News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by warfangle on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:47PM (#817988)
The Accela is an Amtrak train that sometimes goes highway speeds (as opposed to, with Amtrak, almost never) and costs three times as much.

Blerg.

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by Kadin on Friday September 11, 2009 @04:26PM (#818059)
Don't exaggerate; it's not "three times as much."

Amtrak NEC Service, New Haven (NHV) to Washington Union Station (WAS):

Train 175, Northeast Regional, 5'46", $139

Train 2173, Acela Express, 4'36", $213

So for $74 extra you get there roughly an hour and ten minutes faster, provided they both run on-time. (In my experience the Acelas tend to run on-time more often than the regionals, although they both run late more frequently than they should.) The Acela is also a business-class seat while the Regional is coach, and the Acela train is nicer overall.

Whether it's worth the extra money for the extra hour is a personal decision, of course, but I don't think the pricing is wholly inappropriate. It would be great if the Acela was faster because that would make the value equation that much better, but it's not a terrible ripoff as-is.

EDIT: These are fares for today, the equivalent of a "Yankee-class" ticket on an airline. You could do better by buying with a 3-day advance, but I think the Acela/Regional delta would be about the same, percent-wise.

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by hughprime on Friday September 11, 2009 @05:38PM (#818192)
Wow, I had no idea the Acela was that expensive.

Alternatively, I just checked and you can fly from Boston to Baltimore (today, with no advance purchase) for $96, and it takes 1'24". (I admit this isn't quite your example, but it's a reasonable illustration of a similar route).

Or you could drive New Haven to DC, which is 306 miles, and google maps suggests 5 hours 30 mins (admittedly optimistic in traffic). If you drive alone in a gas-hogging 25 mpg car like mine that'll cost you about $40.

I'm starting to understand why nobody takes the Amtrak.

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by catzaa on Friday September 11, 2009 @05:01PM (#818126)
> Train 2173, Acela Express, 4'36", $213

Dude, it is still crap expensive. In my country you pay $210 for a 2000km plane ticket return (4000km total). That is just crazy.

In China trains are dirt cheap, on-time, clean and fast (at least the ones I took). Why does that train of yours have to be that expensive?

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by tptacek on Friday September 11, 2009 @04:03PM (#818014)
The thing you're not acknowledging is that for trips under 3-4 hours, highway speeds + highway overhead beats jet speeds + jet overhead. It's a coin flip whether driving Chicago -> Detroit is better than flying it.

You don't need to be better than highway speed to be extremely valuable. The Acela is a much easier way to get from NYC to Boston than driving (done both), and it's more reliable and sometimes faster than flying.