News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exploding Offers Suck by DanBlake on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:22PM (#8286332)
Im sure a ton of the companies who apply to YC and dont get in are still Grade A. But you have to trust YC knows what they are doing, and the A+++ companies will be picked over before they hit second or third tier.

You have to remember that investing in companies is a lottery game. Most angels/vc's profits are made on that 1 in a million company with a 1000x return.

If YC wants access to truly the best companies, they need to institute a rolling admissions. Otherwise, these scrappy second tier incubators will get lucky a few times when a nervous founder takes a bird in the hand over two in the bush. The policy only hurts YC itself.

Re:Exploding Offers Suck by brk on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:47PM (#8286465)
But you have to trust YC knows what they are doing, and the A+++ companies will be picked over before they hit second or third tier.

IMO, there is still too much luck involved to make this true to the extent it matters in this case. YC has picked several things that didn't pan out, and of course several that did. There have also been multiple follow ups from YC rejects that went on to be much more successful than some companies that WERE picked

Re:Exploding Offers Suck by yid on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:39PM (#8286417)
> But you have to trust YC knows what they are doing, and the A+++ companies will be picked over before they hit second or third tier.

If this were true, YC would be the size of Exxon. Picking A+++ companies is a heuristic.

Re:Exploding Offers Suck by mikedmiked on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @05:35AM (#8289354)
> 1 in a million company with a 1000x return

Sounds like a terrible expected ROI ;)

Re:Exploding Offers Suck by kyteland on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @09:28AM (#8289983)
Not if you can selectively winnow through and take the 100 best. Then it's a guaranteed home run.