News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:48AM (#8131264)
If the hotel is clear about these terms, then I don't see much of a problem with this. It makes it really easy to know to pick a different hotel.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by rrrx3 on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:55AM (#8131290)
I should be stating the obvious here, but the fact that I even have to post this means that obviously, I am not.

Just because something is written into the terms of an agreement doesn't make it legal.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by jebus989 on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:10AM (#8131343)
Yeah, you are not. Say someone writes a contract saying that they can slap me in the face and each time they do I must pay $100, if I carefully read and then sign that contract, and they then slap me three times — have I been assaulted or do I owe $300, or both?
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by JackC on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:29AM (#8131616)
This is actually a tricky question. Your assault & battery law probably says something like "unconsented or violent touching," so the fact that you consented doesn't matter, so you've been assaulted. And you can't enter a contract to perform an illegal act, so you don't owe $300 -- it's not a good contract.[1]

But it depends why you're being slapped! Obviously we can't go prosecuting everyone who intentionally whacks into someone else according to the rules of whatever sport they're playing, so we make an exception for that. This gets tricky with sports like boxing where the rules require you to do something that looks pretty much like a brutal assault, so the exceptions in that case get pretty finicky -- we might insist that you make your mutual-battery deals in public, in licensed boxing rings, instead of by giving Brad Pitt a nice manly handshake in the basement of a bar and refusing to talk about it later.

And then there's the whole gray area of less socially-accepted sports, like Quidditch or BDSM. We (even prosecutors) often approach things from the perspective of, "if this activity seems normal to me, it must be legal; if it seems wrong it must be illegal." When moral judgments and fear of the unknown creep into that analysis, it can lead to some twisted logic to justify the outcome we know must be right.

[1] Now consider whether you can be prosecuted for A&B as an accomplice.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by lifeisstillgood on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:09AM (#8131555)
You have been assaulted. Even professional boxers commit assault in every match. They just are not prosecuted for it because it is a sport and regulated and traditional. If they, for example, bite someone's ear off, then they do get prosecuted for assault. The fact it was in the ring during the fight does not stop that.

Your contract would be unenforceable btw - I could slap you three times (hell make it twenty) and walk off - you could not get any court to enforce payment. You could threaten to accuse me of assault if I did not pay up - but then you are blackmailing me and would do more time than I would for assault.

But I suspect that the hotel owner has been slapped by a couple of brides over this :-)

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by lotsofmangos on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:45AM (#8131466)
Boxing and other martial activities require you to contractually remove yourself from claiming you have been assaulted as long as any violence stays within agreed rules. It would be very hard to train people in boxing, if your customers could sue you for assault every time you hit them.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by danielweber on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:56AM (#8131509)
Context matters. Participation in a sport generally brings with it an expectation to receive minor injuries customary to that sport.

A legal contract depends on mutual understanding. People learning to box generally understand they are going to get hit. People booking a wedding party generally don't expect to be held responsible for their guests having opinions they post online. The hotel would have to make this policy very clear in order to achieve mutual understanding, and that doesn't mean just putting it on the contract and the webpage for the customer to find on their own.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:01AM (#8131520)
> Participation in a sport generally brings with it an expectation to receive minor injuries customary to that sport.

Participation in a contract that specifically covers terms for being slapped also bring with it an expectation of being slapped.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by danielweber on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:07AM (#8131548)
I'm not sure how this is a response.

It's not enough to have language in a contract. There needs to be understanding by both sides about what is being agreed to.

Since the Internet engaged mob-mode before engaging investigation-mode, we don't know how clear these terms are to people who are booking weddings.

