News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by givan on Friday August 29, 2014 @05:19AM (#8241763)
I wonder if it's possible to ever find out what our reality is even if we will eventually reach the intellectual and technology necessary because we are part of it and it's probably impossible to have an objective view of the matter.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by unfunco on Friday August 29, 2014 @06:59AM (#8241970)
"There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable." – from The Restaurant at the end of the Universe.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by lrem on Friday August 29, 2014 @07:10AM (#8241996)
"There is an accompanying theory that states this has already happened." - same source
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by antimagic on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:53AM (#8242455)
I often think about that quote when I'm thinking about the universe as being a simulation in someone's computer somewhere. So imagine us clever little monkeys on the inside, have been probing the behaviour of the simulator by conducting science experiments. We're basically conducting targeting fuzzing of the simulator, which probably results in quite a few bugs going off. At which the compsci student running the simulation sighs, corrects the bug, and launches the simulation again.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by snarfy on Friday August 29, 2014 @07:29AM (#8242048)
"Any effectively generated theory capable of expressing elementary arithmetic cannot be both consistent and complete. In particular, for any consistent, effectively generated formal theory that proves certain basic arithmetic truths, there is an arithmetical statement that is true, but not provable in the theory" - Gödel (Kleene)
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by k__ on Friday August 29, 2014 @08:20AM (#8242178)
Some CS prof. told us this in first semester. After that, Physics was over for me.

And I felt that the Planck-scale was somehow a proof for this.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by deeviant on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:42PM (#8243578)
The thing is, the universe and mathematics are totally separate entities. The universe did not start off "as math", nor is it defined by it.

We, as clever little beings found similarities and analogies between the universe and mathematics and leverage those to make conjecture regarding the form and nature of the universe. However, having a "complete" knowledge of either mathematics or the physical universe does not confer complete knowledge of the other.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by s_baby on Friday August 29, 2014 @03:15PM (#8244071)
You don't experience the universe directly. You experience it through cognitive constructs and all the limitations that entails.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by xenophonf on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:57PM (#8243653)
Physics (and science in general) isn't about searching for the Truth. Instead it's about reducing the amount of error in the mental models we use to approximate reality. Like, when a scientist says "the Law of Gravity", they actually mean "our best current guess as to how gravity works, which seems to make accurate predictions in what we consider a statistically significant number of different scenarios, but which is incomplete and perhaps even completely wrong in several other interesting scenarios or edge cases". Only _everything_ in science has a confidence interval, and prefacing every description of some phenomena with the phrase "we're pretty sure this is how this works, but to be perfectly honest, it's only an approximation to some X degrees of accuracy" gets really exhausting, so for stuff we're really, really sure of, like 99.9999% sure, we call it a "Law" (even though it isn't) and move on with our lives.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by pfortuny on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:45AM (#8242423)
It is funny because if nature is discrete then Gödel has nothing to say about it. Only our present MODELS fail to deal with finiteness properly.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by dllthomas on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:18PM (#8243449)
Weren't the original formulation of Gödel's theorems dealing with natural numbers (a discrete setting)?
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by pfortuny on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:29PM (#8243512)
Sorry I mistook the term: finite, not discrete.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by protonfish on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:20AM (#8242349)
There is this belief propagated among physicists that smaller scales somehow have more to do with reality. I have never been presented with logic or evidence that convinced me that an electron is somehow more "real" than a molecule or a person or the solar system or the observable universe.

I wish the word "reality" would stop being thrown around without justification. "Fundamental" might be a more appropriate term.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by afafsd on Friday August 29, 2014 @02:40PM (#8243843)
>There is this belief propagated among physicists that smaller scales somehow have more to do with reality

Only among high-energy physicists. Perhaps not coincidentally there's also a belief among high-energy physicists that only they count as physicists.

