Also,
"In Florida, the results of end-of-course exams affect the evaluation and pay of teachers."
So I bet low-income areas with less-educated parents working 2 jobs and too exhausted to really help their kids at home probably will have the lowest scores. So any quality-teachers in poorer areas will be less paid, so they'll leave, so the scores will go down, thus the pay goes down, so the quality-teachers leave, so the scores will go down, thus the pay goes down, so the quality-teachers leave...
And what's the end result of that? The kids who need help THE MOST are the ones who get THE LEAST.
>>There was a fascinating ted talk awhile ago about how standardized tests, contrary to being useless as often ascribed by the left, can predict lifetime outcomes such as wages, being published in a journal, level of academic attainment, and so on.
Anyone who is considering tests for predicting people's future potential should watch this movie: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119177/
EDIT: I just noticed you said "the left", so you probably just have an axe to grind and I'm wasting my time with this comment.
I beg to differ. How many 'hot start-ups' are hiring experienced developers in their 50's vs. 20-somethings? If we're going to discriminate on things other than merit, we're not in a meritocracy. Your experience may differ, but it's also just anecdotal.
> There was a fascinating ted talk awhile ago about how standardized tests, contrary to being useless as often ascribed by the left, can predict lifetime outcomes such as wages, being published in a journal, level of academic attainment, and so on.
Assuming that this is correct, there will still be outliers (people that score poorly, but are still very successful). At the same time, the "kids that are too smart for school" are also outliers. You're entire argument, in my opinion, comes across as "I am in group of outliers X, therefore we all need to optimize everything for people in group X."
This is GP's point. If you want to stop discriminating based on irrelevant things like age, you have to test relevant things.
The fault is in the ability to measure cognitive abilities in children. We know surprisingly little about how the human brain develops. A wrong measurement is worse than no measurement at all, for a multitude of reasons, the biggest of which is the fact that measuring will introduce undesired side effects. If you are introducing side effects, with no actionable result to show for, you should consider the value of measuring.
As such, and given that western societies can accommodate free education at least until puberty, the solution is to provide free education. Assess cognitive abilities, for resource allocation purposes, at the terminus of the free education track.
For example: My wife can pass multiple-choice tests with little of the knowledge [she freely admits this]. She had to study her head off for a recent test in a subject she knew little about, because the test was only partially multiple-choice. She ended up passing, yet if I were cruel -- this subject is something I enjoy learning about on my own -- I could snap-test her at will to see if she retained anything for any given time period after the test, and she could likewise do so for herself in everyday life.
Al contrario. We want to use testing to identify holes and other areas of opportunity. To help the teachers teach better and the students to learn better.
More testing raises the stakes for everyone, meaning that the overall population becomes better educated and competitive, in order to do well on the tests.
Furthermore, many smart students find coursework boring an get poor grades, but excel at standardized tests, because they already know the material.
There was a fascinating ted talk awhile ago about how standardized tests, contrary to being useless as often ascribed by the left, can predict lifetime outcomes such as wages, being published in a journal, level of academic attainment, and so on.