News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by hentrep on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @06:33PM (#8175317)
I've always wondered how someone born blind is able to wrap their mind around the concept of color. It appears you've done so -- how would you describe color?
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by jareds on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @08:41PM (#8175576)
I don’t have any meaningful concept of color. I do have some light perception so assume that white is what I see if you shine a light in my eye, black is what I see when all the lights are turned off and gray is the middle ground when there are some lights turned on but not enough for the light to actually be painful. Intellectually I realize there are other colors but the only way I can explain them is in reference to objects. Grass is green, the ocean is blue, etc. I realize that this is meaningless since I don’t have a frame of reference to compare the ocean to grass from a visual perspective.
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by lisper on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @09:18PM (#8175672)
If you have some light perception, what happens if you shine different colors of light in your eye?
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by jareds on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @10:18PM (#8175782)
Nothing, it looks the same to me.
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by Rapzid on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @11:03PM (#8175869)
I suppose it is possible you're perceiving the light as a particular color, but if you can only perceive that color you would mistaken it for white?
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by gohrt on Thursday August 14, 2014 @12:10AM (#8176074)
I don't know what jareds's situation is, but normal humans have light sensors that are not color sensors, and also have color sensors

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photoreceptor_cell

Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by Chinjut on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @06:44PM (#8175351)
Why should the concept of color be harder to wrap one's mind around or describe than the concept of sight itself? Or, considering any animal with any kind of sensory receptors other than those you yourself have, wrapping your mind around or describing the concept of the data produced by such receptors? [A bat's echolocatory sense, say, or magnetoception...]

["Oh, it's easy to understand the PHYSICS and BIOLOGY of color, but can the blind really comprehend the EXPERIENCE of color?", some might say. Alright, fine, shades of "What Mary Didn't Know", but I'm not keen to get into that.]

Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by hentrep on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @07:36PM (#8175479)
I suppose what I was getting at is this: How do you explain what color is to a natively-blind person in a non-mathematical, non-physics based approach? In other words, the way most of the world learns about color (qualitatively). You can't use words like "shade" or "hue", because the very definition of those words are themselves tied to color.

For example, attempt to describe a baseball. Descriptions invoking roundness and texture can be easily understood because the individual retains his/her sense of feel. But saying "it's white in color... white is actually the presence of all colors..." obviously doesn't work.

I'd be curious to hear an example of how you would explain color to someone who has been blind for life.

Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by dandelany on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @07:51PM (#8175510)
I've thought about this before, and concluded that the best analogy to draw would likely be that of sound pitch or timbre.

When a sound is close to you, it seems louder. When it's far away, it seems quieter. But sounds have other qualities which are perceived the same regardless of distance - pitch being the most recognizable. And a sound's pitch changes how you perceive it unconsciously - that is, there is a "qualia" to hearing a low sound vs. a high sound that cannot really be explained.

Similarly, visible objects which are close appear larger and those far away appear smaller. But visible objects have other qualities which are perceived the same regardless of distance - namely color. And an object's color also has a certain "qualia" that unconsciously affects how you feel about it.

This has the added advantage of making it easy to explain Doppler shift vs. redshift :)

Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by aliakbarkhan on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @11:45PM (#8176018)
Try looking into qualia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by Rapzid on Thursday August 14, 2014 @05:35AM (#8176685)
Perhaps it's as good a place as any to make a scientific explanation but... I can see, hear, and understand the science behind light and sound. But as I sit here and think about it there is no link in my mind between the science of light and the EXPERIENCE of perceiving a color :|
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by jimmaswell on Thursday August 14, 2014 @12:27AM (#8176109)
This was touched on in The Giver, interestingly. The main character becomes able to see color after never having been able to.
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by LeoPanthera on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @07:53PM (#8175523)
Assuming they can still hear, I would probably try to explain the colour of light to be analogous to the pitch of sound.
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by furyofantares on Thursday August 14, 2014 @01:59PM (#8178765)
I imagine a blind person can study light just as well as anyone else, and can learn about the eye and can understand that sighted people are able to detect both wavelength and intensity differences. Just like a deaf person could learn about pressure waves in the air and how they can be detected by functional ears.

But it's probably difficult or impossible to understand what the perception is like, and how rich it is, except by analogy when thinking about how they'd try to describe the senses the do have to someone that doesn't have them.

Our understanding of echolocation in bats or the magnetic field in birds is probably similar. We understand what they detect and how they detect it. But I don't think we have any understanding of what it's like to experience that perception.

Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by jes5199 on Thursday August 14, 2014 @02:26PM (#8178952)
There's a classic essay by Thomas Nagel that makes this exact point in great detail: "What is it like to be a bat" http://organizations.utep.edu/portals/1475/nagel_bat.pdf
Re:What Do Blind People Actually See? by marcosscriven on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @10:43PM (#8175823)
This reminds me of musicians, particularly those with perfect pitch, who talk of 'colours' of keys. While it's not a direct analogy, perhaps one way to think of colour, if you've never seen it before, is to think of different wavelengths of sounds being a bit like different wavelengths of light.