In reality, they're a small minority of physicists. The largest specialty in physics, accounting for about half of all research, is condensed matter physics. Then in no particular order you've got AMO (atomic/molecular/optical), astrophysics, geophysics, biophysics, and a bunch of other stuff sitting between or outside those categories. With the exception of just a few corners of astrophysics, none of these fields needs, or can make sure of, the stuff being done on fundamental interactions; regular old quantum mechanics plus relativity is good enough for describing everything we can actually measure.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by im3w1l on Friday August 29, 2014 @10:42AM (#8242698)
It easier to get a detailed understanding of the universe, by observing what happens in extreme cases. The very small. The very big. The very heavy. The very energetic. The very quick.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by pfortuny on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:43AM (#8242414)
I guess you mean "elements." We used to apply the word to earth, air, fire and water. Now it is all about tachions and whatnot. But elements is the word.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by axilmar on Friday August 29, 2014 @08:13AM (#8242154)
I do not think that it is possible.

Any physical system that can be described by a set of mathematical laws is bound to have some axioms that simply cannot be proven within its context. Godel's incompleteness theorems prove that.

Hence, we will never get to the bottom of the reality of our universe.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by smokel on Friday August 29, 2014 @10:06AM (#8242517)
Your statement that we will never get to the bottom may be true, but the reasoning is flawed.

Gödel's incompleteness theorems are about mathematical theories, not about physical theories. It may well be that for physical understanding a very limited arithmetic is sufficient. Also, there may be statements that are unprovable, but these might turn out to be irrelevant to sufficiently understanding the universe.

Also, an axiom, by definition, can not be proven. The things that are proven are theorems, statements, etc. An axiom is an assumption.

Eventually, it all depends on what level of understanding you want. But Gödel's theorems have little to do with that.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by mkaziz on Friday August 29, 2014 @11:20AM (#8242899)
Do you not have to start off with a set of axioms though? Assumptions that will never be proven?
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by dfox on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:10PM (#8243417)
From the mathematical point of view, physics is about finding smallest set of axioms from which you can mathematically derive complete theory of universe's behavior. Validity of such axioms is in turn validated by experiments (by testing whether results match theory derived from given axioms)
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by dllthomas on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:20PM (#8243456)
It is true that they will never be "proven", but that doesn't mean we can't build a tremendous confidence in them through experimentation. (Which is to say "I agree", but I wanted to put a slightly different spin on it.)
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by sp332 on Friday August 29, 2014 @01:53PM (#8243633)
The incompleteness theorem describes a tradeoff: A system of axioms cannot be both consistent and complete. But that seems irrelevant, since you could make a system that describes all of physics while not being either consistent or complete. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_...
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by eli_gottlieb on Saturday August 30, 2014 @06:24AM (#8246070)
Scientific reasoning is inductive, not deductive. When doing inductive reasoning you are allowed to update your belief in your axioms based on the empirical evidence you see.

In fact, the theorem showing how to do so (Bayes' Theorem) is so utterly elementary we teach it in the first probability course everyone takes.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by fjolthor on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:58AM (#8242478)
I agree with this but for a different reason. No matter how much we discover, everything we find is still something in existence. No matter what force or object you are observing, you can't doubt that it exists at some level, in some way (whichever multiverse or reality it is).

This means that at some point, existence must have been started by something non-existent. Because we only comprehend cause-and-effect, we can't possibly find the origin in a provable way while researching from within existence.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by john_b on Friday August 29, 2014 @10:04AM (#8242507)
Godel's incompleteness theorems only place restrictions on deductive systems. In mathematics, you can't perform "experiments" and measure what happens. As long as we can observe and measure physical quantities, even if those quantities are only indirect effects of what physicists are actually trying to measure, incompleteness is not a strong limitation of physics.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by coliveira on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:34AM (#8242385)
This argument is always used to try to reduce the power of mathematics, but the whole fact that mathematics was used to prove this tells me otherwise. There is a huge amount of properties of the universe that can be understood with mathematics despite Goedel's result.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by Tloewald on Friday August 29, 2014 @05:42PM (#8244651)
Not axioms, tautologies (true statements). Godel's incompleteness theorem assumes you know the axioms. Godel doesn't tell us whether we can discover the axioms, although perhaps it implies that as a corollary.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by macspoofing on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:12AM (#8242327)
What if we live in a universe/reality where anything that can happen, does happen. And the reason for this state is because it just is.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by fjolthor on Friday August 29, 2014 @10:05AM (#8242509)
You mean...the multiverse theory.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by Tloewald on Friday August 29, 2014 @05:41PM (#8244647)
Not axioms, tautologies (true statements). Godel's incompleteness theorem assumes you know the axioms.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by kazinator on Friday August 29, 2014 @02:56PM (#8243950)
If reality is just math, then it boils down to everything being generated from axioms. Gödel does not tell us that we cannot discover those axioms (and that they are axioms).

