Perhaps between the crappy economy and whatever Yodlee is charging for their data, Mint may not be anywhere near profitable. They may have acquired a lot of users, but they have to pay Yodlee for all those users' data, and cover the costs by the fraction of those users who go for the bank/credit card stuff suggested.
During the time I used Mint, none of the financial offers presented were better than my current ones, so I never bit.
http://spyfu.com/Domain.aspx?d=-3624320565025573542
http://www.onecubicle.com/page/jobs/job/4581
"We didn’t have money for writers, so most of our original blog content then was guest posts from other personal finance blogs, plus a couple of columns on people’s worst financial disasters. To build demand, we started asking for email addresses for our alpha 9 months in advance of launch. Then when we had too many people sign up, we asked people to put a little badge that said “I want Mint” on their blogs to get priority access. We got free advertising and 600 link backs which raised our SEO juice."
Instead, we relied on press. It’s where I spent 20% of my time. I’m spending it right now while writing this."
http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/09/14/the-value-of-techcrunch...
Having an awesome product certainly helped but it was in conjunction with their other efforts.
I agree with your second statement: to the uninformed observer (me and everyone else in this thread) something does seem off. Bank and credit card leads pay from $50-$200 per pop let alone the riches that mortgage leads bring in.
I was in fits of laughter during the initial Mint acquisition HN thread (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=821615) when people accused Mint of being unable to make money. To some, advertising and subscription payments are the only way to monetize.