It might be very clear because they send an email explicitly telling the bridal party about these terms and asking them to consent, which would also be a signal to the party about the quality of online reviews. Or it might be buried in the middle of 12 other clauses and the customer doesn't know about it.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:10AM (#8131559)
Obviously there needs to be mutual understanding of a contract for it to be enforced. The original question included the phrase "if I carefully read and then sign that contract," which I think indicates that the contract was mutually understood and agreed upon.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by sk5t on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:26AM (#8132138)
Mutual understanding is not the only ingredient that constitutes an enforceable contract. Issues such as duress, inequality of bargaining position, and in this case, the plain bizarre unreasonableness of the terms, can enter into the equation.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by rahimnathwani on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:29AM (#8131408)
There are people who pay for this sort of service. Or so I've heard.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by dragonwriter on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:33AM (#8131626)
Neither, maybe. As contract it seems to fail for lack of consideration, but it still probably is consent to being slapped so there is no assault.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:30AM (#8131410)
I would say that you owe $300.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by aestra on Monday August 04, 2014 @01:19PM (#8132862)
I would really like to know what specific law(s) do you think this private party is violating? I am very curious. I can't think of any off the top of my head.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by owksley on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:00AM (#8131309)
I think they know it's illegal / unconstitutional. They're banking on self-censorship by people who aren't certain where they stand legally.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by cookiecaper on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:53AM (#8131500)
...How is this "unconstitutional"? Not everything that is illegal is unconstitutional. I am also skeptical that this is illegal, but considering the jurisdiction may have many applicable laws, it's hard to say that it is or isn't illegal without significant research. But surely it has nothing to do with constitutional law.

Similar pieces of other contracts are valid and common and are called "non-disparagement clauses". I don't see how this differs.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by owksley on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:52AM (#8131695)
You're quite right. I hadn't realised that the constitution relates to actions between the government and the people only. Reading HN comments is always educational! I suppose it's more correct to say that it isn't in the spirit of the First Amendment, or free-speech in general.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by ulfw on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:56AM (#8131293)
!00% agree. It sure as hell doesn't make it right either.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:25AM (#8131394)
I deliberately used the phrase "I don't see much of a problem with this" rather than "this is legal." I have no idea if it's legal, but I know that I don't have a problem with it.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by ebbv on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:51AM (#8131276)
Doesn't matter where they claim this fee is legitimate, if the person refuses to pay (which I would), there's no way this would be upheld in civil court.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by chatmasta on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:58AM (#8131299)
According to the article, charges come out of your deposit. So that means it's on you to bring it to civil court after they take your money.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by Maskawanian on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:05AM (#8131321)
Easy to work around, make your review after the deposit comes back.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by dspillett on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:19AM (#8131374)
Or, if you've not signed anything yet, the better work around is to find another venue (and drop them a letter with proof of the booking for the other venue and an explanation as to why you passed them by and went with a competitor).
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by chatmasta on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:19AM (#8131595)
Your guests are the ones leaving the reviews, not you.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by cookiecaper on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:57AM (#8131512)
On what grounds would it be dismissed from a civil court? Similar clauses are in many contracts. I'm just curious if there's a reason to believe this is illegal other than simple unpopularity.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by JadeNB on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:12AM (#8131564)
> Similar clauses are in many contracts.

I'm not sure that I believe this. I can believe that there are some places out there that think that they can get away with enjoining you against posting negative reviews (until the law eventually settles down against that, as I'm sure that it will), but I find it hard to believe that there are many places that think that they can fine you for the actions of other people. Can you give examples?

EDIT: As baddox (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8131575) politely points out, I worded this badly. I want to say something like "the actions of other people over which you have no reasonable expectation of control" (for example: you can reasonably be expected to prevent guests in your room from damaging the furniture, but you cannot reasonably be expected to monitor the Internet usage of all your guests after they leave to make sure that they do not post a negative review).

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by cookiecaper on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:51AM (#8131690)
If all we're saying is it doesn't pass the "reasonable person" test, then it's not obviously illegal. Some may feel it is reasonable to communicate the terms of the non-disparagement clause you've signed to the members of your party and that it is reasonable to expect the party's sponsor to pay a fine if the members fail to adhere to the rules.

