News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nathan Myhrvold’s Evil Genius by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @11:57PM (#812508)
This implies that you can, sitting at a table with a pint, come up with the key patentable ideas for the 40 hour batteries. The odds rather favor the people building batteries in earnest, don't they?
Re:Nathan Myhrvold’s Evil Genius by raganwald on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @12:31AM (#812548)
No, because this is not a case of A vs. B. It's A vs. all the Bs, Cs, Ds, &c patenting stuff.

So sure, a company building a battery has a good chance of coming up with an enforceable patent. But given thousands of people trying to patent battery-ish ideas and many that aren't immediately related to batteries, the odds favour one of them coming up with something that receives a patent and is vaguely related to whatever the battery manufacturer is doing.

Remember, a patent is a sword but not a shield. Just because you patent an idea and make something with that idea, you cannot assume that nobody else has a patent that applies to your "patented" idea. They may have patented some other part of the process for manufacturing your "invention" or they may have a patent for an underlying component of your process even though you have patented a novel way to apply their patented idea.

Please let go of the idea that patenting something is a license to actually do something tangible with your idea. It is not: It is actually a license to interfere with other people doing something with your idea.

Re:Nathan Myhrvold’s Evil Genius by CamperBob on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @12:18AM (#812530)
In the modern patent business, the "odds" favor the first party to encounter a particular problem in their field of art. If you're lucky enough to encounter a problem first, you can patent the first obvious solution(s) that come to mind, and effectively own the field later.

This is why nonobviousness was supposed to be a criterion for granting patents, and why we're all worse off now that the USPTO has effectively abandoned it.

Re:Nathan Myhrvold’s Evil Genius by tptacek on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @12:20AM (#812533)
If the "non-obvious" battery implementation is better, you can build and patent it no matter what me and raganwald come up with at the pub.
Re:Nathan Myhrvold’s Evil Genius by CamperBob on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @01:21AM (#812581)
But if it relies on your patent as prior art, I still have to cough up the baksheesh.