It rarely helps them and often makes their lives much worse. If they need something so desperately (food, shelter, etc), private charity or government assistance seems like a better means of providing it than payday lenders.
http://bucks.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/27/why-borrowers-use-...
The only issue is not having something that gives you enough collateral to get the loan in the first place.
The real problem isn't the loan itself, even if it seems exploitative: if someone is in a cash crunch, it's perfectly rational to pay something like $20 to get $200 today (that seems to be what places near me advertise, at least as introductory rates) so they can pay their rent and not be evicted. The problem is the cycle they get into where then they're $20 behind for the next one. Then they get another loan and they're $40 behind for the next one, and so on.
So you catch people that are already in the cycle, fix their immediate need (they need $200 to pay their rent), then help them figure out a way to solve the larger problem (have cash on hand in time for next month's rent) and break out of the cycle.
So the 'mission' of the shop would become to put themselves and all other payday loan shops in the area out of business due to a lack of customers.
Of course, this assumes that the root problem is a lack of planning or education about personal finance. Maybe an outsider's perspective would help. Or maybe that's completely the wrong assumptions, I don't know.
I feel like it's similar to how credit unions do what banks do, but in their customers' interest rather than the owners.
You would have a very difficult time attracting customers. Ignoring the fact that much of the payday loan industry is run by organized crime and you would likely end up with a bullet in the back of your head, even if it were totally safe you would get very little advantage from offering a lower interest rate. Studies have shown that people in economic trouble are not capable of making wise choices. It's commonly referred to as 'decision fatigue'.
I'm guessing geographical location is the biggest factor in influencing their 'choice' of payday loan shop to use, so it would be a matter of taking advantage of that decision fatigue to help them without them realizing it.
So what's the solution to this problem? Clearly a lot of (maybe all) of the payday loan-type places are evil -- is there a way to service these customers without being evil? Would a not-for-profit (or perhaps even a not-for-an-exorbitant-profit) payday loan organization be possible? Or would the typical nasty collections process, the thousands of dollars of interest on a $500 loan still be required, even if the people at the top weren't becoming millionaires?
I guess what I'm asking is, in the story, we see someone paying something like $3900 on a $700 loan, made by one of these evil companies. What would their total bill be if the loan was made by a non-profit organization? Would it be more like $1000, or still closer to $3900?