News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polaroid Cube by georgemcbay on Monday August 11, 2014 @06:21PM (#8165624)
"I thought the video quality was extremely high"

Actually the video quality looks terrible. Compare the bits actually shot with the Cube (most of the promo video isn't... you can clearly see when they switch to the shots the Cube itself took at ~0:22-0:26 and ~0:42-0:44, notice how they switch away from the Cube video pretty damn quickly, probably because it is so terrible... doesn't even look actually 1080p as a source, looks like they are interpolating it up from something lower, frame rate looks bad, massive chromatic aberration).

Compare Cube (switch YouTube player to 1080p if it doesn't auto select that, note that most of the promo video is not Cube footage, pay specific attention to ~0:22-0:26 and ~0:42-0:44):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePO6OKYyOec

To, say, the Mobius (switch YouTube player to 1080p if it doesn't auto select that):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YlSvoKlIaPk

Mobius costs less than the Cube ($80 vs $99), video quality is miles better even when capturing a much faster-moving scene.

I can see reasons why people might buy the Cube... it is cute, the monkey stand is pretty cool; but in terms of price vs image quality it is a clear loser, IMO.

Re:Polaroid Cube by soup10 on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:33PM (#8166057)
This is identical to the sentiment against iPod when it first came out. If the design is good, user friendly, and people still like the product, it won't matter if it's got worse specs since they can always improve them in later releases.
Re:Polaroid Cube by simias on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @06:39AM (#8167242)
If I remember correctly the iPod lacked some features that could have been expected from the product when the first version came out (the famous "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame." quoted else where in this thread. Also, firewire). But the features that were in the iPod worked fine. In this case however I agree with the parent who says the video, the only thing this cube is supposed to do well, is pretty terrible looking by 2014 standards.

Here's a still of the video for reference: https://i.imgur.com/wIF1SFt.jpg

There's so much wrong in this picture I'm not sure where to start. And that's a promotional video!

Re:Polaroid Cube by danudey on Thursday August 14, 2014 @09:29AM (#8177307)
And yet, this is more than enough quality for most people.
Re:Polaroid Cube by georgemcbay on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:00PM (#8166308)
The UX for these cameras is basically "hit record button, see red light go on"; I don't think there is room for any player to win on iPod-style usability.

They either need to sell on lifestyle branding (where GoPro is already owning the market) or quality, IMO.

Re:Polaroid Cube by adav on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @06:57AM (#8167277)
What about the complicated menu structure of a GoPro Hero3+? Surely there's massive scope for improvement there?

Would a non-technical person understand pro's and con's of the trade-off between 1080p24 and 720p120? I doubt it.

Re:Polaroid Cube by araes on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @01:33PM (#8168971)
A lot of opinion, but as a normal consumer, I think this looks fine, or at least "good enough".

I agree, the Mobius video does look better. But, I think that most of the decision doesn't come down to video quality for a normal person. Its like graphics on video games. There's a very vocal crowd that espouses 1080p / 60 Hz refresh rates, but most normal people are as likely to play Candy Crush as a cinematic Final Fantasy or God of War. Its just not that much of a discriminator for the non-hardcore.

Anecdotally, I bought a Go Pro a while back. What really mattered was: "Can I easily use this for the activity I'm planning (I wanted to be able to set a camera on my shoulder)?", "Can I easily work with / upload the video after I'm done?", and "Is this a product that people online say works?"

Re:Polaroid Cube by richardneville on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @02:48PM (#8174410)
Hey - you're absolutely right about the video quality. Thanks for pointing it out.

The cube looks like a great product, but I was wondering if it will be pro quality. Your post helps.

GoPro actually does produce usable pro-quality HD video. Amazing for such a compact and simple device. Great colour balance, great lens, very little CA, etc., etc.

Cube is clearly not competing with that. It looks like a great fun product, and I reckon I'll buy one... but I won't be able to justify that purchase professionally!

Re:Polaroid Cube by cc439 on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:28PM (#8166364)
Agreed, sub-$40 Chinese Go-Pro knock-offs offer superior performance on top of their silly cheap price tags.
Re:Polaroid Cube by nodata on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @08:52AM (#8167511)
Can you recommend one?
Re:Polaroid Cube by robodale on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @11:31AM (#8173342)
It might be sub-par to some people right now, but they are establishing a beachhead in the market. They can certainly improve feature/performance/product line and expand out from there.