However, you will get to network with some good talent if you visit startup school.
Almost everybody I met was doing something interesting, and I had a bunch of great conversations about the realities of startups that weekend. It's a part of the reason that I left my job several months later and joined a small startup.
The talks are more inspirational than informative, but seeing them live was a great experience. What really made it great for me was the chance to be around hundreds of like-minded individuals and have a few conversations about startups that I'd not have gotten in my home city (I live outside SV). There are also pre and post parties to attend and meet more people. There's just an atmosphere there that can't be created easily.
If airfare wasn't an issue, I'd not hesitate to go again. I am assuming it is still free. It was well worth the day I invested.
I highly recommend attending if you get the chance. I've been twice and both times have been well worth it (I traveled from Texas both times).
I attended Startup School NYC, but would have got the same out of sitting down and watching the videos seriously. (The key is to actually do a serious viewing session instead of half heartedly watching them over microwaved lunches).
If you ask me, the primary reason to attend startup school is that you'll see a lot of "famous" people who are just names to you, and you'll begin to realize that they're human. That's a worthwhile experience if you've never done it before, but I wouldn't go into the event with grander expectations.
The hallway conversations and the networking was indeed vibrant and full of energy, but no different than any other startup event, or sxsw, or meetups, or...
I'd say that there are smaller and more focused events (Eyeo comes to mind, even though not free and much longer), that are more rewarding. Anyway, I'd probably go again if invited, mostly for FOMO (fear of missing out).
If you're going just for the talks, then I agree, just watch the videos. If you're going for the networking and/or to visit the area, then it's worthwhile.
I'm taking a week, maybe 2, to visit old friends, explore, and network. Maybe some work too.
It's a weekly email newsletter of startup events happening in San Francisco & Silicon Valley, and DISCLOSURE I am a volunteer "Events Curator" for it.
[1] https://www.startupdigest.com/digests (search for "Silicon Valley-SF Bay Area")
The energy is very good, and its very fun. I've learned much, been inspired to do more and better things, and some of the friendships I've made have been very deep, some of the connections very useful. If you've never been, it's very worth going.
I've watched videos of past events, and they seem to follow the TED model of being amusing and inspirational but not particularly informative; I'm too cynical to be interested in "inspirational". On the other hand, I get the feeling that the hallway track might be good.