IMO the more photogenic white people getting jackbooted in the face, the better. It's good for solidarity.
On the other hand, this points to a (to me, more disturbing) aspect of all this - the adoption of military imagery and styling. Why does an urban police force, even if deals with rioting, need to wear camouflage patterns? Why do their trucks need to be painted green instead of the more traditional blue/white or black?
This is indicative of a police force that sees itself as a military force, and its mission as a military mission.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ot5_UPeZIUw
If they really wanted camouflage they would wear jeans. They just want to play commando and find some "action".
The individual misconduct of these officers should be prosecuted. But these rioting mobs won't stand a chance changing these "bullying" tactics or getting the police to "demilitarize".
In some part, the protective gear actually decreases the need of applying violence against protesters, because the officers don't have to defend themselves as "actively" when trying to control a crowd.
Imagine a black community that largely feels (and by data proven to be) oppressed. Now that community has one of its children murdered by the police. When they want to take a stand they are confronted by a wall of heavily armed police that look like they could be fighting a war in Iraq (but as many have said they're even better armed).
What possible reaction do you envision the black community having? I applaud them for keeping their composure as well as they have. I could not do that.
Peaceful, non-violent resistance might work.
Really. There were peaceful protests that were successful. But there were also many violent ones. Violence can and has changed many things.
I don't like violence, but I like those wrong etaist pacifist statements even less.
Edit: Or are you talking only about this specific situation and this is your opinion? Then nevermind, could very well be true here.
In essence violence justifies counter-violence. The more the angry protesters threaten or attack the police, the less "wrong" the current response looks. Non-violence tries to starve the legitimization of excessive force.
This militarization is not a good idea and should be limited or abandoned. But "riots" are hardly making a point against military gear.
In the near east there is a similar problem. There is so much violence going on from both sides, that people can sympathize with cruelties from both sides.
Colonists had to murder plenty of police and military.
I'll just go ahead and leave this here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_F._Kennedy's_speech_on_t...
The legacy of people who believed that violence is never justified, never necessary and can be overcome with compassion.
The situation will escalate. The Police are escalating.
If you don't want a violent confrontation, don't send in a paramilitary force.
Especially after decades of feeling oppressed and ignored, to have someone whose job is, ostensibly, to protect the public gun down an innocent child is intolerable, and the history shows that after a short internal investigation, while the officer is on 'paid administrative leave' (which may as well be a paid vacation), he will be found to have done no wrong and will be put back on patrol.
I'd be rioting in the streets too, if this were my kid. Except that if it were a white kid, everyone would be calling for his head, not just the black community in Ferguson.
That all sounds perfectly fine, reasonable.
But why are they kitted out like stormtroopers? South Korea has much, much better organised political protesters/rioters and their Combat Police[0] are much, much better at their job than it looks like the US equivalent are, and all they've got is standard riot police kevlar armour, clear plastic shields and the helmets. Note that they don't look like troops occupying enemy territory either[1].
I can't see any justification for local police forces having military vehicles, and I think the optics of police in camo are hideous, unless that is actually the message you want to send of course.
I realise that the USA is legitimately exceptional in the number of guns floating around, illegal and legal, and that it is far, far more violent than any other first world country, for whites and blacks but why the shoddy police militarisation? You're not Mexico, there are no gangs as organised and competent as the Mafia who go toe to toe with the police.
And if a paramilitary force is needed, why doesn't each state have 100 full-time SWAT guys (or more, I really have no idea how many New York or California need.) and 400 guys who are cross trained? If you need more than 500 men with machine guns, it's time to call the National Guard.
[0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Police_Agency_(South_K...
[1]http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=south+korean+riot+police...
Many years ago, Congress passed a law that has the DoD sell off vehicles it no longer needs to police for very good prices. The police get those vehicle for around $3000, which is much less than a conventional car would cost.
I would guess that for most departments, the low cost is their justification.
Also: could those who down vote please explain what you find wrong with asking what the police should be doing?
You don't need trained snipers, full body armor and APCs to do that. Not for a town of 21,000. They were sandblasting saltines.
Also, in every picture I've seen of the militarized police they've had badges as well as tags that read 'POLICE'.
It certainly doesn't help to spread fear. Don't let these frustrations fuel and justify the juvenile and irresponsible reaction we've seen from groups like Anonymous.
These are scary times for everyone involved and polarizing the issue is a path that quite clearly and logically leads people away from resolving their conflicts.
Perhaps you're just wanting to see things burn?
That's kind of a super-extreme isn't it? He said first glimpse of tyranny creeping up. I took it as an implication that the wheels may be beginning to turn.
Social unrest has also happened quite a number of times throughout history, but are we not allowed to be shocked in seeing weapons trained at civilians? Snipers? Vehicles of this stature? I mean, this is a town of 21,000 and utilizing this equipment was deemed appropriate?
Fortunately, the death and violence and hate aren't on par with lynch mobs and the like, but are you trying to say we should just brush this off? If you could perhaps elaborate on how the concept of Police Militarization is being polarized and preventing a resolution?
I don't see this particular resolution in the first place. We had the President decry weapons or war and then the Pentagon give 'em out. I don't feel like there is a resolution in place to be prevented.
Anyone feeling the same is as guilty as they are. They just don't happen to be in possession of an armored vehicle and riot gear. If they did they'd probably be out somewhere knocking heads together.
Someone needs to convince the people who elect these Sheriffs that they should put someone in charge who isn't going to buy 50,000 rounds of tear gas.
You know what's really going to end our democracy? Everyone abandoning it because they think it is too hard to go out, interact with people, and maybe start a real dialog about how we're governing ourselves.
Getting angry, pointing fingers, and inventing some sort of "us vs. them" mentality does nothing to prevent things like this from happening.
Tyranny is "super-extreme". We're nowhere near it. Implying that we are is irresponsible and most importantly, is a type of language that is hard to reconcile. The goal is conflict resolution. That doesn't mean that the actions are condoned just that there are plenty of ways to respond to situations like this.
We quite clearly have a lot of remaining issues from our past. Slavery, segregation, civil wars... it's been a fucking shit show. But so has basically everywhere else.
I'd say that events in Ferguson are more a reflection of our traumatic past than evidence of some sort of paranoid future of oppression. The oppression is behind us, fading away. Fear and mutual misunderstanding is what will lead us back to that bullshit.
Sure, but if you look at the situation: a black kid was gunned down in broad daylight by a police officer, shot at point-blank range and then shot repeatedly while he was trying to escape, without any evidence of danger to the officer or even wrongdoing.
Now you have that same police department rolling in military kit, tear-gassing film crews and assaulting journalists.
I think it's pretty legitimate to be pissed off at the police in this case, but I don't think the police have any justification for their actions.
- Fully militarized police with a Tank(!) and multiple snipers with assault rifles confronting unarmed civilian protesters.[1]
- Tear gassing and arresting reporters
- Al-Jazera news crew was shot at and tear gassed [2]
- No fly zone over all of Ferguson
- Street level blockades & teargassing of porches to keep people inside
- No badges, tags or any identifying marks on police
- etc, etc,
This is a disgrace for America and a wake up call for all of us.
[1] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bu9CVPGIYAA_tFz.jpg:large [2] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bu-N9uIIIAEImna.jpg:large