News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @03:42PM (#8187289)
I think we're saying the same thing here, really; whether "half the lawmaking" is 45% or 50% is a technical point that is basically irrelevant in practice.

My original comment related to very pragmatic situation of acting as "champions of democracy" while still maintaining a very significant role in the lawmaking process for a wholly-undemocratic body. It's a real problem that has not been solved and significantly weakens British arguments in, say, foreign policy and cultural debate.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by maaku on Saturday August 16, 2014 @08:43PM (#8188159)
Who says that democracy has to be 100%? If you want to get technical, we all live in republics anyway, not direct democracies.

I know I am an outlier, but it seems a totally strange and foreign concept to me that one could criticize the UK for being hypocritical in promoting democracy abroad because of the House of Lords.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:11PM (#8188332)
> If you want to get technical, we all live in republics anyway

No "we" don't (dunno about you but I live in a constitutional monarchy, which is a fairly popular form of government in Europe, and it just ain't a republic in any technical sense).

> it seems a totally strange and foreign concept to me that one could criticize the UK for being hypocritical in promoting democracy abroad because of the House of Lords.

You should visit the Middle-East sometimes, but even just France would be an eye-opener I think.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by dragonwriter on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:40PM (#8188278)
> My original comment related to very pragmatic situation of acting as "champions of democracy" while still maintaining a very significant role in the lawmaking process for a wholly-undemocratic body.

That seems to demonstrate a problem of ludicrously binary thinking. The UK is far more democratic than a great many countries -- and has been making democratic progress longer than many countries have existed. The existence of the shrinking vestigial powers of the House of Lords isn't even a little bit of a pragmatic problem for the UK as an advocate of democratic progress abroad.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @11:15PM (#8188431)
> The UK is far more democratic than a great many countries

... and far less democratic than many others.

> and has been making democratic progress longer than many countries have existed

... or, in other terms, has been slower to produce a soundly-democratic system than many younger countries.

In fact, one of the main puzzles constitutional scholars struggle with, is exactly this: how (and why) did a nation that reached substantial parliamentary rule so early, deliberately refuse to evolve towards more democratic forms of governments for so long? Why did England fight the French Revolution so bitterly, when on paper the French were just completing the job started in Westminster so many decades before? How can aristocratic privilege survive, in this day and age, in the same nation that first theorized it as fundamentally unjust?

I know this can be difficult to understand for people grown under the ultimate myth of Westminster "mother of all democracies", but there are other models out there; and some of these models are ultimately much more coherent, in theory and in practice, than the constitutional hodgepodge we experience in modern Britain.