This is why counterfeit money is so bad - it's literally forging a debt of the government that never existed (essentially forging the government's name on a contract that says "I promise to pay the holder of this note $1" when they never did).
Anytime a dollar bill is inadvertently destroyed, this is equivalent to the creditor forgiving the government's debt. This is a form of seigniorage[0][1].
The USD is the currency of choice for many black market transactions across the world. These transactions are usually conducted in cash, and the cash is oftentimes stockpiled (kept in cash instead of deposited into banks) or used for other black market transactions. In many cases, very little (if any) makes its way back into the domestic legal market.
"Free loan" is a little hyperbolic, but it's a way of saying that the US has a number of overseas creditors who are unlikely to either demand that the US make good on its debt or sell that debt to someone who will. It increases the demand for USD internationally, which allows the US to print more USD[2] without any (or most) of the normal consequences of issuing debt.
There's a body of academic literature that goes into the impact of black market transactions on monetary policy. I'm running out the door so I can't look for it, but if you're interested it should be easy to find (though a lot of it may be paywalled by JSTOR and the like).
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seignorage
[2] Sidenote, but this is why protests in which people burn dollar bills (OccupyWallStreet was one, though there are others) are so ironic - they're simply giving free money to the government, which is someties the exact opposite of what they are trying to convey with the protest.
[2] Here I use the term "print" both figuratively and literally, unlike before
As it is, it is a debt to repay $1 for each $1 bill. You might well ask, $1 of what? Since the government doesn't produce anything, it is a strange kind of debt.
$1 of tax-forgiveness is one answer. $1 of whatever our citizens produce is another answer. This 2nd answer is the reason why the demise of the dollar as the world currency (aka wealth reserve function) could lead to hyperinflation in the USA as all those foreign-held dollars come flooding back, looking for something domestic to buy.
As long as the dollar is legal tender within the USA, foreign "creditors" (in the sense used in the above comments) can always get something back (however debased in value).
If like Brazil and Argentina, the USA defaults and creates a new currency (it'll never happen, right?) then good luck to all the drug-dealers of the world trying to cash in their old greenbacks.
<edit: phrasing!>
This is an interesting and often overlooked aspect of monetary policy in the US.
In the US, we are used to the dollar being the single currency domestically for virtually all domestic transactions, and even used to it being used abroad (which extends our purchasing power greatly) as well as in most black market transactions (which essentially acts as a free loan to the government).
It makes monetary policy changes that much more effective, because there is no other currency to compete with directly (not by fiat, as in Argentina, but by custom).
If alternative currencies like Bitcoin take off, the US government will have a very strong incentive to regulate them directly or manipulate them indirectly, because their very presence and widespread use would weaken the ability of the government to use monetary policy as an economic tool.