News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A visual proof that neural nets can compute any function by maaku on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @02:31PM (#8259283)
A "neural net" is what a computer scientist decided to call something that he thought behaved somewhat like a now dated abstract model of what individual neurons worked like, from a period when neuroscience was really in its infancy.

Your brain is not a neural net.

Re:A visual proof that neural nets can compute any function by jo_ on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:33PM (#8259614)
Certainly not in the deeper senses of the phrase.

If we take the phrase neural network to mean, "a series of deeply and widely interconnected elements which assist or inhibit the transmission of signals to one another, activated by the inputs exceeding a threshold," then I think there's a pretty good amount of overlap.

I understand there's a temporal signaling model (pulses at varying rates, not steady state signals) and stochastic information (like random firing and a bunch of noise), but once we abstract out the axons, dendrites, and neurochemicals, is there another piece of functional equipment which drastically effects things? How does our simplified view that small, individually stupid pieces, acting in concert to produce complex behavior differ from the real brain?

Re:A visual proof that neural nets can compute any function by maaku on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @04:16PM (#8259890)
The point is more that you can't abstract neurons away into a simple "analog in, digital out" pseudo-transistor with fixed connections and expect that to describe how the brain works. The brain makes active use of all those details you are abstracting away, in ways that would make your model's predictions differ from reality.
Re:A visual proof that neural nets can compute any function by Tenobrus on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:30PM (#8261372)
Are you saying there is literally nothing in the brain that can be abstracted away? This seems like a very bold claim.
Re:A visual proof that neural nets can compute any function by maaku on Wednesday September 03, 2014 @04:42AM (#8262052)
No, absolutely not. I'm saying that a "neural net" a la McCulloch doesn't accurately model how computation is performed by the brain. You can't accurately model human thinking by recording the brain's connections as a classical neural net. That's all I'm saying.