Nowhere on Fivver's website do they claim you are getting a unique one-of-a-kind hand-designed logo
On the other hand, http://www.fiverr.com/search/gigs?utf8=%E2%9C%93&search_in=e...I think the larger issue is that some of these come from stock photo sites which place restrictions on using them as logos. I'd be more than a little annoyed if I built a brand around a $5 logo and then hit legal trouble because of it.
You make it sound like hand-crafting is hard. I can pump out custom bespoke geometric shapes in seconds!
*edit, this part was only in the linked longer version of the first part of the article
I'm sorry, but if someone says in their profile headline, "I will design amazing logos for $5" then I expect it to be more than just clipart or color-shaded text.
I think you can't expect to buy a Ferrari at the Hyundai price point. If you want more, you're going to have to pay more.
And when you say 'most company logo's are not much more than clipart' - you're refering the the simple construction and form of the icon used in a logo. Apple, Microsoft, and IBM obviously didn't pull their logos from a stock library.
Although it's interesting to hear such logo's be described with such flippant regard for their conception.
Nowhere on Fivver's website do they claim you are getting a unique one-of-a-kind hand-designed logo -- you are paying $5 for someone else to tell you what a sensible logo should be and provide a few decent choices for starting out with... and that can be valuable (I know because as an engineer, the creative side of things often escape me).
I see no issue here. For my side project websites and companies, these sorts of logos (and at this price point) is exactly what I would look for.