News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coders at work is finally available by jasonkester on Friday September 11, 2009 @10:17AM (#817377)
Founders at Work is one of those books that I keep finding myself re-reading over and over. There is so much good stuff there.

For some reason, the description of this book just doesn't inspire me to read it. It's hard to articulate why that is, since it's in the same style as Founders, and it interviews a similar set of people.

Maybe it's just that I've heard enough from that generation of programmers. Maybe I've just heard enough from all programmers. Maybe, talking about programming is simply not interesting at all. I don't know.

Tell me about how you launched a billion dollar company from your apartment with stolen office chairs and I'm there. Tell me how you really like pointers, and I sort of lose interest.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:47AM (#817540)
"Tell me about how you launched a billion dollar company from your apartment with stolen office chairs and I'm there. Tell me how you really like pointers, and I sort of lose interest."

Thankfully (for the authors and publishers), for some of us, that is reversed. The phrasing can be different.

"Tell me how and why you created a new language, and I am interested. Tell me how hard work and determination is how you made your money and the key to success for the rest of us and I lose interest"

EDIT: Ok I am reading the pdf version now and it is VERY enjoyable.

from the first chapter/interview

"Seibel: What about XScreenSaver—do you still work on that? Zawinski: I still write new screen savers every now and then just for kicks, and that’s all C.

Seibel: Do you use some kind of IDE for that?

Zawinski: I just use Emacs, mostly. Though recently, I ported XScreenSaver to OS X. The way I did that was I reimplemented Xlib in terms of Cocoa, the Mac graphics substrate, so I wouldn’t have to change the source code of all the screen savers. They’re still making X calls but I implemented the back end for each of those. And that was in Objective C, which actually is a pretty nice language. I enjoyed doing that. It definitely feels Java-like in the good ways but it also feels like C. Because it’s essentially C, you can still link directly with C code and just call the functions and not have to bend over backwards."

............................................

"Seibel: Six or seven being the whole Netscape development team or the Unix development team?

Zawinski: That was the whole client team. There were also the server folks who were implementing their fork of Apache, basically. We didn’t talk to them much because we were busy. We had lunch with them, but that was it. So we figured out what we wanted to be in the thing and we divided up the work so that there were, I guess, no more than two people working on any part of the project. I was doing the Unix side and Lou Montulli did most of back-end network stuff. And Eric Bina was doing layout and Jon Mittelhauser and Chris Houck were doing the Windows front end and Aleks Toti and Mark Lanett were doing the Mac front end for the pre–version 1.0 team. Those teams grew a little bit after that. But we’d have our meetings and then go back to our cubicles and be heads-down for 16 hours trying to make something work.

" ...........................................

"They thought just by virtue of being here, they were bound for glory doing it their way. But when they were doing it their way, at their company, they failed. So when the people who had been successful said to them, “Look, really, don’t use C++; don’t use threads,” they said, “What are you talking about? You don’t know anything.” Well, it was decisions like not using C++ and not using threads that made us ship the product on time. The other big thing was we always shipped all platforms simultaneously; that was another thing they thought was just stupid. “Oh, 90 percent of people are using Windows, so we’ll focus on the Windows side of things and then we’ll port it later.” Which is what many other failed companies have done. If you’re trying to ship a cross-platform product, history really shows that’s how you don’t do it. If you want it to really be cross-platform, you have to do them simultaneously. The porting thing results in a crappy product on the second platform.

They didn’t start from scratch with a blank disk but they eventually replaced every line of code. And they used C++ from the beginning. Which I fought against so hard and, dammit, I was right. It bloated everything;

"

...........................................

there's lots of interesting anecdotes and insights about his work with Peter Norvig at Berkeley, with Lucid and at Netscape and how he learned lisp and how he hates perl but uses it anyway and the hardest bug he ever encountered ( real doozy but i won't spoil the surprise for you) and so on .. And that's just Chapter 1.

I must be weird but I really enjoy reading stuff like that.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by jasonkester on Saturday September 12, 2009 @03:45AM (#818740)
Thanks for the snippets. That's pretty much exactly what I was afraid it would be like. Kind of "Ghost of a new machine" without any of the things that made it interesting.

I can certainly see why this sort of thing would appeal to some folks. For me though, I don't think I could sit through a whole book of bitter guys complaining: "they rewrote my thing in C++ and it failed. Told you so!"

Founders was about inspiration. From what you show, Coders is not.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Saturday September 12, 2009 @04:32AM (#818764)
"Founders was about inspiration. From what you show, Coders is not."

For you, sure. I find both inspiring (in different ways).

