Re:Ask HN: Is it reasonable to cover your webCam?
by yepnopemaybe on Sunday August 03, 2014 @12:48AM
(#8127059)
I have heard various FBI/CIA/NSA whistleblowers talk about this issue, so I don't think that the statement is inflammatory or misleading. Thanks.
Re:Ask HN: Is it reasonable to cover your webCam?
by hrrsn on Monday August 04, 2014 @06:55AM
(#8131100)
> Remember that a hibernating system is actually in a low power state
Not the original quote. The quote was "even if your device is turned off", which I take to mean 'shutdown -h now'. Nowhere is hibernation mentioned.
If your EFI/preboot environment is rooted by a three letter agency you have more problems than someone getting your picture.
Re:Ask HN: Is it reasonable to cover your webCam?
by dredmorbius on Monday August 04, 2014 @01:06PM
(#8132779)
Assessing whether or not an "off" device is truly "off" isn't trivial. That's a big part of my point.
I do suspect that running a camera would generate sufficient power draw that you'd tend to notice, though hibernating and taking periodic snapshots might be much harder to detect.
For the casual user, distinguishing a down-disabled device from one that's got a slight charge trickling through it, especially if it happens to be connected to a charger, is going to be easy to get wrong.
Remember that a hibernating system is actually in a low power state, but there's still some draw. This means that specific processes might be running.
Baseboard / preboot / bootloader and other execution environments, including even running within the firmware of specific peripherals, is a concern I've been aware of since ~2005, from people who are taken exceptionally seriously in the security community. Context was a presentation following an RSA conference and Intel's plans at the time for extensive baseboard/preboot environments (which have largely failed to take hold on consumer hardware, though many/most server systems now have same).
Do I think the risk is high? No. But it's nonzero.