News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:00AM (#8268620)
You might like to read Matt Levine's article on Barclays. Choice quote:

Barclays, like other dark pool operators, knew this: that you can run a pristine dark pool without "predatory" high frequency traders, and without much trading, or you can run a useful dark pool with high-frequency traders.

http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-06-26/barclays-no...

tl;dr; No HFT, no liquidity, and people who want to trade take their business elsewhere.

[edit: If Barclays didn't need to bring HFTs in to provide liquidity, why did they subsidize HFTs? Matt Levine crunches the numbers - the biggest HFTs paid Barclays about $3M assuming a wild overestimate of the amount of liquidity they take, compared to institutional investors paying $4B.]

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:17AM (#8268737)
Exchanges subsidise market-making, because that is the unquestionably beneficial activity.

But the high-frequency aspect of it is separate from the algorithmic-trading aspect of it, so one can criticise high-frequency trading for its uselessness, while accepting that algorithmic trading is hugely beneficial.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:29AM (#8268814)
You are acting like algorithmic/hft/market making terms are clearly defined.

It turns out that the vast majority of HFT are algorithmic market makers. Why is that? Because if they can trade more they are more profitable (if they are good at market making). This means that they can make less on each trade driving down the bid/ask spread which is good for everyone. Further, if they can reduce their risk by trading fast, then they don't have to price that risk into the spread once again making the price better for everyone.

You can't separate hft from algorithmic market making because it is a central driving premise of the industry.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:36AM (#8268856)
I think you can separate them perfectly well.

Algorithmic traders compete on price: they aim to offer better prices, and narrower spreads, to liquidity consumers.

High-frequency traders compete on the speed, with which orders are placed. The parasitic traders are the ones who profit not by providing you with a service, but by taking advantage of your inability to place and remove orders as quickly as they can.

You can do both of these at the same time, but the two competitive advantages are different and separate.

Market making is what all this activity is supposed to do, because it is a service provided by the liquidity providers, through the exchanges, to the liquidity consumers.

I think the distinctions are clear enough.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:41AM (#8268893)
Market makers compete with each other on speed. If market maker A and B both want to provide you liquidity at $10.00/10.05, whichever one is fastest will be the one to get your business.

If market maker A wants to compete on price and provide liquidity at $10.003/10.049, too bad. That's illegal. He must compete on speed instead.

I wrote some tutorials on mechanics of this a while back, you might find them useful:

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology.html

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology2.html

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.html

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by dllthomas on Thursday September 04, 2014 @01:41PM (#8269577)
"If market maker A and B both want to provide you liquidity at $10.00/10.05, whichever one is fastest will be the one to get your business."

Unless the allocation is pro-rata, but it usually isn't.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by harryh on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:50AM (#8268935)
By being very fast at taking into account new information as fast as possible market makers reduce their risk, thus allowing them to offer better prices.

Price and speed are closely intertwined.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:52AM (#8268946)
The vast majority of HFT trades are market making - with razor thin margins. The vast majority of profit making trades do not involve market making, however - they usually involve trading on an information advantages, or spearing a whale (large institutional investor trying to buy or sell large amounts of stock).

It's good to mix in a large dose of almost-zero-profit market making trades in with your more ethically and legally dubious trades. It helps cover your tracks - both from regulators and other market participants.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:57PM (#8269351)
Do you have a citation for this? What does "spearing a whale" even mean? What is ethically or legally dubious about electronic market making?

Please just come out and say what you think HFT is, how it works and why it is ethically or legally dubious, because your claims in this thread border on the hysterical.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by conistonwater on Thursday September 04, 2014 @01:17PM (#8269455)
There was a rather famous incident with a trader nicknamed "London Whale", who accumulated a massive position in the CDS market, which then led JPMorgan Chase to lose immense amounts of money on the trade. The money went to those people that correctly figured out what was going on in the market.

In general, if you know important information about someone else's positions, you can sometimes use that information to profitably trade against them.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @01:46PM (#8269607)
The London Whale did not involve HFT. In fact, it is a rather good example of how little HFT matters in the world of finance. One division at Chase (and if you believe them 1 man) cost the company more in 1 year than HFT makes in profits. The other sides of that trade were not HFT firms, but other human driven trading funds. So of course information advantages allow you to make money, that's the point of the market and it is no more unethical or illegal when an HFT makes money than it is when those human traders were on the other side of the London Whale.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:32PM (#8272189)
http://www.demos.org/publication/cracks-pipeline-part-two-hi...

>A classic aggressive strategy involves hunting and trapping “whales.” It is a good example of aggressive HFT strategy.

