I don't know why you mention paper currencies and gold when most money today is transferred electronically, in a far more efficient way than Bitcoins.
And one block will include a whole slew of transactions, that's fixed overhead with economies of scale built in.
You've chosen a particularly odd phrase here, since BitCoin mining was fundamentally designed to get computationally more expensive over time.
So, no, an economy of THE OPPOSITE OF SCALING was built in.
As an aside, "economy of THE OPPOSITE OF SCALING" is probably better termed "diseconomy of scale" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseconomies_of_scale).
(If you wish to say they encourage unhealthy behavior, that's another argument.)
Mt. Gox collapsing was a worse wealth loss than bank bail outs, by far.
They required the devaluation of the dollar via Fed 'printing.' The Fed had to take trillions in nuked assets off the balance sheet of Bank of America, Citi, and others.
The primary bailout was not the Treasury program TARP, but the Fed programs.
That stole purchasing power from everyone that uses the US Dollar. That purchasing power will never be returned. Trillions in real wealth were destroyed, that is gone. Even if you supposed all assets returned to their previous value, the time cost, wrecked credit ratings, debt accumulation, etc. that was involved in that loss of wealth is still massive when it has to do with tens of trillions in total asset value.
The collapse of Mt Gox isn't even a rounding error compared to the real wealth destroyed by the Fed in the last five years through dollar devaluation. It's equivalent to about ten hours, from one day, of QE the past year.
Not to mention, any bitcoins lost in the collapse of Mt Gox, increases the value of all other bitcoins over time due to the reduction in supply. To be like the bank bailouts ala the Fed, Mt Gox would have had to create a lot of new bitcoins in the process of being destroyed.
Compared to what? You can't compare it to the results of not having done bailouts, so the comparison is largely a matter of economic prediction, and economic prediction is obviously very controversial. The only non-controversial part is that the bailouts were certainly very good for the banks receiving them.
The bail outs stabilized the currency in lieu of massive wealth loss (e.g. toxic debt), while not adding to transnational costs because the returns were positive.
Most bitcoin evangelists fail to grasp the negative impact that volatility has on currencies, and instead think of bitcoins like assets, even hording them.
Revenues of Brink's alone, sayeth Google, are roughly $4 billion. My understanding is that a substantive portion of that represents cost of transporting cash and gold, and of course they are only one of several such companies.
The United States alone spends tens of millions of dollars a year on producing pennies - beyond the face value of the pennies.
So the entirety spent on mining bitcoin is not too far off from what one country spends just on minting pennies.
It's true, pennies are a horrible waste. It costs almost $0.02 to make one, and nobody even likes them very much, but the mint still churns out billions of the things ever year. That should probably stop.
But overall, coinage is a tiny fraction of the overall dollar economy. And Bitcoin isn't really comparable to coinage, anyway, since BTC is not a fast, convenient, anonymous, peer-to-peer mechanism for exchange that's appropriate for use in small transactions. Compared on that level, BTC seems sub-optimal long before we start worrying about details like energy efficiency of production.
What BTC really compares to is a currency in general, such as the dollar. There BTC at least has a chance of comparing on a vaguely level playing field. And at that scale, pennies are insignificant.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_debate_in_the_United_Stat...
Consider the impact of minimal fluctuations of exchange and interest rates. No one could just say "fuck it" and buy into a completely unpredictable new system. Governments would give up control, and random people who happened to have mined Bitcoin until that point would hold the world's wealth? I don't think so.
Currencies can only be political instruments up until a point -- and then people get tired of it and start looking for other mediums of exchange, units of account, and stores of value. Bitcoin is theoretically something people could turn to for one or more of those, though it would have to be a pretty bad situation to make Bitcoin's volatility look good.
(Disclaimer. The overall likelihood of this happening at a large scale is not something endorsed by this post.)
They really are just throwing tons of electricity and hardware at "nothing", but if this kind of activity helps replace the current inefficient systems of currency, then I'm all for it.