News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Final exams for kindergartners by pyre on Saturday August 23, 2014 @10:32AM (#8215903)
> in the meritocracy

I beg to differ. How many 'hot start-ups' are hiring experienced developers in their 50's vs. 20-somethings? If we're going to discriminate on things other than merit, we're not in a meritocracy. Your experience may differ, but it's also just anecdotal.

> There was a fascinating ted talk awhile ago about how standardized tests, contrary to being useless as often ascribed by the left, can predict lifetime outcomes such as wages, being published in a journal, level of academic attainment, and so on.

Assuming that this is correct, there will still be outliers (people that score poorly, but are still very successful). At the same time, the "kids that are too smart for school" are also outliers. You're entire argument, in my opinion, comes across as "I am in group of outliers X, therefore we all need to optimize everything for people in group X."

Re:Final exams for kindergartners by sp332 on Saturday August 23, 2014 @11:36AM (#8216036)
I beg to differ. How many 'hot start-ups' are hiring experienced developers in their 50's vs. 20-somethings? If we're going to discriminate on things other than merit, we're not in a meritocracy. Your experience may differ, but it's also just anecdotal.

This is GP's point. If you want to stop discriminating based on irrelevant things like age, you have to test relevant things.

Re:Final exams for kindergartners by pyre on Sunday August 24, 2014 @04:35AM (#8218044)
So, the solution to (e.g.) age-ism in the workplace is final exams for 4-5 year olds?
Re:Final exams for kindergartners by sp332 on Sunday August 24, 2014 @09:10AM (#8218476)
The "final exam" in the article doesn't discriminate among kids, but teachers. There don't seem to be any consequences or "discrimination" for kids who fail the tests.