Re:Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language (1981)
by habitue on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @12:57PM
(#8263987)
I believe that works fine (at least in C). You have to statically put the array size into the function signature, so it will only work on arrays of that size. I was simply pointing out the difference between dependently typed vectors which have the type checker prove you use the vector correctly, and arrays in c and pascal whose sizes are known at compile time. I am agreeing with the author that this makes it hard to create generic array bounds if you don't have the ability to make unbounded arrays (as c does). I was disagreeing with the gp, who was conflating these two different sorts of types.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language (1981)
by pjmlp on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @01:18PM
(#8264115)
So I guess you aren't confortable with the C standard.
Functions don't take arrays size statically in arguments. Whatever you write is ignored.
Re:Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language (1981)
by habitue on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @06:46PM
(#8265858)
It's been a few years since I've written a lot of C. ufo's sibling comment reminded me of how it acts (the last dimension is ignored).
Anyway, this is completely beside the point of what I was talking about. The point is that a static size is a very different level of type system machinery from a dynamic size.
Re:Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language (1981)
by pjmlp on Thursday September 04, 2014 @02:25AM
(#8267010)
My point is that although they are static allocated, the moment you pass them as arguments, they are just another pointer.
Which leads to those beautifull security exploits.
Re:Why Pascal is Not My Favorite Programming Language (1981)
by ufo on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @02:02PM
(#8264370)
IIRC, if you have multidimensional arrays only the last dimension is ignored so arr[3][4] is equivalent to arr[3][]. Of course, in the one dimensional case it means that the dimension is ignored.