The point of the article is that the only losers are the ones who try to do anything tangible that requires a collection of patented ideas to function.
So sure, a company building a battery has a good chance of coming up with an enforceable patent. But given thousands of people trying to patent battery-ish ideas and many that aren't immediately related to batteries, the odds favour one of them coming up with something that receives a patent and is vaguely related to whatever the battery manufacturer is doing.
Remember, a patent is a sword but not a shield. Just because you patent an idea and make something with that idea, you cannot assume that nobody else has a patent that applies to your "patented" idea. They may have patented some other part of the process for manufacturing your "invention" or they may have a patent for an underlying component of your process even though you have patented a novel way to apply their patented idea.
Please let go of the idea that patenting something is a license to actually do something tangible with your idea. It is not: It is actually a license to interfere with other people doing something with your idea.
This is why nonobviousness was supposed to be a criterion for granting patents, and why we're all worse off now that the USPTO has effectively abandoned it.
(a) if your broad claims and best-known-mode are insufficient to instruct someone as to how to build a battery, your patent won't matter, and
(b) just because you patent a 40-hour-battery concept doesn't mean you've patented the concept of a 40-hour battery. Every aspect of battery design that you didn't document and claim in your patent is itself patentable. You can patent technology that you yourself cannot build because of other overlapping patents.
Unfortunately, while that's how it was supposed to work, that's not how it does work.
Amazon's "one-click" patent is an obvious case in point: they own the idea of executing an Internet shopping transaction with a single mouse click. No matter how divergent your implementation is from theirs (and to be fair to Amazon, Barnes & Nobles' implementation wasn't very divergent) they effectively own the core idea and, by extension, any work you put into it.
It's utterly impossible to argue that this state of affairs encourages progress in the useful arts and sciences, or otherwise benefits society in any way.
Of course, if I could brush my teeth on the Internet, I can see how that might be different.
While the idea of one-click ordering is obvious, it takes some nontrivial business infrastructure to make it safe and robust. You need to be able to consolidate separate orders placed within a brief timeframe, you need to allow your customers to view and edit their existing orders and fix accidental ones without human intervention... and probably most important, you need to be large and well-known enough to be trusted by your customers to retain the financial and personal information needed to execute one-click orders.
The idea was indeed a ballsy one, and it took some real work on Amazon's part to make it happen successfully. But it was still an obvious idea, it wasn't the least bit creative, and it didn't deserve patent protection.
Hard work on my part shouldn't, by itself, entitle me to stop you from doing the same.
But from what I understand, from being involved in several patent filings, you can't just patent an idea. You have to patent an enablement of an idea. A patent that can't be used by someone skilled in the applicable arts to implement the patented concept isn't supposed to be defensible.
Commenters on this post repeatedly argue that engineers do all the real, hard work, and that the ideas themselves are trivial. That's probably true. But all that hard work is also patentable; if I'm dumb enough to file for "40 hour batteries", and you file for the chemical process that makes 40-hour batteries work without melting through the floor, you win, right?