries and deaths, etc.), and yet drivers seem less keen on paying extra to compensate for those costs.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by sedachv on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:05PM (#8299170)
The biggest externality cost in the United States by far is parking. Many cities have mandatory parking space requirements for businesses that impact not just new developments but re-purposing of existing properties (ex: restaurants must provide so-and-so many free parking spaces per thousand square feet; you have to do this even if you're converting an existing property into a restaurant). This is a huge pain for a lot of people trying to open small businesses.

This is more of a zoning issue though (I think mandatory parking ordinances should be repealed and all parking should be privatized).

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by seanflyon on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @04:59PM (#8299134)
And wear and tear on the road is approximately proportional to weight and speed so bikes make almost no contribution to road wear, which is the primary cost of our road system.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by DanBC on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:00PM (#8299146)
About 29,000 people die from air pollution in the UK and about 1 in 4 of those may have been from traffic pollution. But death is cheap and people living longer with worse quality of life with COPD or similar costs money.

http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/apr/29/diesel-en...

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by jrockway on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @04:55PM (#8299109)
I pay taxes on wars, but would be happy to not have the war if I didn't have to pay those taxes.

Sadly, that's not how taxes work. Each tax isn't "for" something, they all go to into the budget and are used to buy stuff.

Toll roads might be a fair example. Those are mostly closed to bicycles.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by true_religion on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:11PM (#8299205)
Often gas taxes/vehicle property tax is tagged by the state to be dedicated solely towards road development and upkeep. If there's ever a shortfall, they stop maintaining lesser used roads because the rest of the budget has already been decided.

This is despite the fact that it takes more than gas + property tax to fund the highway system.

Thinking about that... I get your point, non-drivers are funding the roadway system as much as drivers are.

I think its the way that gas taxes for instance are leveraged in the decision making process that makes people think that it makes the lion share of the contribution. When the proceeeds from gas tax falls, lawmakers think less people are driving thus less maintenance is needed.

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by soperj on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @05:28PM (#8299307)
Not to mention bikers inflict 0 wear & tear on the road.
Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by jrockway on Thursday September 11, 2014 @12:20AM (#8300872)
Not quite zero, there are some speed bumps that I notice in NYC where the bouncing motion of the bikes has worn additional bumps in the speed bump.

Of course, you don't really need the speed bumps in the bike lane. I assume it's there because people will drive around it if it doesn't cover the entire road surface. (Protected bike lanes would fix that, but I'm not really a protected bike lane proponent, so we'll pretend I didn't mention that.)

Re:Bike lanes have sped up car traffic in New York City by recursive on Wednesday September 10, 2014 @04:45PM (#8299026)
Most bicyclists pay all those things as well. Additionally, in many states, roads are mostly paid for by other sources.