Does a HOA provide garbage removal, street maintenance, etc?
The cynical answer is that HOAs are legal fictions set up to shelter building developers from the financial burdens and liabilities of having to pay for, or be on the hook for, any of those services or maintenance needs. HOAs are the greatest invention in favor of real estate developers since the timeshare.
You buy from the developer or the previous owner.
> And surely if you own them, they have no legal right to tell you want to do unless it breaks the law?
Membership to the HOA is required by and included into the building sale, contracts are binding.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covenant_%28law%29#Covenants_re...
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covenant_%28law%29#Covenants_in...
So why in the hell would you sign that sort of deal in the first place? Well, if you don't have to, you shouldn't. But in some cities, such as SF, it's extremely hard to buy a condo that doesn't come with an HOA.
HOAs are as prevalent as they are because in most cases they are highly beneficial, both legally and financially, to building or subdivision developers. So more and more developers are using them.
The sale of the residence includes (and requires) contracting with the HOA.
> probably some obscure law
No need for laws, you've signed a contract.
Where I live the HOA board only gets to decide on the 'small stuff' (for big purchases like said Pool renewal above they still need a majority vote.) I try to 'activate' HOA members (everyone that contributes) and remember them that a HOA is made up of its members in the end. If you don't like anything about it you should either talk with your HOA representative / board member AND/OR contribute by opting to become a board member yourself.
Source: I'm one of the five HOA board members in our small (60apt) apartment building.
Some HOAs operate by pretty weak by-laws, and can only decide trivial things. Others have obnoxious levels of control.
Typically an HOA board consists of community members or home owners (if that's the type of development), and sometimes a company that either developed (and owns) the neighborhood or one that manages it will have seats.
Some HOA boards are easy to toss out, others are not.
The vast potential variances make it important to try to get to know more about the HOA ahead of time if you're thinking about moving into a development with such.
Like many bureaucracies, they survived the obsolescence of their original purpose. They provide little beyond (sometimes) a way to arbitrate homeowner disputes.
http://depts.washington.edu/civilr/covenants.htm
> They have zero say about who can and cannot live in a given area.
Because they've been barred to by the Fair Housing Act of 1968.
Sadly, I think any time you have amateurs involved with administration and decision making, you cop the resulting amateur politics and it can quickly make the process miserable.
I wonder if somehow anonymising the process and removing personalities could even help? Leave it purely about the issues, funds and votes?
Most Americans, at least in the past, would be throwing out bank statements in their trash every month (now a lot of it would be digital of course). If you wanted to steal bank details, I suspect that would be the way to do it rather than trying to time the mail and risk getting caught that way.
Name and date of birth are mostly trivial to come by. You can look up modest details about almost anyone in the US for $20 or $50.
Suburban areas are typically classified as "rural routes" so they're required to have mailboxes on posts out by the curb. These days, a "rural route" is basically anything that isn't an older neighborhood inside a larger city.
Fair warning: based on the tone of this guy's dispatches, I'd say there's an outside chance he is the car thief. The plot thickens.
So far my neighborhood is pretty quiet. About 50-odd users. It's entertaining, though. There's this one guy who posts weird survivalist rants and doomsday scenarios about The Big One, and how we're not sufficiently prepared for it. (Probably true, I hate to say.) There's a woman breeding puppies in her apartment and offering them for sale. There's a guy using the site to promote his political blog. There's a guy playing True Detective, tracking all of the car break-ins in the neighborhood, and looking for a "pattern" and "the perp's signature" in the items left on the scenes. I kind of dig it all. Seeing the eccentricity on display adds a smidgeon of big-city atmosphere that I've always felt SF was lacking in comparison to other cities I've lived in.
I hope the network comes into its own, and that we get more people in my neighborhood on board. In the meantime, I'm enjoying the strangeness of my early adopter cohort.