I apologize for not explaining terminology used by the financial community in laymans' terms.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:47PM (#8272226)
This blog article has huge technical problems and is not a financial community technical journal. It is in fact a political blog with it's own agenda to push. Even without these giant warning signs what they describe in this article is not illegal or unethical.

After reading this article your assertion is that it is unethical and/or illegal for market makers to use standard market orders that are filled in legal and standard ways as price information signals, but it is not illegal and/or unethical for large market participants to hide their order flow with specialized orders and/or venues?

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:04AM (#8272271)
>It is in fact a political blog with it's own agenda to push.

It is describing a commonly used HFT trading strategy in objective terms. Your ad hominem attack on their credentials and agenda does not change this.

>After reading this article your assertion is that it is unethical and/or illegal for market makers to use standard market orders that are filled in legal and standard ways as price information signals, but it is not illegal and/or unethical for large market participants to hide their order flow with specialized orders and/or venues?

What was just described is detecting a large institutional order through the use of 'pinging' trades and then effectively taking advantage of that knowledge by trading ahead of it. That is NOT market making.

It is not strictly speaking insider trading or front running either, but it combines features of both practices.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:38AM (#8272335)
"Your ad hominem attack on their credentials and agenda does not change this."

An ad hominem attack assumes that my attack is based on an irrelevant fact about the arguer. That the arguer has no experience in, and cannot articulate a common description of the issue in question is not an ad hominem attack. Just like saying that I have no basis in describing rabbinical law and should therefore not be determining what is and is not kosher, me saying that your source doesn't know what they are talking about when it comes to electronic trading is what is important.

"What was just described is detecting a large institutional order through the use of 'pinging' trades and then effectively taking advantage of that knowledge by trading ahead of it."

What is described in that article is 1 market participant, using a well known and perfectly legal market means to send in orders that they want to trade and then extrapolating from the completion of those orders, information about another participant that is using highly exclusionary, extra-market venues (dark pools) to hide their desire to change the price of an instrument.

That you think the market participant that is most disadvantaged in this relationship should be penalized more says more about your biases than anything else in the market dynamic.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:04AM (#8268649)
You do not need to sell privileged access to HFTs to your dark pool of institutional investors in order to have liquidity.

Barclays were ripping off their clients. It wasn't even a complicated scam.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:19AM (#8268753)
"You do not need to sell privileged access to HFTs to your dark pool of institutional investors in order to have liquidity."

Except that is untrue historically. The reason dark pools sell that privileged access is that they can't provide liquidity any other way and their clients find it better to trade in HFT allowed environments than in ones without liquidity.

IEX is trying something new, driving liquidity via scare tactics and publicity but we still don't know how that will work out.

"Barclays were ripping off their clients. It wasn't even a complicated scam."

Barclay's lied about allowing HFT firms into their dark pool. That is fraud but it has nothing to do with bad behavior on the part of the HFT. If you are suggesting that dark pools have inherent conflicts of interest that might be a more valid argument than "HFT IS THE EVILS"

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:03PM (#8269020)
>Except that is untrue historically.

Historically there was no HFT. Historically we have managed to have liquidity without it. Historically, the thing that brought us the greatest liquidity (something that is useful but vastly overrated) in the equities markets is electronic trading.

>The reason dark pools sell that privileged access is that they can't provide liquidity

I think it's cute the way that you're pretending that they were doing their investors a favor. They were selling dark pools to investors because investors WANTED to get away from HFT. If they wanted HFT infested waters they could have traded on the public markets!

What the fuck do you think they were DOING there in the first place? They happily sacrificed a sliver of extra (and largely unnecessary) liquidity for the chance to not get ripped off.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @01:42PM (#8269586)
They thought they wanted to get away from HFT. But once they were away from HFT they realized that the liquidity wasn't there and started trading on other venues. Barclay's dark pool was failing as it had no participation and like almost all the other dark pools in existence to get around this they started letting HFTs in.

The difference is that in Barclay's case they lied about it and thus committed fraud.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:04PM (#8272106)
>They thought they wanted to get away from HFT. But once they were away from HFT they realized

THEY WERE PAYING TO BE IN A DARK POOL IN THE FIRST PLACE BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO BE AWAY FROM HFT. There was no "they realized".

Once they got away, Barclays tried to figure out if there was any BARCLAYS could extract more profits from these dark pools than the fees they were already paid. There was: allow HFT sharks to take advantage of their customers and collect fees for letting them do so.