Where Gödel comes into the picture is that he gives us no right to believe that only those axioms are all there is.

If the reality is mathematics, Gödel justifies the Multiverse hypothesis: just because we are objects within some theory doesn't mean there don't exist other theories (perhaps superset of this one).

"Unable to prove" in the Gödel sense can be then equated with "unable to peer into another universe".

Gödel's sentence becomes analogous to some phenomenon or artifact of another universe which cannot exist in ours because it cannot be derived from its axioms.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by danbruc on Friday August 29, 2014 @08:07AM (#8242144)
For the moment it seems to me that there is no chance to ever know what something REALLY is. There is obviously stuff out there that behaves exactly like mathematical models we made up - there are things called electrons behaving like our model of electrons interacting with things called photons behaving like our models of photons. But what does this tell you about the nature of electrons and photons? Is a electron just a handful of numbers like charge -1 and spin 1/2 behaving according to the laws of physics or is there more to an electron? I can't even imagine how one could bridge the gap between our models of reality and reality but then there is probably so much more to learn about our universe, maybe some day...
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by thibauts on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:05AM (#8242309)
Maybe asking what things REALLY are has no meaning. Do objects have characteristics apart from what we can (physically) interact with and measure ? If thoses characteristics exist but aren't measurable can we say they are real ? Does it make any sense ?

I often use this line of thought to talk about God with open-minded believers. If there is a God that created our reality and acts on it, then the effects of these actions are real in our sense and thus measurable. It then follows that God isn't separate from the natural world and can be observed like many other natural phenomena we don't look at directly. Without a chain of interactions this wouldn't be possible.

What I mean is our reality is one of interactions. What is real to us, and what can be called "existing" is what interacts directly or indirectly with our senses and our minds. What we mean by "nature" on a large scale is ultimately internal structure. Once we hit a level where internal structure doesn't make sense anymore, I'm not sure what we are looking at and what the word "nature" can be made to encompass.

Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by snarfy on Friday August 29, 2014 @08:38AM (#8242238)
Why are all electrons the same? It's because they are all manifestations of the same electric field. But then what is the electric field? Yep, it's a rabbit hole.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by noiv on Friday August 29, 2014 @08:03AM (#8242134)
I think, we are not bad at describing reality, the problem is describing our self, because whatever the outcome is it doesn't sound, well, motivating?
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by macspoofing on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:10AM (#8242320)
Only one way to find out.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by collyw on Friday August 29, 2014 @05:45AM (#8241829)
Yes. Open minded comments like this, questioning the limits of science get down voted here on HN.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by goblin89 on Friday August 29, 2014 @06:43AM (#8241928)
I didn't downvote, but if you ask me I'd say others did it mainly because grandparent brought philosophy into scientific discussion. (And with reasoning or phrasing issues at that: “we can't do something even if we can”, for example, contradicts itself.)
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by halfcat on Friday August 29, 2014 @09:59PM (#8245326)
Ironic that science is a subset of philosophy.
Re:At Multiverse Impasse, a New Theory of Scale by goblin89 on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:45AM (#8245963)
That's precisely why, IMHO, if you aren't prepared to make a complete well-thought-through argument, then you should think twice before venturing into a philosophical discussion.

On the other hand, due to the nature of HN, one has to choose between either spending a few days researching the comment and posting it with a very slim chance of being read or answered, or blurting out something not very polished.

In this case it's the latter. (How you define “objective”? “reality”? A rough example of how could the answer to the question “what reality is” roughly look like? Any links to existing research—people certainly attempted to ask a question of this nature before?) The resulting discussion may be worth it, though.