News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by skybrian on Sunday September 07, 2014 @03:24PM (#8282116)
I'll probably get downvoted for this, but I'm ashamed of Randal Monroe for asking for such a crazy deadline and Max for agreeing to it.

This is an art project. Randal can set his own deadlines. There is no reason to ask someone to work crazy sleep-deprived hours for it, even if they volunteer. He's doing the same thing a bad boss would do, with less justification than most.

Writing it up afterwords sets a bad example for other impressionable young hackers who look up to these guys and will set themselves up for being exploited when they go to work because they think it's expected of them.

I couldn't finish the article. I'm sure there are good hacks in it. But we have to stop promoting bad behavior. If we can't do this ourselves for art, what about when there's real pressure?

Update: to clarify, there's nothing unusual about this and there far worse examples all the time. It's just a bit striking since Randal's image is of a somewhat otherworldly idealist.

Backpedal #2: to avoid being overly dramatic, let me clarify that being ashamed of someone else's behavior implies that you feel some responsibility for their behavior, which doesn't make sense in this case. Also, not finishing an article is, to be honest, not all that unusual.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by chromakode on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:58PM (#8282393)
Thanks for making this point. I wholeheartedly agree.

I didn't anticipate this response. You're absolutely right about taking responsibility for the example we set of project management. I personally hate pulling all-nighters, and did not intend to legitimize the unhealthy "larval stage" hacker culture archetype (re: http://modelviewculture.com/pieces/the-open-source-identity-...).

This was a project with crazy bounds that we all consented to sprint towards. We are a team that has worked on many projects together across years, and are wholly comfortable with each others' constraints and limits.

It's usually the case for our projects that inspiration arrives at the most inconvenient time. For this one in particular, the idea came up 3 days before launch. We had several discussions during those days where we could have pulled the plug on this due to scheduling concerns. Each of us decided to push forward because we wanted it to exist.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by skybrian on Sunday September 07, 2014 @06:10PM (#8282610)
Thanks for your response!

It seems like the basic idea could be used for anything. There's nothing about zooming that makes it particularly appropriate for a book launch; a simple comic would do to mark the occasion and Pixels could have launched later. So the use of this idea for this project is a choice and the deadline is entirely self-imposed.

(Also I do enjoy the occasional hackathon, though I won't stay up late for it. I'll stay up late for entirely different and probably just as bad reasons.)

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by csirac2 on Monday September 08, 2014 @08:53AM (#8284435)
This is perhaps the wrong place to discuss, but reading Noah's piece you just linked seems just a little narrow-minded... Given the struggles I see to recruit and retain contributors (who overwhelmingly $work to 17:30 and take school holidays), I'm left wondering truly how many open source projects (maybe the top 0.00001%?) can really afford to (let alone actively engage in) building their existence around these pathologies.
Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by beambot on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:13PM (#8282247)
I don't disagree with the sentiment (hiphip-hurrah for better planning!). But in this case, I'm not sure we have sufficient information to claim malice.

Perhaps they only came up with the idea 3 days before Colbert? Perhaps Colbert asked (last minute) for a cool, new, live demo? Perhaps they were just being opportunistic, and this turned into one of those unforeseen firedrill moments? Externalities being what they are, they did a bang up job of pulling it off in time.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by skybrian on Sunday September 07, 2014 @04:26PM (#8282298)
You're of course right that we don't know the real story, just what it looks like. However, asking an artist for an original work of art in order to promote their book on your show seems like a rather unlikely request.

Also I'm not assuming malice. However, I wouldn't congratulate them for pulling it off; this is itself encouraging the wrong thing.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by alexqgb on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:25AM (#8283441)
In general, TV people have absolutely no idea what's involved with coding. Accordingly, they're likely to assume that it's much easier than it actually is, not realizing that their "simple" request may involve a fairly complex process to deliver.

Ironically enough, they get this principle when it comes to other people's misconceptions about television. Very few people have any idea how much time and effort goes in to film and broadcast production. Producers are constantly fielding requests from clients, executives, and others with limited technical skill who say things like "Can't you just..." or "I don't see why we don't just..." or "How about just...?".

You get the picture.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by beambot on Sunday September 07, 2014 @07:38PM (#8282824)
TV producers asking for original functionality (or art) is par for the course. When I did live robot demos on CNN, they asked me to code up some new functionality to display in the commercial break transition (surreal coding on the newsroom floor ensued). If Picaso were alive today... yep, on-the-fly napkin sketches.
Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by jakejake on Sunday September 07, 2014 @05:23PM (#8282472)
I agree 100% with your feelings, and on top of that I find it to be a bit of humble-brag when I hear people talking about how much sleep they skipped to hit a deadline.

I have to bust ass once in a while to hit a deadline, but I always consider that a failure of my project planning. I get psyched about hitting a deadline without a single hour of overtime from any member of the team - to me that is something to brag about.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by vinceguidry on Sunday September 07, 2014 @08:54PM (#8282982)
I dunno. Art plays by different rules. The opportunity to make art is often fleeting, inspiration is a harsh mistress.

It's easy to expect more out of artists. Good artists make finished works look easy, even when it could never have been. It's much harder to appreciate the insane number of constraints that come baked into every single project whose only judgment and exposure comes in that 5 second time between when you first see it and when you get bored of it and click to the next thing in your feed.

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by skybrian on Sunday September 07, 2014 @09:46PM (#8283108)
Well, except that I'm not actually trying to add a constraint. I'm trying to relax a constraint. As a member of the audience, I'm saying: hey, don't kill yourself over making this neat toy for my amusement. I don't actually want you to do that. Take all the time you need. Don't worry, I'm sure it will be great and it will show up in my feed whenever it's ready. (And maybe I should have said that in the first place.)

But of course they never asked me. Any pressure they feel comes from the imaginary audience in their heads.

How much this resembles the actual audience (which, admittedly, can be harsh, fickle and are easily distracted - guilty!) is hard to say.

Taking a broader perspective, there are of course far worse problems in the world, the sort of thing the Fair Trade advocates worry about. Demonstrated demand for consumer goods is quite a force, in aggregate. Who wants to be a millionare?

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by mhb on Monday September 08, 2014 @07:32AM (#8284216)
To achieve great things, two things are needed: a plan, and not quite enough time.

Leonard Bernstein

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by qq66 on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:03AM (#8283388)
People who make their living by their art need to treat their art as a business, and set deadlines like any other business.
Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by alexqgb on Monday September 08, 2014 @12:19AM (#8283422)
Actually, not every business has schedule as their top priority. That's true of most R&D efforts, and it's especially true of creative endeavors, which tend to be (in NASA parlance) "discovery driven missions."

It comes down to cheap, fast, and good. You can pick any two you like. If you're lucky, you'll get both, so you better be sure to note which matters most, because honestly, that's what's going to drive everything else. This is especially true of non-routine work, like much of art in general. Creative businesses that make a priority of hitting deadlines must either have very deep pockets, or enough latitude to ship sub-par product.

A great example of this is the Clock of the Long Now, which is being designed and built by Danny Hillis. This is a clock that is designed to run for 10,000 years. Quality is job one. Right now, they have about $43 million to work with (supplied by Jeff Bezos). When people ask when it will be ready, they say "we don't know." Pressed for a ballpark figure, the answer is simple: "No."

Re:Notes on XKCD's “Pixels” by hammock on Sunday September 07, 2014 @06:25PM (#8282652)
Who knows if it ever would have gotten done without the pressure of a deadline? I know they help me.