On the other hand, the use of Direct3D is a competitive advantage for them. It made ports easier with the XBox 360 and it probably still makes them easier for the XBox One.
If as a developer I could have one codebase and target all three platforms it would be pretty compelling.
I mean, I know why - it is because the entire console model is license deals, app store cuts, and exclusives. If you could write your games and seamlessly run them everywhere, console manufacturers lose their primary pitch to consumers. Especially since this console generation isn't amazing value hardware wise, you can build a computer as powerful as either for the same price as either.
And peripherals are an awful argument, because they are all wifi / bluetooth / usb based, nothing stops these companies from selling their accessories like the Move, Kinect, Wiimote, etc as pc peripherals with open APIs besides their complacency.
Valve is just entering consoles scene. It's too early to call that pressure, but they at least plan to disrupt it. Time will tell.
> it is because the entire console model is license deals, app store cuts, and exclusives.
Yes, that's why this sick approach needs some serious disruption. Linux gaming looks like one.
> if you could write your games and seamlessly run them everywhere, console manufacturers lose their primary pitch to consumers.
Exclusivity is a weird pitch. Real pitch of consoles should be in ease of access, usability and user friendliness.
> you can build a computer as powerful as either for the same price as either.
That's exactly what consoles should be about - plug and play. No building for those who don't want it. All of that doesn't preclude using cross platform technologies. Let console makers compete on hardware (Asus, Dell whoever) and not on locking developers into their walled garden proprietary OS and APIs.
You mean MS doesn't want it. MS is not everybody though. Xbox is one of the ways they can keep DirectX around in the face of potential competition as you said yourself:
> Direct3D is a competitive advantage for them
Though I'd call it an anti-competitive advantage.
As far as I'm aware, devs aren't too keen on it. No other maor consoles are using it anyway, so the X-platform argument doesn't really apply.
1. http://www.amd.com/en-us/innovations/software-technologies/m...
2. https://developer.apple.com/library/prerelease/ios/documenta...
Also, Mantle was supposed to be open. Did AMD open it already?
Because of current market lock-in on DirectX. OpenGL isn't ideal, but it's not much behind. MS however doesn't want it to become better and is scared of more competition from cross platform APIs. Not sure why though. These days lock-in with API is a very dumb method to compete.
I think Valve has a good potential to push things forward.
Regardless of FOSS myths, no console has proper OpenGL[0] support.
[0] Yes, not even the PS3.
Valve will have to do lots of work just to try to pull off the same quality of developer support console vendors offer.
Let them. Improving developers' tools around OpenGL was one of their key plans in this effort. So far they look serious about it.
But on the console, the target is constant, and every Xbox One or every Playstation 4 is identical to every other of the same console on the market. The overhead of the OpenGL/DirectX driver reduces performance, and unlike in the PC market it's no longer solving a problem -- you can very easily support two to three consoles without resorting to abstraction layers, and new consoles only come out sometime between five and ten years, so you don't have to do a lot of churn to keep up with hardware revisions.
Valve isn't shipping consoles, they're shipping living room PCs -- with all the diversity of hardware that implies. Some Steam Boxes will use Nvidia, others Intel or ATI. Games designed to run on Steam Boxes need to support all of those. They need OpenGL. But current consoles don't, and no amount of OpenGL stumping by Valve will change that, because OpenGL solves a problem the consoles have never had.
That's exactly what should change. Such situation can exist only because of lack of competition. With increased competition the overhead of writing bare metal code to support many targets will become prohibitive on consoles as well, and console makers will be forced to support portable higher level APIs. Squeezing performance by being closer to bare hardware was more reasonable in the past, when it was too weak and extra abstraction introduced too much performance penalty. Modern day hardware should be already better in this regard. And modern OpenGL isn't introducing much overhead if used properly.
> OpenGL solves a problem the consoles have never had.
They always had that problem, except there were too few of them and the problem didn't become criticial. Increased competition will blow that problem into different proportions. Supporting 2 console APIs is possible. Supporting 10 is insane and developers should demand a portable layer in such situation.
Why? For people who don't want to deal with the Xbox One/Playstation 4 monocultures, there's PC gaming. It already exists. The people who choose consoles over PC gaming choose it because it's more convenient. And that convenience derives in large part from the monoculture (or duoculture, I guess). Low-overhead bare metal programming is what enables the relatively long life of most consoles compared to PC gaming, because developers have time to learn how to get the absolute best performance out of a particular hardware configuration. It costs less money up-front in hardware costs, and it's a lot less work to figure out if a game will work on your system or not (almost no work, actually).
Because dealing with many APIs is an extra effort and proprietary APIs make games harder to port to other platforms. Of course those who have unlimited resources are free to write games even in assembly for each platform, but most don't have such resources.
> And that convenience derives in large part from the monoculture
Convenience of users has nothing to do with monoculture. It has something to do with form factor and design of hardware and software interfaces. Monoculture is just a sick method to lock developers into one platform. Convenience of developers on the other hand should not be based on poor competition. That's a dangerous convenience which leads to stagnation.
> Low-overhead bare metal programming is what enables the relatively long life of most consoles compared to PC gaming
Which is a double sided issue. Longer update cycle makes development simpler but it also limits creativity by artificial technical limits. The update cycle of consoles can be reasonably more frequent.
Game engine middleware. No sane people should be using 3D API directly anyway, unless they are writing their own engine or learning 3D programming.