I'm not a lawyer so maybe I'm missing something obvious. I would just like some substantiation. It seems that many people have the habit of automatically declaring something they don't like to "must be illegal" simply because they strongly dislike it. That's now how law works, and that's important to understand because many people seriously underestimate the powers that the legislature holds.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by JadeNB on Monday August 04, 2014 @01:34PM (#8132966)
> If all we're saying is it doesn't pass the "reasonable person" test, then it's not obviously illegal. Some may feel it is reasonable to communicate the terms of the non-disparagement clause you've signed to the members of your party and that it is reasonable to expect the party's sponsor to pay a fine if the members fail to adhere to the rules.

I didn't claim that it was (il)legal or (un)reasonable, only that I wasn't convinced that language of this sort (where you are being held responsible for the actions of people when they are not under your immediate control) was common in contracts.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:15AM (#8131575)
> but I find it hard to believe that there are many places that think that they can fine you for the actions of other people.

There are plenty of examples of that, even in the context of hotel booking. The person who pays for a hotel will be fined if non-paying guest damage hotel furniture, for example.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by JadeNB on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:19AM (#8131592)
Agreed—I meant to be more precise about the kinds of behaviour that you (the contract-signer) can be expected to monitor. I have updated my post accordingly.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by nmjohn on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:26AM (#8131397)
Because it is extorting guests into not leaving bad reviews online - regardless of service. I'm not really sure how one would think this is okay!
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:27AM (#8131400)
It's not extorting if they are clear about these terms before you decide to book the hotel.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by nmjohn on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:35AM (#8131437)
Yet it is.

When you attend a wedding, you have absolutely no say in the venue. Yes, the bride and groom may have agreed to the terms, but the attendees did not have a choice.

So if they get shitty service and want to post a review about it online, they find out doing so will cost the bride and groom $500. It might not be clear cut extortion - but it is not an acceptable business practice.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:59AM (#8131516)
The attendees did not have a choice on the venue, but they are not bound to any contract and do not get fined if they post reviews.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by zaphar on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:41AM (#8131657)
That's like saying it's not extortion if I threaten your friend unless you do what I say. The Bride and Groom are threatened with a fine unless their attendees do what the hotel says.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @02:38PM (#8133317)
That's not at all analogous. The bride and groom are "threatened" because they're the ones that signed the contract.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by zaphar on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:43PM (#8134925)
The legality of the contract is up in the air.

Just because I sign a contract saying I agree to pay $1 everytime someone I know says something unkind to anyone doesn't mean the contract is enforceable.

Besides I don't think the he meant extortion in the legal sense but more the moral sense.

Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by chrisbennet on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:38AM (#8131644)
Read it more closely and you will see that, yes, the guest will not get fined, but the bride and groom will have $500 per bad review removed from their deposit.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by vonmoltke on Monday August 04, 2014 @10:40AM (#8131921)
You are correct, it is not extortion. It's blackmail.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @02:39PM (#8133319)
It's neither.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by ctdonath on Monday August 04, 2014 @10:32AM (#8131885)
By the time you get around to reading all the fine print, you're pretty mentally committed to signing. If your bride-to-be has her heart set on the quaint old hotel, is already buying decorations to match, telling people the preliminary plans (and they're starting to book in advance), etc ... and then you get down thru the fine print, about to seal the deal, and you see an absurd "you'll be charged $500 for each negative review by people you don't control", are you REALLY going to walk away from the deal? Really?
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by personZ on Monday August 04, 2014 @12:19PM (#8132508)
Fine print? It's on the page for "Events & Weddings", and will absolutely be the first thing most people considering this venue will read. It looks like they removed it, but any notion that this was fine print or hidden away is just dishonest misrepresentation.
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by chris_wot on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:57AM (#8131712)
Because they are asking you to police the comments of a third party who posts an opinion you may not have and you may not be able to convince to remove the post?
Re:Hotel fines $500 for every bad review posted online by sigzero on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:25AM (#8131605)
Maybe. I don't see how it is right for anyone to be "fined" for giving their opinion.