News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:01PM (#8286544)
Smaller nations sounds nice but in the intermediate term reality Scotland would become a minor province of the EU nation. It'd be trading Britain for something much bigger.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by cstross on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:06PM (#8286561)
We've already got that something (the EU). It's relatively benign. (Meanwhile, we've got an extra tier of government that insists on spending tax revenue raised in Scotland on stuff the Scottish people really don't want.)
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:46PM (#8286792)
The UK has a government that spends tax revenues raised in the UK on stuff people in [some parts of] the UK don't want.

A new country called Scotland will it seems have a government that spends tax revenues raised in Scotland on stuff people in [some parts of] Scotland don't want. If you lived in a tax raising city state then your city would do the same thing.

If you didn't want an extra tier of government then why vote for one? We could have saved £414 million in one swoop on that.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by smsm42 on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:12PM (#8287309)
One could argue that the smaller the government is and the more local the taxes are, less is the percentage spent on the things inhabitants of this locality do not want. Example: if you raise taxes on city level, then spending decisions are influenced only by people living in your city, and the chance it would be spent on building an airport in the next county that nobody flies from, to suit some politician, are much less. OTOH, if all the taxes are collected by a huge central government, the chances that you will disagree with a lot of its spending are much higher.

Of course, the hybrid model is possible - with only taxes that are needed specifically for big things - like national defense - collected on hight level, and taxes needed for local things - like police, roads, schools, etc. - collected on the lower levels. That's how the federalism works.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by wisty on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:29PM (#8287038)
The main problem is, revenue and spending are rarely done by the same people.

The UK can blame the Scottish Parliament on reckless spending, and be forced to raise taxes. A local government can recklessly spend (or neglect infrastructure), and force the Scottish to bail them out. Should a state government fight to create jobs (even if it annoys special interest groups), or just rely on welfare from the federal government?

If there's a government that is in charge of major infrastructure, health, education, social welfare, and taxes, then there's far less buck passing.

States spend the big bucks, so states should be responsible for raising the big bucks.

The other problem is that people only care about the highest level of government. Probably because it's more efficient for news organisations to only report on the Federal level (since the story will be more widely read).

Look at the US. It seems that virtually everything gets blamed on Obama or the House, despite the fact that the real decisions are generally done at the state level, with far less scrutiny, because it's cheaper for the newspapers to just send a single correspondent to Washington, and report on what's going on there.

I don't even know the current Premier (governor, in US terms) of my state. Not since a "memory lapse" in front of a corruption inquiry forced the last one out a few months ago, after the previous party lost a string of premiers also due to corruption - I just can't keep up.

So there's two problems - no-one cares about anything other than the top level of politics (since the papers are all national now, and it's more efficient to just look at what happens at the Federal level), and there's too much buck passing between the level of government that has the money, and the level of government that spends it.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:13PM (#8286591)
The EU is an ongoing and succeeding effort to replicate the United States Federal government in Europe. Scotland will eventually wind up having as much say as New Hampshire does in very important matters, such as control of its borders and agriculture policy.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by arethuza on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:29PM (#8286683)
"control of its borders"

I'm pleased to say that we don't seem to have quite the same obsession in Scotland with keeping immigrants out as a lot of people in the UK. In fact the SNP is rather keen on encouraging immigration.

I'd far rather have the right to live and work anywhere in the EU than be trapped in the UK with Boris Johnson as PM running second hand UKIP policies.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by DmitriRavinoff on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:42PM (#8286766)
Control of borders doesn't imply "everyone keep out." It just means that the government reserves the right to keep people out.

Kinda like a trademark, actually. One has to "defend" a trademark in order to keep it, which can either take the form of an overeager legal department, or you can just find all the people who are using your trademark and give them explicit permission to do so with the caveat that you may rescind that permission at your discretion (like Hormel did with the word Spam).

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by arethuza on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:48PM (#8287138)
'Control of borders doesn't imply "everyone keep out."'

You should have a read of the Daily Mail.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:54PM (#8287182)
>I'd far rather have the right to live and work anywhere in the EU //

https://www.gov.uk/working-abroad, "You have the right to work in any country in the European Economic Area (EEA) without a work permit if you’re a UK citizen."