The point was it depends on the person. I would be bored stiff listening to yet another business guy talk about how he made his billions. I like programmers stories about their successes, failures, learning and insights. As someone else said , "different strokes".

"I don't think I could sit through a whole book of bitter guys "

If you think Don Knuth, Peter Norvig, Simon Peyton Jones and Jamie Zawinski (randomly picked from the book's interviewees) are "bitter guys complaining" (!), based on one sentence in a small set of excerpts(!!), this book is certainly not for you!

I like Founders at Work. I like Coders at Work. They are both great books.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by mncaudill on Friday September 11, 2009 @10:28AM (#817398)
Different strokes for different folks, my man. The business-oriented people can read Founders, the technical-minded people can read can read Coders, and then the intersection of the two can read both!

I personally find the idea of this book to be fascinating and pre-ordered it a couple of weeks ago.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by ionfish on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:06AM (#817463)
> [T]he union of the two can read both!

Don't you mean the intersection of the two?

Re:Coders at work is finally available by mncaudill on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:19AM (#817486)
Good catch--I edited it to correct the wrongness. Fingers going faster than the brain on a Friday morning...
Re:Coders at work is finally available by edw519 on Friday September 11, 2009 @10:32AM (#817408)
Tell me about how you launched a billion dollar company from your apartment with stolen office chairs and I'm there. Tell me how you really like pointers, and I sort of lose interest.

Thank you. I thought I was the only one.

95% of the time I program. 5% I conduct business.

But for learning, the ratio is reversed. Whether it's hacker news, the articles I read on the web, or the books on my shelves, my interest is mainly in business stories, especially start-up success stories.

Not really sure why. Maybe because I think I have all the technology I need. If I need more, I'll find it and learn it. Always have, always will. It's nice to learn a new technique here and there, especially with data base and web technology, but that's rare.

The business success stories, OTOH, almost always fascinate me. I love Founders at Work and for some odd reason, Marcus Frind of plentyoffish is like a mythic hero to me: If a regular guy like him can do it, then so can the rest of us.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by DannoHung on Friday September 11, 2009 @01:36PM (#817741)
Maybe this is why you spend so much time programming and so little time doing business.
Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Friday September 11, 2009 @10:28AM (#817399)
Yeah I feel similar. Programming isn't that hard :/

Building a successful startup, selling stuff, getting investment etc etc - They seem orders of magnitude harder than programming.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:52AM (#817549)
" Programming isn't that hard"

Whoa! doesn't that depend very much on what exactly you mean by "programming" and which specific program you are trying to create ?

Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:13PM (#817919)
Pick a webapp. Lets take twitter or facebook, or even youtube. I'm sure there's some really interesting problems when you drill down, and it'd take a fair while to conquer the problems, but it's just a large mountain - just takes longer to climb. I'm sure most of us could build a facebook/twitter/youtube clone if we decided to.

The hard bit of course would be getting people to use it.

The world is absolutely littered with fantastic clever well written programs, that no one uses. This is why I think programming is far easier than convincing someone to use it and all that other non-programming stuff, and why I personally am far more interested in the non-technical side of the equation. In comparison, the technical side is trivial.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by sanswork on Friday September 11, 2009 @07:22PM (#818331)
People always assume this with sites like youtube/facebook/twitter/etc but they forget that the most interesting problems tend to come from the requirements of scaling.

From my experience most people seem to have their wall at which point they can't possibly conceive of a better way to scale X until someone comes along and goes "Try this". My experience also says this level is pretty low for most people.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by bad_user on Saturday September 12, 2009 @03:22AM (#818731)
> Pick a webapp.

Google :)

> The world is absolutely littered with fantastic clever well written programs, that no one uses.

The world is also littered with twitter/facebook/youtube clones that no one uses.

What sets apart the wannabes from the successful ones is (among other things) the implementation.

I find much joy in doing clever things. If those things end-up being used by other people then I literary have an orgasm. But doing something simple that happens to end-up popular because of happening at the right time ... that's really a turn-off (look honey, this website of mine got really popular so now I have to maintain it ... oh joy). Fortunately that happens less and less because the low-hanging fruits are already taken.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by holygoat on Friday September 11, 2009 @09:48PM (#818495)
Webapps are not the only thing to program. Heck, they aren't even the only subject of a startup
Re:Coders at work is finally available by iron_ball on Friday September 11, 2009 @01:39PM (#817743)
Programming isn't that hard, but the business side is? The scales have been lifted from my eyes! Next time a "business guy" wants me to implement his great new idea for an iPhone app, I'll totally make it for him!
Re:Coders at work is finally available by abstractbill on Friday September 11, 2009 @02:27PM (#817824)
I think what axod is saying (and I agree), is that being a random "business guy" who wants you to implement your great new idea is easy. But being a really great business guy, on the level of someone like Richard Branson, is really hard.

