It turns out that the vast majority of HFT are algorithmic market makers. Why is that? Because if they can trade more they are more profitable (if they are good at market making). This means that they can make less on each trade driving down the bid/ask spread which is good for everyone. Further, if they can reduce their risk by trading fast, then they don't have to price that risk into the spread once again making the price better for everyone.
You can't separate hft from algorithmic market making because it is a central driving premise of the industry.
Algorithmic traders compete on price: they aim to offer better prices, and narrower spreads, to liquidity consumers.
High-frequency traders compete on the speed, with which orders are placed. The parasitic traders are the ones who profit not by providing you with a service, but by taking advantage of your inability to place and remove orders as quickly as they can.
You can do both of these at the same time, but the two competitive advantages are different and separate.
Market making is what all this activity is supposed to do, because it is a service provided by the liquidity providers, through the exchanges, to the liquidity consumers.
I think the distinctions are clear enough.
If market maker A wants to compete on price and provide liquidity at $10.003/10.049, too bad. That's illegal. He must compete on speed instead.
I wrote some tutorials on mechanics of this a while back, you might find them useful:
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology.html
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology2.html
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.html
Unless the allocation is pro-rata, but it usually isn't.
Price and speed are closely intertwined.
It's good to mix in a large dose of almost-zero-profit market making trades in with your more ethically and legally dubious trades. It helps cover your tracks - both from regulators and other market participants.
Please just come out and say what you think HFT is, how it works and why it is ethically or legally dubious, because your claims in this thread border on the hysterical.
In general, if you know important information about someone else's positions, you can sometimes use that information to profitably trade against them.
>A classic aggressive strategy involves hunting and trapping “whales.” It is a good example of aggressive HFT strategy.
I apologize for not explaining terminology used by the financial community in laymans' terms.
After reading this article your assertion is that it is unethical and/or illegal for market makers to use standard market orders that are filled in legal and standard ways as price information signals, but it is not illegal and/or unethical for large market participants to hide their order flow with specialized orders and/or venues?
It is describing a commonly used HFT trading strategy in objective terms. Your ad hominem attack on their credentials and agenda does not change this.
>After reading this article your assertion is that it is unethical and/or illegal for market makers to use standard market orders that are filled in legal and standard ways as price information signals, but it is not illegal and/or unethical for large market participants to hide their order flow with specialized orders and/or venues?
What was just described is detecting a large institutional order through the use of 'pinging' trades and then effectively taking advantage of that knowledge by trading ahead of it. That is NOT market making.
It is not strictly speaking insider trading or front running either, but it combines features of both practices.
An ad hominem attack assumes that my attack is based on an irrelevant fact about the arguer. That the arguer has no experience in, and cannot articulate a common description of the issue in question is not an ad hominem attack. Just like saying that I have no basis in describing rabbinical law and should therefore not be determining what is and is not kosher, me saying that your source doesn't know what they are talking about when it comes to electronic trading is what is important.
"What was just described is detecting a large institutional order through the use of 'pinging' trades and then effectively taking advantage of that knowledge by trading ahead of it."
What is described in that article is 1 market participant, using a well known and perfectly legal market means to send in orders that they want to trade and then extrapolating from the completion of those orders, information about another participant that is using highly exclusionary, extra-market venues (dark pools) to hide their desire to change the price of an instrument.
That you think the market participant that is most disadvantaged in this relationship should be penalized more says more about your biases than anything else in the market dynamic.
But the high-frequency aspect of it is separate from the algorithmic-trading aspect of it, so one can criticise high-frequency trading for its uselessness, while accepting that algorithmic trading is hugely beneficial.