So presumably you'd vote No to maintain this right and stay in the EU? I'm confused as that seemed contrary to the rest of your comment.

Parts of the UK could easily be overwhelmed by open borders with the rest of the Schengen Area. Perhaps Scotland will fair better, maybe it's less attractive to migrants. What is certain though is, with a Yes vote, that unless the rUK vote to become part of the Schengen agreement there will need to be border controls between Scotland and the Common Travel Area (CTA).

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by alextingle on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:34PM (#8287445)
> Parts of the UK could easily be overwhelmed by open borders with the rest of the Schengen Area.

This is nonsensical scaremongering. The UK's refusal to join Schengen keeps out a handful of illegal migrants, most of whom would be caught and deported anyway. If the far greater number of French[1] and Eastern European migrants who live and work here courtesy of the EU's "free movement of labour" clauses haven't "overwhelmed" anybody,[2] then a few extra illegals are hardly going to tip the balance.

[1] - Oddly, nobody ever complains about the huge numbers of French migrants to the UK. It's almost as though there's an element of racial discrimination somewhere...

[2] - Boston, Lincs. is often cited as being overwhelmed by Eastern migrants. But even the BNP can only find an uptick in driving offences to complain about: http://www.bnp.org.uk/news/regional/stop-press-boston-crime-...

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by chestnut-tree on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:04PM (#8287255)
"In fact the SNP is rather keen on encouraging immigration. I'd far rather have the right to live and work anywhere in the EU than be trapped in the UK with Boris Johnson as PM running second hand UKIP policies."

The SNP proposed plan is to encourage skilled workers (from outside the EU) using a controlled points-based system. That's quite a different policy position to the EU where EU citizens can freely live and work in any EU country. I doubt many people in the UK would object to the skilled immigration policy the SNP proposes. But, of course, we need workers of all skill levels. I agree that the rhetoric from the UKIP and Conservative party on this subject (and the toxic British Press) is often alarmist and inflammatory.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:34PM (#8286724)
Control of borders is practically the definition of a nation. If you don't have a say in who comes in, you aren't a nation.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by arrrg on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:30PM (#8287045)
Restricting freedom of movement and labour is morally unconscionable. I’m certain we will look back to that in a few centuries with horror.

At least the EU was able to reduce that somewhat in some places. Sure, the outer border of the EU is horrific, but inside it’s at least somewhat ok. A world with borders is an evil and oppressive world. We should always work towards removing them all for everyone.

(Yes, I know about Schengen and the differences between Schengen and the EU. However, be assured that Schengen would not exist without the EU. It’s just that achieving consensus is hard, so some want out of some things and some want it. That’s why it’s always so complicated and hard. EU is a convenient shorthand, because I don’t just mean visa free travel, I also mean being able to live and work in other places.)

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by jiggy2011 on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:43PM (#8287120)
That might work if all countries had similar culture, values, standards of living and agreements over things like how healthcare should be paid for. In reality, if a first world country opens it's borders to the rest of the world , even if the agreement is reciprocal then most of the traffic is going one way as people try and converge on the source of wealth. We already have this problem within the UK when trying to cram so many people into London.

It also raises questions like, if I can live and work wherever I want why should I only be able to vote in one fixed arbitrary place?

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by arrrg on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:00PM (#8287568)
Yes, and abolishing slavery was also hard … (I do explicitly not want to compare the severity and impact of borders to the severity and impact of slavery or even racism today. It’s an analogy.)

I know there are practical issues in the way that prevent abolishing borders. I know this won’t happen quickly, probably not during my lifetime, probably not in a couple centuries, but working towards a world where this is possible seems like a worthwhile goal to me. Why should people be arbitrarily bound to the place they were born? It’s insanity and highly unethical.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @10:20PM (#8288439)
I look forward to hearing your tune when 2,000 illiterate indians show up in your neighborhood and start publicly defecating all over the place. http://www.poo2loo.com/
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by seanflyon on Monday September 08, 2014 @08:14PM (#8288056)
> Restricting freedom of movement and labour is morally unconscionable.

