Re:The Lie Behind 1.2B Stolen Passwords
by userbinator on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:47AM
(#8152706)
I think the notion of "stolen" passwords should be replaced with pirated passwords, unless the attackers really did something different from just gaining access to and copying them.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Lie Behind 1.2B Stolen Passwords
by tedunangst on Friday August 08, 2014 @10:15AM
(#8152835)
Semantic arguments about the meaning of stealing are only appropriate in discussions about copying other people's stuff. When it's our stuff getting copied, then it's theft plain and simple.
Re:The Lie Behind 1.2B Stolen Passwords
by Dylan16807 on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:22PM
(#8153593)
It's not the fact that the passwords are being copied, it's that someone without access took access.
The closest analogy to media piracy is someone with a password telling it to their friend.
In short, the difference is between 'sharing' and 'taking'. It's not about whose data. It's not hypocritical.
(That said, feel free to disagree with the opinion, but don't accidentally strawman it. Maybe it would be better to use a different word here too, but this sort of thing is much closer to theft because of that lack of consent and breach of privacy.)
Re:The Lie Behind 1.2B Stolen Passwords
by icebraining on Friday August 08, 2014 @10:31AM
(#8152900)
No, just when it requires illegal access to a system, instead of legally buying the stuff and then offering copies to others.
Oh, I see. So THAT law, you like.
Re:The Lie Behind 1.2B Stolen Passwords
by icebraining on Friday August 08, 2014 @11:02AM
(#8153086)
I said nothing about liking any law. I just said one easily equates to theft, while the other one doesn't[1].
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dowling_v._United_States_(1985)
So... I suspect there's some trolling going on but the problem with password/creditcards being stolen is that they steal my monies out of my bank or mess up my twitter/facebook/youtube/etc account. Depending on who you are, that could be a real problem.
The piracy issue is about outdated-business models being supported by ridiculous laws with insane consequences.