News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lost Lessons from 8-Bit BASIC by userbinator on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @06:09AM (#8256734)
Even the IBM PC and XT had BASIC in ROM, which worked much the same way; and it also came with a complete set of schematics and the source code of the BIOS (I don't think the source for ROM BASIC was included, since it was licensed from Microsoft.) While it wasn't truly "open source" in the legal sense and was still copyrighted, it gave users a chance to learn how their machines worked all the way down to the hardware level, and along with that came the feeling that they actually owned the hardware they bought. DOS also came with a version of BASIC and DEBUG, a simple debugger that allowed the creation, editing, and testing of Asm programs. I remember the magazines at the time would have source code listings of simple programs for readers to type in and use. This isn't really "programming" in the sense of "write your own code", but it definitely provided a "catch-point" - some of the more curious might modify the program and see its effects, or do more research about e.g. the instructions and BIOS calls it used, and eventually start writing their own.

Several decades later, you're lucky if you can find even a detailed datasheet or programming manual for the most important chips in a computer. BIOSes are all closed and proprietary, with the exception of minority projects like Coreboot. The relatively few schematics for commercial PCs only exist because someone was nice and neighbourly enough to leak them. I think the gradual shift towards consumer-oriented is part of it, but security also had a chilling effect: belief in "security through obscurity" and the idea that users shouldn't be developers has lead to a situation in which access to development tools and information are seemingly treated as a privilege instead of a right, and systems are correspondingly locked down against users (but they'll all say this was to prevent "malicious attackers"...)

The walled gardens of Apple's iDevices, Microsoft's position on Secure Boot/Trusted Computing, and increasing prevalence of other schemes like DRM designed to take control away from users and strongly push a consumer-oriented mentality are a great evidence of this effect. More subtly, dumbed-down software designed to be "easy to use" take away much of the incentive to learn about how things work that is often responsible for transforming consumers into producers. No doubt the companies like this because they want to be in control and regulate the creation of software; as me and others have said before, "knowledge is power, and they don't want the users to have too much of it." However, I don't think they're ultimately going to benefit from this practice, since by encouraging users in the direction of consumption, they'll be reducing the number of potential good developers in the future.

From that article you linked to:

A kid puts her hand up in my lesson. ‘My computer won’t switch on,’ she says, with the air of desperation that implies she’s tried every conceivable way of making the thing work. I reach forward and switch on the monitor, and the screen flickers to life, displaying the Windows login screen. She can’t use a computer.

Having done some work helping with teaching before - in a computer science course - the number of times I've seen this happen is astounding. A large number of the population seem to have this condition where it appears their brain completely shuts down the moment they're put in front of a monitor, and I think a large part of it has to do with the notion that computers are somehow "magical" and "mysterious" things that don't follow the same rules of the universe as everything else.

Re:Lost Lessons from 8-Bit BASIC by pavlov on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @07:29AM (#8256954)
... I think a large part of it has to do with the notion that computers are somehow "magical" and "mysterious" things that don't follow the same rules of the universe as everything else.

Excellent point. Computers are indeed like bubbles of custom universes that don't follow the rules of this one. The web doesn't have a real-world metaphor.

How do those universes and their foundational laws get created? By programming, of course. We all know that the stuff computers do is just built up from simple stuff that's been meticulously assembled into layers of increasing complexity: electrons on tiny wires, ands and registers, ifs and structs, packets and sockets, requests and threads, etc. But that knowledge is not discoverable by using a computer today.

It's no wonder that children don't know how to deal with failures that occur in the real-world interface of these custom bubble universes, when all they're thought about that interface amounts to magic gestures that trigger actions within the bubble. When a magic wand stops working, how do you fix it?

Re:Lost Lessons from 8-Bit BASIC by joelanders on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @09:03AM (#8257247)
Regarding machines and discoverability: I think an interesting comparison to flesh out would be computers vs. cars. Compare how tinkerers in each came to be (opening up their parents' car/computer, for example). Compare how "the average user" treats the thing when it breaks. Etc.
Re:Lost Lessons from 8-Bit BASIC by pdkl95 on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:36PM (#8261388)
> the idea that users shouldn't be developers has lead to a situation in which access to development tools and information are seemingly treated as a privilege instead of a right

Unfortunately, a lot of people have been starting the War On General Purpose Computing[1] for a while now.

While many people saw Doctorow's first talk[1] on the War On General Purpose computing, his sequel talk[2] about the upcoming Civil-War On General Purpose Computing is one of the most important talks I've ever seen.

The talk is about exactly this point: Turing completeness scares various traditional powers (and some new/upcoming powers), and their instinct is to lash out and try to mandate that someone make a computer that can't run the various programs that scare them. Not understanding what "Turing Complete" means, they end up in a cycle that tries to blacklist anything that allows these scary programs to be written and used. Hiding the dev tools is just one step on a path that - by definition - must end up with the hobbling of computing devices until they are no longer Turing complete.

This problem needs to be fought right now, in a big way. The non-technical population is just starting to understand the full impact of what it means to have a General Purpose Computer, and we are only seeing the first skirmishes. The 2nd talk I mentioned above by Doctorow[2] - which I very strongly recommend that everybody watch - points out how modern concerns over "dev tools" (or "copyright") are trivial. We need to start the fight now, because it will be a lot more important when the War moves into areas such as medical devices or self-driving cars. We are already seeing the War start to affect areas like property rights and "first sale"; just wait until someone gets sued for publishing a fixed firmware for some company's buggy medical device.

Teaching the next generation from an early age about computers is an important part of the fight to preserve General Purpose Computers, and by promoting "learning by exploring" so kids of the future can learn like we did on older devices would help a lot, at least in the long-run.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nypRYpVKc5Y

Re:Lost Lessons from 8-Bit BASIC by ErikRogneby on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:54AM (#8258274)
This made me wonder when PEEK and POKE were no longer available. And I ran across PC magazine vol 1, issue 1: http://books.google.com/books?id=w_OhaFDePS4C&printsec=front...

Lots of good stuff in here. Page 52 has some details on the new "escape" key.