And, unlike programming, which is "easy" to learn in the sense that there's a hell of a lot of resources that teach you how to do it, there simply is no way to learn how to be the next Branson.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:19PM (#817928)
" But being a really great business guy, on the level of someone like Richard Branson, is really hard."

Well then, the analogy (for programming) should be to become someone like Ken Thompson . And that's equally hard (or harder).

Being a really great X guy, is really hard, for most values of X.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by abstractbill on Friday September 11, 2009 @05:59PM (#818225)
I take your point, but I would still assert there are more and better resources for learning how to be the next Ken Thompson than there are for learning how to be the next Richard Branson.
Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:32PM (#817955)
But being an awesome excellent programmer doesn't mean guaranteed success in any real measurable way. Maybe some recognition from peers, but certainly not in monetary terms. Begin an awesome excellent business guy does mean success in a measurable way.
Re:Coders at work is finally available by keyist on Saturday September 12, 2009 @02:46AM (#818712)
"Being an awesome excellent business guy does mean success in a measurable way."

You are committing the logical fallacy of converse accident, essentially saying: "All awesome excellent business guys I have heard of is are successful financially, therefore it is true that all excellent business guys are successful." Survivor bias comes into play here too -- you don't get to hear stories of those with the exact same set of skills and personality as other 'business greats' who went bankrupt.

"Maybe some recognition from peers, but certainly not in monetary terms."

You can measure success in ways other than money. A programmer can count the number of users who have benefitted from using their code. A violinist can count number of standing ovations at concerts. An athlete can count number of medals/trophies. A parent can count number of successful children content with life.

Not everyone defines their success in terms of their net worth.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:39PM (#817976)
"But being an awesome excellent programmer doesn't mean success in any real measurable way."

Being an awesome excellent violinist (say) doesn't mean success in any "measurable way" either. There is no absolute, objective ranking for violinist, but becoming an "awesome excellent" violinist is still just as hard or harder than becoming Richard Branson.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Sunday September 13, 2009 @03:19AM (#819918)
Apples and Oranges.

End users don't care if a program was written well or not. They care if it solves their problem. There are countless examples of horrible buggy badly written programs that are wildly successful. There aren't many examples of horrible bad violinists that are successful.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by plinkplonk on Sunday September 13, 2009 @03:32AM (#819928)
Your original statements were "being an awesome excellent programmer doesn't mean guaranteed success in any real measurable way. " and "Begin an awesome excellent business guy does mean success in a measurable way."

When the argument was made that success has meanings beyond "how much money someone made" or needs an absolute scale of measurement to define it, you are now saying that software that is not well written can be successful, Sure, but by that logic then many businessmen get rich by luck, not by being "awesome excellent business guys". So ? Still doesn't affect the irrelevance of your original argument.

There are godawful musicians who lip synch songs and can barely maintain pitch but are successful in terms of making money. You need to let go of thinking that your ideas of what "success" is, is somehow universally held or accepted.

( I am done with this thread. It isn't worth the time. )

Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:05PM (#817889)
Thanks ;) You put it far better than me.
Re:Coders at work is finally available by mncaudill on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:49AM (#817542)
Programming isn't that hard? Writing code is easy, writing good code is hard, otherwise more people would do it, right?
Re:Coders at work is finally available by axod on Friday September 11, 2009 @12:02PM (#817566)
Alright. Sorry... Programming is about as hard as mathematics I'd say - you can just learn it, and if you have the talent and perseverance, you can be a good programmer.

So yes, perhaps this book will be more interesting to non-programmers, or people who are just starting out programming.

It's the other things I find more interesting, that were covered in founders at work - the things that seem like luck - how do you get people to use your product? How do you make money? build a team? etc etc.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by randallsquared on Friday September 11, 2009 @12:22PM (#817611)
It's the other things I find more interesting, that were covered in founders at work - the things that seem like luck [...]

This is precisely why I don't find those other things very interesting: they seem like luck (to a degree larger than things that interest me more, at least). Gambling is also uninteresting, for the same reason: there's too much luck involved.

Re:Coders at work is finally available by jalammar on Friday September 11, 2009 @11:48AM (#817541)
There's certainly something to learn about entrepreneurship from some of these guys.

I'm really looking forward to reading about Brad Fitzpatrick. He founded Live Journal, and made or started a lot of the software that powers many giant web startups (Memchached, MogileFS, OpenID...etc).