Undoubtedly food has changed wildly in 55 years, but so also has the quantity. Not to mention all the estrogens from plastics.
[1] http://www.buzzfeed.com/summeranne/adorable-real-vintage-wed...
http://www.usda.gov/factbook/chapter2.pdf
That lists a 25% increase in calories consumed between 1970 and 2000.
If the hormonal food-partitioning theory is correct, had we increased calories 25% using fat instead of carbs, we wouldn't have an diabesity epidemic today. Instead, people would have perhaps gained a little weight and burned off a lot more using non-exercise activity thermogenesis.
It does include an annual increase in grain consumption of about 50 pounds and an increase of sugar consumption of about 45 pounds.
But it also includes an increase of meat consumption of about 50 pounds, an increase of fat consumption of about 30 pounds and an increase in fruit and vegetable consumption of more than 100 pounds.
There are reductions of about 15 pounds of eggs and 100 pounds of milk products (people drink less of it, much of that weight is water).
There is certainly an increase in carb consumption, but it's clear enough that "all" is an overstatement, people are consuming an additional 85 pounds a year of meat+fats.
There have always been adamant non-smokers just as there have always been convinced smokers.
Well, you might not care, but your body sure does. Your body responds very differently to sugar than it does to fat. And for some people—I would say anyone struggling to lose weight—this difference is the key to success.
Yes, some people can lose weight eating nothing but carbs. There's a lot we don't know, and proponents of this theory will admit this. But one of the primary prinicples of this theory is that genetics plays a large role in human fat metabolism. Some people can eat whatever they want and remain thin, while others eat whatever they want and become obese. There is no such thing as a one size fits all diet.