News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by dredmorbius on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @12:18AM (#8225714)
There are a lot of holes in modern mainstream economic thinking, a large number of which are actually pretty old. We've been having what are fundamentally the same economic debates for 2000+ years, largely over fairness of pricing, wages, equity, and control, as a survey history such as Roger E. Backhouse's The Ordinary Business of Life details.

In the 20th century, the three major challenges to free-market capitalism as espoused by Adam Smith and his followers have been the Great Depression of 1929-1940, the environmental and oil shocks of the 1970s, and the "Great Recession" of 2007 onwards.

The Depression raised the question of whether or not the free market was itself self-correcting, and the answer is generally accepted as a pretty emphatic "no". It wasn't until massive amounts of government-induced spending, partially through the New Deal, but largely as part of World War II and post-war reconstruction efforts (e.g., the Marshall Plan) that the economy really got off the ground again, and even through the 1950s and 1960s, there was concern that the malaise of the 1930s would return.

What happened instead were a series of environmental and safety concerns -- Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, Ralph Nader's Unsafe at Any Speed, and more so the question of whether or not the modern post-Industrial Revolution age was sustainable: the Club of Rome's Limits to Growth.

These were immediately followed by peaking of US domestic oil extraction in 1971, and the first effective middle-east oil embargo from the recently-formed OPEC (several earlier attempts had been made, notably during the Suez crisis of the 1950s, but US domestic extraction could take up the slack). It was also a decade in which the last vestiges of the gold standard were removed from most major world currencies (the Swiss Franc continued through the 2000s), with the cancellation of the Bretton Woods agreement, unilaterally, by the US.

The turbulent 1970s turned into the prosperous 1980s and 1990s, which some attribute to opening up of the North Sea, Alaskan North Slope, and offshore Gulf of Mexico to oil development. Crashing oil prices are thought to have played a major role in the collapse of the former Soviet Union, long dependent on its oil exports for hard currency.

There were also massive political shifts underway. Within the US, the previously white-Democratically-dominated South was split amongst a now black Democratic and white Republic party, while moral and other issues were used to create unity amongst an otherwise increasingly class-divided Republican party elsewhere. Labor unions lost a huge amount of power both due to general decline among US manufacturing companies (particularly automobiles, steel, and other heavy industry), as well as federal action (the 1980s air traffic controllers' strike and dissolving of the union by President Reagan).

While real returns on business investment were falling (look up Deloitte's Center for the Edge study "The Shift Index"), financial wealth creation was increasingly coming from the financial sector itself, and asset inflation of securities and later, real estate (itself driven by securities return demands).

There has been economic growth, mostly in the BRIC nations: Brazil, Russia, India, and China, but most especially in the latter two, with growth in China quite simply blowing away any previous economic revival anywhere, including the post-WWII European and Japanese recoveries. Unfortunately for economics, the growth in India and China has come largely with an almost precise parallel growth in primary energy consumption, a huge portion of that exceptionally dirty coal (in both traditional particulate, smog, and heavy-metal pollution as well as CO2 emissions). Much of the "economic decoupling" of growth from primary resource consumption in the rest of the world disappears if you factor India and China back into the equation.

Then came the 2000s: the dot com collapse, the Bush tax cuts (favoring the wealthy markedly), two unfunded wars, peak oil in 2006, the housing (asset) bubble, 2007 global financial crisis, and growing inequality worldwide.

To put it bluntly, conventional economics predicted little if any of this. The models of the Limits to Growth types appear to be playing out, though with some variance (the post-oil embargo efficiency improvements and reduced oil consumption, as well as fracking and other "enhanced recovery" petroleum extraction methods have pushed back the net fossil hydrocarbon liquids by 5-15 years). The criticisms of Marx, Malthus, Toynbee, and others over the inequality of capitalism have resurfaced with a vengeance. Claims of a "new" economy or "information" economy are proving largely illusory. The Web 2.0 economy is largely funded by advertising, the bulk of which are FIRE (finance, insurance, and real estate) and electronics consumables themselves, as well as exceptionally liberal central bank monetary policy.

