News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 08, 2014 @03:46PM (#8286792)
The UK has a government that spends tax revenues raised in the UK on stuff people in [some parts of] the UK don't want.

A new country called Scotland will it seems have a government that spends tax revenues raised in Scotland on stuff people in [some parts of] Scotland don't want. If you lived in a tax raising city state then your city would do the same thing.

If you didn't want an extra tier of government then why vote for one? We could have saved £414 million in one swoop on that.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by smsm42 on Monday September 08, 2014 @05:12PM (#8287309)
One could argue that the smaller the government is and the more local the taxes are, less is the percentage spent on the things inhabitants of this locality do not want. Example: if you raise taxes on city level, then spending decisions are influenced only by people living in your city, and the chance it would be spent on building an airport in the next county that nobody flies from, to suit some politician, are much less. OTOH, if all the taxes are collected by a huge central government, the chances that you will disagree with a lot of its spending are much higher.

Of course, the hybrid model is possible - with only taxes that are needed specifically for big things - like national defense - collected on hight level, and taxes needed for local things - like police, roads, schools, etc. - collected on the lower levels. That's how the federalism works.

Re:On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-West... by wisty on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:29PM (#8287038)
The main problem is, revenue and spending are rarely done by the same people.

The UK can blame the Scottish Parliament on reckless spending, and be forced to raise taxes. A local government can recklessly spend (or neglect infrastructure), and force the Scottish to bail them out. Should a state government fight to create jobs (even if it annoys special interest groups), or just rely on welfare from the federal government?

If there's a government that is in charge of major infrastructure, health, education, social welfare, and taxes, then there's far less buck passing.

States spend the big bucks, so states should be responsible for raising the big bucks.

The other problem is that people only care about the highest level of government. Probably because it's more efficient for news organisations to only report on the Federal level (since the story will be more widely read).

Look at the US. It seems that virtually everything gets blamed on Obama or the House, despite the fact that the real decisions are generally done at the state level, with far less scrutiny, because it's cheaper for the newspapers to just send a single correspondent to Washington, and report on what's going on there.

I don't even know the current Premier (governor, in US terms) of my state. Not since a "memory lapse" in front of a corruption inquiry forced the last one out a few months ago, after the previous party lost a string of premiers also due to corruption - I just can't keep up.

So there's two problems - no-one cares about anything other than the top level of politics (since the papers are all national now, and it's more efficient to just look at what happens at the Federal level), and there's too much buck passing between the level of government that has the money, and the level of government that spends it.