News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by colinbartlett on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:14PM (#8282250)
All of these analyses of how they might have located the server are great. I'm pleased to see folks trying to prove or disprove that the FBI is not trying some parallel construction here.

But what worries me is that all of this will have to be eventually dumbed down to an explanation that a jury of average joes can understand. The increasingly technical complexity of evidence in some of these cases worries me that our system doesn't have an adequate way to deal with it.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by dobbsbob on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:18PM (#8282260)
They probably won't argue this in front of a jury since it's a pre-trial motion to challenge the evidence the FBI collected. No idea how a judge will understand this, I guess they bring in experts to testify if the FBI's claim is possible or not.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by cookiecaper on Sunday September 07, 2014 @09:20PM (#8283046)
I share that concern in general (and in particular with regard to software patent cases, which often cover highly technical material and where the jury has no context about the novelty of the patented inventions), but I think this case is pretty much a slam dunk however you approach it. Regardless of how they obtained the IP, they got to the box to find it running Silk Road code, they got to the box's owner to find him holding Silk Road bitcoins, etc.

This isn't a case that hinges on a technical nuance. It will be practically impossible for DPR to convince a jury that there is any reasonable doubt as to his guilt.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by roel_v on Sunday September 07, 2014 @10:06PM (#8283137)
If the evidence was obtained using illegal methods, all that evidence can't be presented at trial and the jurors can't take that information into account when deciding guilty or not. There are many people who are acquitted for things they obviously did, but for which there is no formal legal way of proving it.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by spindritf on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:56AM (#8283916)
If the evidence was obtained using illegal methods, all that evidence can't be presented

Isn't that for the judge to decide? Judge decides what can be presented to the jury, and jury renders the verdict, right?

Then the argument doesn't need to be dumbed down for the jury. They won't see it at all.

Although the argument will still probably have to be dumbed down for the judge.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by gambiting on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:02AM (#8284034)
Nope. A judge cannot decide to admit an illegally obtained evidence, no matter what it is.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by spindritf on Monday September 08, 2014 @06:38AM (#8284103)
OK but he gets to decide if it was illegally obtained.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by _archon_ on Monday September 08, 2014 @02:55PM (#8286512)
This is decided in pretrial hearings. There have been entire cases based on the admissibility of evidence. If the judge rules it is or is not admissible, there is some manner of recourse or escalation for the usurped party. IANAL YMMV BBQ
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by akerl_ on Sunday September 07, 2014 @09:54PM (#8283121)
Except that if they obtained the IP illegally, and the defense can prove it, all the evidence obtained based on that is thrown out. Which is why they're pursuing it so vigorously: as you've noted, it's the code they found on the box and the bitcoins they found by finding the box's owner that pin him so severely.
Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by PeterisP on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @03:51PM (#8292399)
Wouldn't the only evidence obtained through that hack be the actual IP and related data?

I mean, the actual box was presumably seized after a proper warrant for searching a specific physical location. The question is would the fact that his stuff was searched be considered "fruit of the poisoned tree" since the servers were identified through that IP or as "inevitable discovery" since if he's a suspect, it's standard procedure to search his stuff anyways. But IANAL so I'm not sure how it works in USA.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by gwern on Monday September 08, 2014 @11:01AM (#8285122)
> But what worries me is that all of this will have to be eventually dumbed down to an explanation that a jury of average joes can understand.

Not necessarily. They could give up the right to a jury trial and go for a bench/judge trial. That's often done in complex or technical cases (the reasoning being that, despite the pro-state biases, better to appeal to an experienced and known-intelligent person like a judge than to risk the prejudices of the common man).

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by ptaipale on Monday September 08, 2014 @04:50AM (#8283902)
<i>The increasingly technical complexity of evidence in some of these cases worries me that our system doesn't have an adequate way to deal with it. reply</i>

Indeed. Then, "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic", and you have some ingredients for a witch-hunt.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by lifeisstillgood on Sunday September 07, 2014 @06:00PM (#8282570)
Honestly I have no worries about this or any other "technical" issue like financial fraud cases. If a cop can learn enough to catch someone then it is possible to explain that to a nurse or an electrician.

Jurors don't switch off because they are learning how to move money between banks or break into servers - they switch off because it takes three months to present a case.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by EpicEng on Sunday September 07, 2014 @08:56PM (#8282987)
> If a cop can learn enough to catch someone then it is possible to explain that to a nurse or an electrician.

You think a cop did this? No... the FBI has technical personnel. Just like any corporation, they have different departments to fulfill different needs.

Re:Analyzing the FBI’s Explanation of How They Located Silk ... by lifeisstillgood on Monday September 08, 2014 @01:43AM (#8283565)
Not quite what I meant - no I don't think cops were writing SQLi but they learnt enough to laugh at Little Bobby Tables, just as they can learn enough to follow the money through 17 bank accounts.

This is the equivalent of is the FBI allowed to search my trash if the trash is in a trashcan on my property or on the sidewalk, being pulled by a street cleaner or knocked over by a fox. We can make it as complicated as we like but the law needs to draw some lines somewhere and stick to them.