And the critics of economics are mainstream: you'll find articles questioning received wisdom in the Financial Times, Economist, Wall Street Journal, New York Times, and elsewhere. Critics include Joseph Stiglitz, Paul Krugman, James Galbraith, Steve Keen, Herman Daly, and a handful of others -- hardly the bulk of the profession, but some key thinkers.

And as others have noted, "anti-capitalist" is at best a label of convenience applied to a system that could be characterized by a great many things. I've called it the economic orthodoxy (as opposed to heterodoxies). Salient characteristics include free markets, laissez-faire (according to some), corporatism, financialization, globalization, commoditization, computerization, automation, extraction, nonsustainability, and others.

All of which tends to be a bit of a mouthful. There's also a fair bit of disagreement among critics on just what the most relevant elements of failure are (as is typically the case -- it's easy to agree that you don't like the old boss, harder to select a new boss you happen to agree on).

Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by pnathan on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @11:19AM (#8227567)
Thank you for your survey. I appreciate it.
Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by waps on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @05:47AM (#8226348)
Thank you for this insightful comment. It really was a joy to read.

To some extent I feel you are avoiding the basic question, though. What do you think the solution is ? The only real argument in favour of capitalism is simply that it has survived where other systems have not. Natural selection.

Granted, economic systems haven't always failed for "good" reasons. Some were conquered. Others built an economy based on oil, and oil ran out. Others strip-mined colonies. Islam built it's civilization on slavery, and can be said to be a continuation of Rome (mostly of the bad parts of the Roman empire, but ...). But, like natural selection, there are no good and bad reasons, hell, there aren't even really (known) reasons at all, and it doesn't really matter "whose fault it is", they failed, and when they failed, that was the end of the road. Capitalism, by contrast, has risen from the ashes more times than a drunk pyromaniac phoenix.

The vast majority of critiques on capitalism are simply expressing a refusal to change (in some cases ironically). In a way, it's a form of conservatism, even if different from what we usually call conservatism. Or, in some cases, much worse : an attempt to resurrect dead societies (like the many attempts at resurrecting the caliphate we see now, hell, those even fight like the Roman empire did, which frankly justifies killing them all in my humble opinion, but ...). But sadly[1], there's a reason these societies died (and in the vast majority cases, like the islamic one for example : good riddance). If you resurrect them, that reason will simply surface again, and kill them in the cradle.

Right now we are in a boom phase of capitalism, and yes, it looks like we may be at the end of the boom (then again, it's looked like that for 10+ years now, and before that we had 1980, 1972, the cold war, 40-48, 30-40, 14-18, "revolutionary" Europe, and so on and so forth, and all of those look to me much, much worse than our current situation. So to some extent I feel inclined to say to people complaining about the economy "big fucking whoop". But it certainly is getting a little bit worse. On the other hand today, I can name 50+ things that could easily resurrect economic growth, and only one of them needs to happen. We could discover a useful fusion principle, we could find a way to mine plate-edge methane gas, we could find a way to produce really cheap solar panels (we're not too far from making that happen, actually), we could ... If you ask me "what could anyone have done to avoid what's coming" in 1938 or 1912, I'd have said "other than changing the religion/ideology of a great many people overnight, nothing can be done". Most societies never even tried to dig themselves out of the hole they dug for themselves. Certainly the Ottoman empire, for example, "deserved" what was coming to it. So did the kingdom of France. So did ... Most of these civilizations had people working in them that had at least the seeds of a solution to their problems, and, generally speaking, they killed those people. I'm pretty confident in saying that we are currently not doing that.

Anyway, I may be rambling a bit here. My question is simple : what is the way out of the current conundrum ? If history is a guide, the way out is simply a huge war, a new superpower, and a new dollar, and more capitalism. That's what happened to Spain, Britain, Portugal, ... and that's what fixed their versions of financial industry stupidities. I will agree that it looks like the US is getting buried in financial industry stupidities as well, but ... In history two economic systems have lasted really long times : slavery, and capitalism. The choice seems obvious to me.

[1] I say sadly out of nostalgia. But having read stories from the Roman empire, medieval China, from the Colonies, from the Ottoman empire (I talked to the grandfather of an Armenian immigrant. That was enlightening, especially the parts about the supposed "tolerance" of the Ottoman empire. By that standard Hitler was a saint), stories from 19th century Europe (hell, my granddad actually told me some stories his dad told him about what life was like in France between the revolution and WWI), I'd say it is a very good thing indeed that you can't resurrect societies.

Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @05:25AM (#8231362)
One more follow-up: I've just read the first chapter of Gregory Clark's Farewell to Alms (available online) which looks at the three questions of the Industrial Revolution, Demographic Transition, and Great Divergence. I suspect you might enjoy that as well.
Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by dredmorbius on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @07:55AM (#8226618)
When you ask for solutions, the first thing to be clear about is what the question is. I was addressing the matter of the study and understanding of economics rather than of the economic system itself, though both are pretty profoundly troubled.

For the first, I think adopting a systems approach as suggested by Limits to Growth would be a good start, and find the writings of ecological economists (Odum, Daly, Hall) to be superior to most of the orthodxy, with Hall perhaps among the most rigorous.

In terms of the economic system itself: I don't see a solution to the present crisis. There are too many people, consuming too many resources, and yet we want to increase both values. There's a simple formula that was derived in the 1970s that describes this: I = P x A x T

Impacts is equal to population times affluence (material resource utilization per capita) time technology.

Alternatively: k <= S x A x P

Sustainability x Affluence x Population is subject to a maximal constraint k.

Which means that you can optimize at best any two of the three. Your choices are high affluence and large population, but low sustainability. High population and high sustainability but low affluence. Or high affluence and high sustainability, but low population.

Or of course, optimizing for at most one or zero aspects.

The "solutions" in this case involve deciding reducing population, accepting crushing poverty (as existed for much of human history), or wipe ourselves out.

I'm not predicting an imminent collapse of the global order, but things could turn south on relatively short notice. More likely this is a scenario which will play out over decades, possibly a couple of centuries paralleling the rise of human population following the Industrial Revolution.

Economic growth has to top out at some point, simply due to physical planetary limits. And no, we're not going to overcome those any time soon, if ever. Even planetary space travel is tremendously expensive, let alone interstellar travel. And there are multiple things we'd have to solve to address near-term challenges, with energy, phosphorus, other minerals, soil, and fresh water chief among them. Look up Leibig's Law of the Minimum -- any one constraint is sufficient to limit growth, and we're facing many.

Your past civilizations and empires weren't global in scope and yet even their falls typically precipitated long periods of darkness. And yes, life for much of human history was pretty interesting, in a Chinese curse sense of the word.

The solution in a nutshell? A man (or all humans) have got to know their limits.

Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by waps on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @03:09PM (#8228894)
> The solution in a nutshell? A man (or all humans) have got to know their limits.

But if you look at animal or plant (or bacteria) species, they absolutely don't do this. They just grow to whatever the current capacity of the world is (meaning they would immediately choose the "low sustainability option you present).

This is despite the fact that most non-human species are most definitely living in a world that is being filled close to capacity.

So the argument to this solution is that it's not possible. It's not a Nash equilibrium and any set of humans that picks an option like that will simply die through natural selection, and this will not result in increased sustainability at all.

Re:Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep by dredmorbius on Tuesday August 26, 2014 @07:22PM (#8230124)
I pretty much agree with your overall view. There are very few examples of species which consciously self-limit.

Humans are distinctive for a number of reasons, including that we've got the ability to model complex relationships and project forward into the future. Jared Diamond's Collapse looks at a number of civilizations which have fairly effectively managed to live within their means, though they do so by adopting moralities which are quite extreme, and generally unacceptable, to Western views, including infanticide and ritual suicide.

Most of those cultures are also fairly small. Playing out this game on a global scope, where communications can circle the world in under a second, people in under a day, and massive quantities of goods in a few weeks (via ship), is a rather different game.

If you're interested in more, look up David Korowicz, Joseph Tainter, or for a real blast of optimism, Olduvai Theory. Korowicz in particular looks at issues of global supply chain contagion and what that might have to offer by way of negative dynamics.

My point of "knowing limits" isn't that that knowledge be expressed consciously. But it will be established.

http://energyskeptic.com/2014/david-korowicz-2013-catastroph...

http://www.powells.com/biblio/9780521386739

http://dieoff.org/page125.htm