Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ...
by Kalium on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:35PM
(#8138171)
Being able to compare a lot of options and filter down to just a handful that interest you is very valuable. It handles discovery and filtering steps in one go. There's your value-add.
You're asking for consumers to make significant decisions in what to them will feel like a position of ignorance. And you're asking for it because you think it will be profitable for you. Do you understand why I'm skeptical of this?
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ...
by AJ007 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:15PM
(#8138739)
I don't think anyone is saying aggregators should not show up.
Do a search for a local hotel. I just did one. I counted 3 aggregator ads above organic results. 6 aggregator ads on the side, 2 other hotel ads on the side.
Organic listing #1 is the hotel, that is good. 7 other results are aggregators. 1 is the hotel parent company, 1 is an unrelated hotel.
What happens if you are a niche travel site, or a local blog? Your not going to rank. Your business model is now more or less dead.
For those people I suggest they consider their fundamental reason for taking a vacation in the first place.
I think the prevalence of aggregation on holiday sites is simply causality of these companies not having a clear direction for their business. After all, it's easy to aggregate everything with the money and time to do so. But where is the value add?