Eugenics is reproductive control on a very high level, and may go even as far as governmental control on procreation.
Aside the ethical problems with Eugenics there's also a problem raising from simple statistics: In which way shall it be decided who may procreate with whom and who not? Any kind of biased selection eventually leads to a drop in genetic diversity. However the smaller the genetic diversity the higher the chance for illnesses and defects to spread within the population. So if the ultimate goal is genetic diversity the only sound selection would be to make as much mix-and-matches as possible.
Interestingly enough mitochondrial transplantation adds a little to genetic diversity, because it dissolves the meiosis relationship between female nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA.
(1) is it fair to prohibit someone from having one biological child, while others can have five or six, just because she got unlucky in the genetic lottery, assuming she can afford the procedure?
(2) assuming legalization, is the number of children born from parents with this problem really going to have a significant impact in the worldwide population levels? Isn't it like stopping bathing to save water while you continue to water your lawn every day?
Luck doesn't seem to have a scientific basis. No one chose for the person to have an innate biological inability to produce healthy offspring whilst another person does have that ability [to a greater extent]. How is it not fair? Clearly being unfair is allowed as you said "assuming she can afford it", why should financial ability trump biological suitability? That doesn't seem fair nor sensible.
Will children born from parents who are otherwise unable to reproduce, due to their innate biology, contribute to global population increase over the long term? Well, yes, if we allow it to. Or as is suggested here, we choose it.
Use your shower water to water your lawn, make sure you're washing without chemicals that are going to cause a detrimental impact on flora, waterlife, groundwater and such.
To use your analogy I'd say choosing to enable the continued acceleration of global population increase is like legislating to guarantee the use of lawn sprinklers when there's a shortage of drinking water. Your analogy is twisted as without allowing this procedure to take place we will still have more people than we need to continue the human race [of course if we need more people in the future for colonisation of other planets, or whatever, then the argument may well change].
That she has an inability is not fair nor unfair; it simply is. That you chose to criminalize her decision to have children via this procedure is a choice, and in my opinion, it's unfair since it discriminates people and for no good reason.
I'm a fat, lazy slob, and I'm allowed to have children, and she isn't? That's simply wrong.
Clearly being unfair is allowed as you said "assuming she can afford it", why should financial ability trump biological suitability? That doesn't seem fair nor sensible.
Who says it should trump? As far as I'm concerned neither should be restricted from having children. You're the only one arguing for restrictions.
The idea of financial ability was merely to say that my position doesn't require others to pay for it.
Use your shower water to water your lawn, make sure you're washing without chemicals that are going to cause a detrimental impact on flora, waterlife, groundwater and such.
What "chemicals"? It's just a child like any other. We have no reason to believe it's more harmful than mine or yours. If she should prevented from having them, on what grounds shouldn't we prevented everyone else?
To use your analogy I'd say choosing to enable
Ah, but that's the thing. You view this as "choosing to enable". But nobody is asking you to enable anything; just to not throw people who decide to have the procedure done in prison (or fining them or whatever).
On the other side, we've also engineered in the ability for societies with low morals and low intelligence and low natural survivability to thrive on foreign aid and green revolution and raw minerals export.
Maybe we should be fixing this from the angle of letting poor and inefficient cultures starve, rather that preventing more productive cultures reproduce?
Which population?
Population in Africa is barely sustainable, but they aren't getting mitochondria implants there, not even diag.
Population in e. g. Germany is shrinking, they have money and they certainly want to make sure everybody who is willing to bear kids get them.
That's two different populations with different solution.
According to Wikipedia, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Germany, Germany's natural population as deaths-vs-births has declined by up to 0.24% (-2.4 per mille listed on Wikipedia) per annum. However, the same page indicates that Germany has the largest migrant population - 10 million people - who are not in those figures.
I've not looked at their population stats in detail but first indications are that their population is not falling.
Natural population of European countries falling doesn't create extra resources on the planet.
Lets turn it around, explain why Germany need an increase in endemic population? How does that benefit the rest of us?
On the other hand, endemic African population can't even feed themself and rely on foreign aid and still starve.
It is obvious that we should make sure stable and productive society remains stable. Yes, lifting Africa out of poverty is important, but more important is not kicking Germany into poverty.
Which might as well happen if we populate it with random starving people from that 8 billion and order them fed no matter what.
So, Germans are going to try to keep their endemic population and culture because they can and should. And the "rest of you" should probably learn how to survive without wasting precious planetary surface.
Personally, I wouldn't be so sure. Having kids is a leap of faith and involves risks no matter what you do, of course, but if I had a problem which a) prevented me from having kids without assistance and b) may result in unknown complications later for my child, I'm not sure I'd do it. At that point being a loving, generous, responsible parent may mean not being a parent at all (or adopting).
I'd have to know what the odds and severity of any potential problems would be in order to compare that to other (normal) genetic risks, though.
I don't get it. Of course on a personal level we have a biological drive, like a hunger, to have children. But on a group level I don't understand why we find it necessary to satisfy that need?
The problem of children with mitochondrial problems being born, as in Bernardi's case in the article, could seemingly be solved by her having had a test to determine if she had mitochondrial disease (ie she would, in the future, qualify for this cytoplasmic transfer treatment) and then her not having biological children of her own. That would also rule out the potential for unknown complications later
To me our current population seems barely sustainable and we already have plenty of orphans in need of families to care for them. It doesn't add up.
Now, I'm sure if I were in the situation of this enabling me to have a biological family then I'd want it, that seems entirely natural. But objectively how does that benefit my community, country, the world?