If what you said were true (and frankly I cannot possibly see how you could believe it) they would have ZERO reason to commit fraud and lie about selling privileged access to HFT traders.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:22PM (#8272160)
"Once they got away they did NOT start whinging that there was not enough liquidity."

Of course they didn't. Professional market participants don't whinge. They go to venues that provide the services they want, namely cheap liquidity. Those venues were ones that allowed HFT market makers.

When you say "they got away", you do know that those market participants moved to open exchanges where HFTs "run rampant" and stopped paying Barclay's for their service.

"allow HFT sharks to take advantage of their customers and collect payment for letting them do so."

A) what do you mean when you say HFT shark? You keep using that term, in what I assume is a pejorative but it doesn't mean anything.

B) If the point was extracting more fees why did Barclay's subsidize HFT trading? They charged HFTs an order of magnitude less than their clients, that was a central part of the complain. If it was an example of allowing advantage taking, wouldn't the fee structure be reversed? That is, if I have a chance to fleece someone, wouldn't I pay up for that instead of require payment for it?

"If what you said were true they would have no reason to lie"

Of course they had a reason to lie. They claimed that they could provide a high liquidity environment without letting market makers trade in their dark pool, despite the overwhelming historical evidence to the contrary. Admitting that they were wrong brings their whole value proposition to buy side investors into question and delegitimizes their dark pool.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:43PM (#8272220)
>Of course they didn't. Professional market participants don't whinge. They go to venues that provide the services they want, namely cheap liquidity.

If they prioritized liquidity above all else, as you appear to think they should, they wouldn't be using a dark pool in the first place. They would have been using a public exchange.

>When you say "they got away", you do know that those market participants moved to open exchanges where HFTs "run rampant" and stopped paying Barclay's for their service.

Yes, I'm sure they all left after it was revealed that Barclays was lying to them and allowing HFT predation on their trading activity.

>what do you mean when you say HFT shark?

An HFT trader that parasitically extracts value from a non-HFT traders - often institutional investors (e.g. pension funds) putting through large orders. The link I put below describing a 'whale' to you explains just one parasitic strategy.

>If the point was extracting more fees why did Barclay's subsidize HFT trading? They charged HFTs an order of magnitude less than their clients

A) Subsidizing != Charging lower fees B) Citation, please (that OVERALL fees were higher, not just fees per trade - HFT will obviously get bulk discounts).

>that was a central part of the complain.

The central part of the complaint was that the service was advertised as HFT free when, in fact, it was not. The marketing literature is all out there saying this.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by kasey_junk on Friday September 05, 2014 @12:47AM (#8272353)
"If they prioritized liquidity above all else, as you appear to think they should"

No, I think they should prioritize execution costs above all else. It turns out that fees then liquidity costs are the biggest variables in determining execution cost. Public exchanges with low fees and high liquidity provide the lowest execution cost, no matter what the dark pool salesmen claim (fraudulently or not).

"Yes, I'm sure they all left after it was revealed that Barclays was lying to them"

Actually the complaint shows they were leaving before the lying started. This is what you are missing. The lying was a response to the natural market condition that execution costs are lowered in environments with HFT participants. That Barclay's had staked their reputation on that not being true is what led to the fraud.

"The central part of the complaint was that the service was advertised as HFT free when, in fact, it was not."

And that is fraud. The book should be thrown at Barcaly's but that doesn't add any insight into the arguments surrounding HFT, other than in real world conditions, even buy side clients prefer venues with HFT provided liquidity, even in the face of fraudulent marketing claims.

Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by harryh on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:07PM (#8269046)
Historically (in the 1980s) liquidity was 10x-20x more expensive than it is today. No one is willing to pay those sorts of prices anymore.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:12PM (#8269070)
Nobody is suggesting turning off electronic trading systems and going back to pen, paper and shouting in a pit.
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by harryh on Thursday September 04, 2014 @12:13PM (#8269075)
So computers are fine. Faster is fine. Just not too fast? Because once we pass some sort of arbitrary speed barrier then....what happens exactly?
Re:Donald MacKenzie on high-frequency trading by crdoconnor on Thursday September 04, 2014 @11:14PM (#8272132)
The market stops rewarding those who do the best research and make the best value judgments about stocks and simply rewards those with the fastest exchange connections and best hardware (who can parasite upon the research and risklessly make money by covertly front running it).

If value investors stop being rewarded for doing good research and correctly assessing the true value of a stock they will usually withdraw from the market (c.f. market for lemons: akerlof).

It should be pretty obvious why a stock market whose values are disconnected from reality is a bad thing, and why having a pool of investors who do good real world research and get rewarded for it is a good thing.