News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by paulannesley on Friday August 08, 2014 @03:14AM (#8151824)
Choice quotes from ast:

> 5 years from now [1992 -> 1997] everyone will be running free GNU on their 200 MIPS, 64M SPARCstation-5

> My point is that writing a new operating system that is closely tied to any particular piece of hardware, especially a weird one like the Intel line, is basically wrong.

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by bhaak on Friday August 08, 2014 @05:37AM (#8152079)
The second quote continues with "An OS itself should be easily portable to new hardware platforms".

The 1.0 release in 1994 only supported i386 machines. Only after considerable efforts and changes to the code Linux got ported to different platforms with 1.2 and AFAIK even the port to 68k and PowerPC for 2.0 needed again quite some work.

So, history proved him right. ;-) Of course, Linus didn't intend to write a portable OS but only one for AT clones.

Maybe Tanenbaum didn't foresee that Linux would jump across to that many different platforms that it eventually did but with his experience he probably already saw the possible need to port it to newer machines if Linux would be useful for some people.

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by waps on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:33PM (#8155955)
Tanenbaum is an academic. The ivory tower got (and gets) the microkernel debate wrong. Microkernels are a "better architecture" and that, to them, justifies performance levels that are abysmal. It took them decades to get it working in the first place, and again this is not seen as a problem.

This is how academia works. For a long time:

micro kernels were universally perceived as better

despite never having seen a working one

despite the few attempts at a working kernel could not run basic programs, never mind a decent interface

despite every successful kernel ever being monolithic (exception, to some extent, is QNX)

and of course these messages were posted from machines that ran ... monolithic kernels

And of course : they admitted to using their power to force people "the right way" in this debate. Both ast and tanenbaum point out that they'd deduct points/fail students who took the wrong stance. (presumably, of course, they'd also fire any phd students who do the same)

Please keep this in mind next time you hear that academics widely support idea X.

Think of academia like a hell of a lot of climate debates, except with the protagonists' positions usually not very well supported, or outright contradicted by the real world. Or even worse : the position is a choice, with no real argument one way or the other, with a strict hierarchy between people, and the higher ups very willing to abuse their power.

It took me a long time to get out of academia, and out of this madness. I wrote papers, dissertations, and here's how that plays out "Good boy ! +1 (not in pay of course). Publish. Copy to the library. Now put it in the trash and work on something else" (I had failed papers too, of course).

Let's just say that this is far from the only debate that works this way. There's many other things, like in programming languages, (extreme) static typing, (pure) funcional programming, dependent typing, garbage collection, rpc interfaces, object databases, machine learning nonsense, ...

Barring other information, I have realized, a good bet is this : if >70% of the academic researchers are on the same side for any particular claim, bet against that claim, just for that reason alone. And get out of academia, of course. Google, facebook, yahoo, microsoft, ... all are building large machine learning teams with actual resources, by far the best researchers in the world, people who demand actual results on some problems (yes, that's a plus), and continuity.

there is an extreme obsession with learning algorithms in academia. The whole thing is a worthless waste of time, for one simple reason : feature engineering can make k-means beat the crap out of the most advanced algorithm anyone's ever come up with. But new learning algorithms are much easier to write, much smaller to prove things about, and thus much, much easier to get a phd dissertation through a committee with. In practice "deep learning" is by far the most successful algorithm (which is another way to say running a 1963 algorithm at scale)

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by axaxs on Saturday August 09, 2014 @01:17PM (#8157381)
> Both ast and tanenbaum point out that they'd deduct points/fail

I agree with your post completely, but you do realize ast is Tanenbaum, right?

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by userbinator on Friday August 08, 2014 @10:34AM (#8152923)
That first quote is funny when you look at this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instructions_per_second#Timelin...

> Intel Pentium Pro 541 MIPS at 200 MHz ... 1996

Also this list of benchmarks suggests a SPARCstation5 was either slower or roughtly the same performance as the 1st-generation Pentiums (which came out in '93, only a year after that post): http://www.vintage-computer.com/vcforum/showthread.php?11079...

But this was definitely a time when betting on RISC-based desktops seemed like a good idea.

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by bluedino on Friday August 08, 2014 @10:50AM (#8153005)
Low-end Sun hardware wasn't exactly fast. When the Pentium came out the gap between RISC workstations and commodity Intel desktops really started to shrink
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by Rusky on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:03PM (#8153462)
Even better is that x86 started translating its instruction set into an internal RISC-like set, so RISC kind of won anyway.
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by mcv on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:40PM (#8153702)
RISC didn't "kind of" win; it really won, due to everybody walking around with tiny RISC computers in their pockets. Running a variety of linux.
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by Rusky on Friday August 08, 2014 @06:08PM (#8155322)
The important difference between traditional RISC and what we have now in either x86 or ARM is the instruction encoding. You have to have a compact instruction encoding or you waste memory bandwidth. That's part of why x86 eventually beat the old RISC designs and that why ARM has the Thumb encodings.
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by userbinator on Saturday August 09, 2014 @08:50AM (#8156792)
I don't think it's that clear of a victory; ARM is everywhere (and so is MIPS, to a lesser extent) and is commonly mentioned, that much is true, but there are far more ISAs that most people don't hear about in mundane embedded applications (of which there are many) - 8051, 6502, PIC, etc. which are definitely CISCs.

Also the x86 being "RISC-like" internally is a bit of a misnomer - x86 uops are much wider (118 bits for the P6, even wider for later models) than most RISCs' fixed 32-bit instructions. Modern RISCs like the ARM Cortex series also decode instructions into wider uops.

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by paulannesley on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @03:28PM (#8169661)
> 6502 … which are definitely CISCs

It seems the "6502 risc or cisc" debate was never really solved, as a Google search for that phrase will show.

Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by Joeri on Friday August 08, 2014 @12:54PM (#8153799)
Even the tiny windows computers are RISC machines. Windows NT also dates back to somewhere around 92 and made hardware independence a big deal. Dave Cutler had to fight tooth and nail to keep it in while lots if people were telling him to just build it for Intel.
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by arethuza on Friday August 08, 2014 @05:06AM (#8152015)
In the 1980s there was often an assumption that "all the world's a VAX" - in the 1990s there was often an equivalent assumption that "all the world's a Sun".
Re:The Tanenbaum-Torvalds Debate (1992) by marcosdumay on Friday August 08, 2014 @01:23PM (#8153969)
Just a few years ago, "all the world were an Intel/AMD". We are just starting with the "all the world's an ARM" mindset.

Some things never change.