Why? I'm in favor of more open borders than most nations have, but I don't see a moral imperative to let outsiders in.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by tptacek on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:20PM (#8286987)
Control of borders is practically the definition of a nation in the sense of Westphalian Sovereignty, but arguing against that is Stross' whole point.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:30PM (#8287048)
He never really makes a coherent point about how his smaller states will handle borders. Bringing up Westphalia in this particular context is silly because it's an eternal truth. If your people don't control access to the land, you will lose control of the land. This was true ten thousand years ago and it's true of Tibetans now.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by tptacek on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:26PM (#8287396)
An "eternal truth"? It's called Westphalian Sovereignty because it's the result of the eponymous historical event, prior to which extranational forces played a huge role in the internal politics of states.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:13PM (#8287620)
What point are you making? A chimp can understand this need to control land access. Saying "westphalia" over and over sheds no light. Control over immigration and land use was not invented by 17th century european diplomats if that's what you think. To the extent nations failed to control their borders in the past they were simply unfortunately weak nations.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by tptacek on Monday September 08, 2014 @08:23PM (#8288100)
I think I'm making exactly the point I just made in the comment that you responded to: that prior to the Peace of Westphalia, extranational forces played a part in local policy. Today, states and national borders dominate policy, but in pre-Westphalian society, borders were fluid, and the church often played as great a role as local governments. One day Aquitaine was English, the next French, &c.

Perhaps what Stross is intimating is that we'd be better off if Wales was Wales, Normandy Normany, &c, and that instead of the church, we devise some more sensible extranational force to implement the social contract across all those small nations.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday September 08, 2014 @09:39PM (#8288319)
Borders were not fluid and influenced by outside powers for real nations. Nobody moved China's or Rome's or Assyria's borders until they lost battles. Or Prussia's for that matter. Westphalia was an agreement within a closely related ethnic and cultural zone (the crusader pals) for superpowers to not to push around the weaker nations quite so much. It's a temporal european footnote that attached some semantics to the specifically european concept of "the state" (not "nation"). In the broader reality of human history, a nation is a related group of people who can drive people off their land and keep them out, or at least subjugate others to dhimmitude. If you can't do that you will inevitably be conquered. Consider texas for a recent example. No magical international bureaucracy can prevent that in the long run.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by ghaff on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:35PM (#8287071)
Note however that EU != Schengen zone. (Though there's more to control of borders than simply crossing borders without immigration checks.) In fact, UK border checks are relatively strict even for other EU citizens.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by jsnell on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:15PM (#8287330)
The strictest UK border check I've gone through in a few years was putting my (EU) passport into an automated passport reader and looking into a camera for 5 seconds.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by nbouscal on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:21PM (#8286634)
That's an interesting choice of example state given New Hampshire's significant role in primary elections.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by notahacker on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:48PM (#8286808)
The tendency of a few states (including a handful of very small ones) to get disproportionate attention at the federal level (and sometimes accompanying pork-barrel policies) is a bug rather than a feature of the US system.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by smacktoward on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:07PM (#8286923)
There's nothing inherent in the American election system that requires New Hampshire and Iowa to get the attention they do. That's strictly an artifact of how the parties have chosen to schedule their primary calendars; New Hampshire and Iowa happened to be put first in the schedule, and people started paying more attention to them on the theory that winning these early primaries could start a snowball effect of support in the later ones.

Either party could choose any time it wants to reshuffle their primary calendar and move some other states before NH and IA, or to hold all their primaries at once on the same day. There's just not much pressure on them to do so, so inertia keeps them where they are.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by maxerickson on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:45PM (#8287129)
The state parties set the dates. Of course the national parties can influence that, but there is no cohesive group mandating the dates.

A not very talked about aspect of U.S. politics is how much influence peddling is possible at that level.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by baddox on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:03PM (#8286900)
But they still can't make treaties with foreign nations, raise a military, mint coins, or any of several other things generally associated with sovereign nations.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by baddox on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:07PM (#8286924)
As opposed to being part of the UK, which is part of the EU nation?
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by sentenza on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:54PM (#8287187)
Not for long.

As a continental European, I'd be quite surprised if the UK voted to stay in the EU in the 2017 referendum. There is just so much hatred for the EU coming out of the UK that by now, its leaving almost seems a forgone conclusion.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @05:11AM (#8289293)
As a Brit (English, living in Scotland), I'd say that there is a way to go before that and would make two points:

1) there is only one party promising that referendum and they're behind in the polls

2) current polls say that we'd vote to stay (http://yougov.co.uk/news/2014/06/17/eu-referendum-record-lea...), even before any renegotiation. There are other polls which have said otherwise but YouGov provide an on-going tracker which I think shows that, while the level of support has changed, broadly we still support EU membership.

Obviously all very uncertain (and until a couple of weeks ago polls were sure Scotland would stay in the UK) but I'd say that you shouldn't confuse the volume of some of the negative views on Europe with them being a consensus - most people are quietly happy with the status quo.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by dragonwriter on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:32PM (#8287051)
> Smaller nations sounds nice but in the intermediate term reality Scotland would become a minor province of the EU nation.

If it's admitted at all, which is far from certain.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:37PM (#8287083)
> If it's admitted (to the EU) at all, which is far from certain.

I don't see why it would not be admitted. The EU is not in the habit of turning down that kind of country: wealthy, peaceful, of Christian heritage and adjoining several EU countries.

And if you want to play that game, it's not certain that England will remain in the EU. An independent Scotland could well end up the only part of Britain left in the EU. Yes that would be a crashingly stupid thing for Britain to collectively do. But it's not impossible.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by dragonwriter on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:52PM (#8287171)
> I don't see why it would not be admitted.

Inability to come to mutually agreeable terms -- Scotlands wants (1) essentially automatic admission without the normal new state process, and (2) to keep the UK's special exemption for using the sterling, and (3) to get part of the UK's rebates.

AFAICT, much of the rest of the EU is opposed to all three of those. Spain is particularly opposed to the first (and possibly to Scottish admission at all), because an independent Scotland getting into the EU, especially on fast-track process, is seen as encouraging Catalonian independence.

> The EU is not in the habit of turning down that kind of country: wealthy, peaceful, of Christian heritage and adjoining several EU countries.

First, I think you are considering the wrong category: the category of interest is "states having recently broken away from existing EU member-states", particularly as the UK isn't the only EU member with regions that have some pro-independence sentiments, and admitting such a breakaway state is something that states that have their own aspiring breakaway regions are likely to see as providing encouragement to those breakaway regions.

Also, an independent Scotland would be adjoining exactly one other country (the UK), and one of the reasons that seems to keep being cited for it leaving is that, even with Scotland still in the UK and exerting pro-EU pressure, the future of the UK in the EU is locally considered less than certain, so I'm not sure where you get that "adjoining several EU countries" is a fair description.

> And if you want to play that game, it's not certain that England will remain in the EU.

Of course its not; I don't dispute that at all.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:20PM (#8287358)
> Also, an independent Scotland would be adjoining exactly one other country (the UK)

For certain values of adjoining. They have been making common cause with the nearby Nordic countries. I was going to add Ireland but only the UK part of it is actually visible from Scotland. Carndonagh, Republic of Ireland to Port Ellen, Islay is only 50 miles as the crow flies. There's EU to be found to due East, West and South of Scotland; you can't say that it's not in-amongst the EU.

The "no fast track" argument is I think one of those "will be settled in a few years anyway" arguments that cstross dismisses; there is a plan b to the fast track and it is the regular track.

The argument about the dangers of breakaways regions to other EU states is something that bears watching; it remains to be seen how strong it is in Brussels.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by glomph on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:38PM (#8287465)
It is not as clear as that what Spain would do. García-Margallo later said Spain would have “nothing to say” if Scotland got independence.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by cmdkeen on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:21PM (#8287369)
It's not about whether it gets turned down - it is what all the constituent countries get out of the negotiations - because each one has a veto.

Spain for instance would I'm sure be very interested in the fisheries policies in Scottish waters, something to buy off the Catalans. Belgium (another country with worries about secession movements) might have something to say about Anglo-Saxon capitalism, France certainly will. Germany will want to be strict about budget deficits.

Other countries have agendas that don't perfectly align to Scotland's. They have what we want, and Scotland would have a deadline, that isn't the best position in the world to negotiate from.

If you care about independence at (almost) any price then it shouldn't matter, but it is clear the SNP don't believe a majority of voters do.